Garden centre with a café and gift shop in the East Midlands, busiest from March to August. 60 staff; turnover £4,200,000, of which £3,100,000 on cards.
Verdict: Ask Present bank to match, or move: card takings (Card processor quotation), international payments (Online business bank quotation), saving £11,720 a year; moving costs £2,500 one-off, paid back in 3 months. Move idle cash to savings: £6,825 a year before tax. Ask Present bank to match the rest too: £2,587 a year. Find out why £300 was charged above today's prices. Relationship: Weak (45%).
The cheapest single step is to take the card processor's and online bank's quotations to Present bank and ask it to match them: if it does, the saving comes with no disruption; if not, both moves pay for themselves within months. Moving the main account and overdraft would save a further £2,587 a year but takes nearly two years to repay the cost of moving, and lenders usually want the main account, so those two should move together or not at all.
| Area | Now | Cheapest quotation | Its cost | Saving a year | Cost of moving | Payback |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bank account | £8,006 | High-street bank quotation | £6,269 | £1,737 | £3,000 | 21 months |
| Card takings | £24,960 | Card processor quotation | £17,560 | £7,400 | £2,250 | 4 months |
| International payments | £5,460 | Online business bank quotation | £1,140 | £4,320 | £250 | 1 month |
| Borrowing | £4,738 | High-street bank quotation | £3,888 | £850 | £1,800 | 26 months |
| Total | £43,164 |
An alternative counts for an area only if it prices every charge paid there. Costs of moving include exit fees from the current provider (£1,850 to end the card terminal contract early, though the unnotified rental rise in March may let the business leave without it). The high-street bank's prices may depend on moving the main account, and its overdraft price is indicative until credit-approved. A year, ex VAT, before tax.
| Charge | Area | Cost a year |
|---|---|---|
| Consumer debit cards | Card takings | £10,350 |
| Consumer credit cards | Card takings | £5,700 |
| Exchange rate margin on international payments | International payments | £4,500 |
| Cash paid in | Bank account | £4,200 |
| Business and corporate cards | Card takings | £4,200 |
At 3.25% (Business 32-day notice account, written quotation from the high-street bank, October 2026) that is £6,825 a year before tax. Two cautions: the balance falls through the autumn towards the winter overdraft, so notice must be given in time to have the money back before it is needed, ideally in stages; and deposit protection covers eligible deposits up to £120,000 per bank, so savings above that are better spread across more than one bank.
A weak relationship matters most when the business needs the bank: a bad season, a bigger overdraft in February, a guarantee to release. The quotations gathered here are worth keeping warm for that day, whatever is decided about charges.
Costs are for a normal 12 months: each charge priced from the tariff and the volumes on the statements, ex VAT and before tax. Each alternative is a written quotation and counts for an area only if it prices every charge paid there; a move counts if it saves at least £500 a year and repays its one-off cost, with exit fees, within 12 months. Quotations change, some depend on the business qualifying or on moving other areas too, and borrowing quotations are indicative until credit-approved; card prices assume the same mix of cards and leave out any charges the new provider adds unless entered. Idle cash assumes the average balance above £120,000 could sit in savings at 3.25% before tax for the 9 months a year the accounts are in credit; savings rates move with Bank Rate. The relationship score is the business's own judgement, backed by evidence. Service, branch access, borrowing appetite and how a bank behaves in a bad year are not priced; weigh them before moving.
At handover the bank would not match the quotations, so Lindale moved its card takings to the card processor from 1 December (the exit fee was waived, because the March rise in terminal rental had never been notified) and its international payments to the online bank from 1 November, and put £160,000 of idle cash into the 32-day notice account. Lindale chose the guided route. At the last session the agent was set up in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to the statements from the bank, the card processor and the online bank (its IT confirmed this before it committed). On the first Monday after each quarter end it reprices every charge from the new statements in a new dated copy of this review, runs the checks and sends the managing director a short note. It uses the rules on Inputs: £500 a year as the saving worth acting on, £120,000 kept day to day, and the 3.25% savings rate quoted. It never moves money or contacts the bank. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of Lindale's own people approving it. These events continue the fictional example.
| Date | What the agent found | Flag? | What people decided |
|---|---|---|---|
| 4 Jan 2027 | October to December, with the two moves made: the bank and card provider now cost £31,444 a year, against £43,164 at the review. The bank's tariff from 1 February adds £370 a year, below the £500 line, so it was listed, not flagged. | Note only | Nothing needed now. The managing director will raise the tariff at the bank's annual review in May. |
| 4 Jan 2027 | The card processor charged 2.5p an authorisation, not the 2p it quoted: £185 on December's statement against £148. | Flag | The accounts manager queried it. The processor refunded £37 and charged 2p from January. |
| 5 Apr 2027 | The bank set the overdraft renewal fee for May at £2,000, up £500, which meets the £500 line. | Flag | The managing director pointed the bank to the high-street bank's £1,000 quotation. The bank held the fee at £1,500 for another year. |
| 5 Jul 2027 | Idle cash over the line after the busy season: £230,000 above the £120,000 kept day to day, worth £5,606 a year before tax at the 3.25% quoted in October, and above the deposit protection for one bank. | Flag | The managing director asked for a fresh quotation (3.10% offered), moved £120,000 to the notice account and £100,000 to a second bank's notice account, and diarised notice by 1 December for the overdraft season. |
The 30-day check-in in mid November came before the first quarterly run, so Geoff and the managing director checked the set-up with a test run on the latest quarter's statements, July to September, and left the rules as they were. Geoff's upkeep ended there: the first real run, in January, and the agent, its accounts and its log were Lindale's.
What the agent added. The method is unchanged: the same spreadsheet, the same checks and the managing director's own lines. The agent made sure the charges were repriced every quarter, caught the new card processor charging above its quotation in its first month, and put the overdraft fee rise in front of a person before the renewal. It also caught the cash building up again in the busy season, when the review's one-off move would otherwise have been forgotten. Each quarterly check took reading a note instead of gathering and pricing the statements by hand (estimate). The months after add nothing to the figures above.
Fictional and labelled: these events continue the worked example. The same events are the sample rows in the Agent log of the worked-example spreadsheet. The agent is part of the guided and done-for-you routes; the self-implement kit does not include it.