Civil engineering subcontractor: drainage, groundworks, highways and utility diversions for councils, housing associations and main contractors across the East Midlands. 85 staff; about 25 bids a year.
Verdict: The log holds 18 bids with 218 questions. Of the 20 themes asked, 16 come up in at least 30% of tenders, and 16 of those have an approved, in-date answer. Gaps: 4 to fix: Insurance (Failed a pass/fail question); KPIs and performance (Scores low; not reviewed since); Supply chain and subcontractors (Asked; no approved answer); and 1 more. 6 to watch (scored low, rewritten since). Evidence: 3 expiring, 0 expired; first: Quality management on 15 Dec 2026. Procurement basics done: 6 of 7. Case studies: 6 on the register, 4 usable now; kinds of work bid for with none usable: 1; case studies used off scope or too old on earlier bids: 13; on bids since the library: 0. Social value: 8 commitments on won contracts: 4 delivered, 1 behind; 8 reported as contract KPIs. Today 27% of questions are answered from an approved library answer; a higher share is not success on its own. Scores (direction only): Library answers none (0); written from scratch 59% (38); old copies edited 57% (64). Measured bids take 58.9 hours to write (give or take 11.1, from 9 bids on the main source), 12.0 hours per 1,000 words asked for. Measure again on 16 Apr 2027, the same way: a change under 17.5 hours could be chance, and the owner's target of 40 hours is inside the smallest change this can show (24.5 hours, 80% power), so a real change that size might not show; the re-measure months differ from the baseline's, so season can move it: measure over 12 months to compare the same months. For scale only: reaching the target would be worth £10,527 a year of writing time, against £6,200 of fee, build and upkeep. 4 uses in 3 catalogue products (3 uses in ROI products); 4 ready now. Not yet measured: fill in the Value Case after 16 Apr 2027.
Red: a gap to fix. Dark: asked in at least 30% of the 0 tenders and PQQs. Light: asked less often. Scores are shares of each question's maximum on the buyer's own scheme (0–5 with descriptors for most councils and housing associations; 0–10 on frameworks; main contractors' PQQs are pass/fail); averages show direction, not size, and none is shown from fewer than three scored answers. Insurance, financial standing and the civils certificates are pass/fail. Limits set in characters or pages are turned into words (6 characters a word, 500 words a page).
Reused against fresh (direction only): Library answers none (0); written from scratch 59% (38); old copies edited 57% (64). Before the library, reused answers were old copies; a rising share of library answers counts as success only if they score at least as well as fresh ones, so the re-measure compares the two.
| Theme | Owner | State | Evidence held | Versions (words) | Next date |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Case studies Case study | Nia R | Approved, in date | Clients' written permission and referee details for all four; completion photos | 150 · 300 · 500 | 9 Apr 2027 |
| Health and safety Policy or statement | Lauren H | Approved, in date | ISO 45001 certificate; H&S policy signed by the MD (Sept 2026); AFR and RIDDOR figures 2023–2025 | 150 · 300 · 500 | 22 Sep 2027 |
| Insurance Certificate or insurance | Dev K | Approved, in date | Broker's certificate for all policies (to 31 Jan 2027) | 150 · 300 · 500 | 1 Oct 2027 |
| Quality management Policy or statement | Lauren H | Approved, in date | ISO 9001 certificate (renewal audit booked 24 Nov 2026); sample inspection and test plan | 150 · 300 · 500 | 22 Sep 2027 |
| Financial standing Financial | Dev K | Approved, in date | Accounts to 31 March 2026 and 2025; bank reference letter (Sept 2026) | 150 · 300 · 500 | 30 Sep 2027 |
| Method statement Narrative answer | Simon T | Approved, in date | Sample traffic management plan; resident letter template; programme from LC-2610 | 150 · 300 · 500 · full 1,000 | 2 Oct 2027 |
| Environmental management Policy or statement | Lauren H | Approved, in date | ISO 14001 certificate; 2025 waste returns | 150 · 300 · 500 | 24 Sep 2027 |
| Social value Narrative answer | Gareth P | Approved, in date | Apprentice and local-hire figures 2025 (payroll); local spend from the purchase ledger; school visit log | 150 · 300 · 500 | 5 Oct 2027 |
| Equality and diversity Policy or statement | Dev K | Approved, in date | Equality policy; resident liaison procedure | 150 · 300 · 500 | 15 Sep 2027 |
| Street works qualifications (NRSWA) Certificate or insurance | Simon T | Approved, in date | Register printout of supervisors' and operatives' cards (first renewal 31 Aug 2027) | 150 · 300 · 500 | 2 Oct 2027 |
| SSIP membership Certificate or insurance | Lauren H | Approved, in date | SSIP member scheme certificate (to 30 Apr 2027) | 150 · 300 · 500 | 1 May 2027 |
| Traffic management (Chapter 8 and sector schemes) Certificate or insurance | Lauren H | Approved, in date | Sector scheme certificate (to 31 Jan 2028); operatives' cards | 150 · 300 · 500 | 2 Oct 2027 |
| KPIs and performance Narrative answer | Simon T | Approved, in date | Sample monthly KPI report | 150 · 300 · 500 | 20 Nov 2026 |
| Carbon reduction Policy or statement | Lauren H | Approved, in date | Carbon Reduction Plan (Oct 2026), signed by the MD; fuel records 2024–25 | 150 · 300 · 500 | 1 Oct 2027 |
| Mobilisation Narrative answer | Simon T | Approved, in date | Mobilisation plan from LC-2611 (won) | 150 · 300 · 500 | 7 Oct 2027 |
| Modern slavery Policy or statement | Dev K | Approved, in date | Modern slavery policy (Sept 2026); agency right-to-work audit 2026 | 150 · 300 · 500 | 15 Sep 2027 |
| Data protection Policy or statement | Dev K | Approved, in date | ICO registration (renews 12 Mar 2027); data protection policy | 150 · 300 · 500 | 16 Sep 2027 |
| Supply chain and subcontractors Narrative answer | Simon T | Draft | Subcontractor vetting form | 150 | – |
| Business continuity Policy or statement | Dev K | None | none yet | none | – |
| Cyber Essentials Certificate or insurance | Dev K | Approved, in date | Cyber Essentials certificate (to 20 May 2027) | 150 · 300 · 500 | 20 May 2027 |
Every narrative answer ends with a compulsory "for this contract" section, rewritten for each bid: the buyer, the site, the figures. The method statement holds a 1,000-word full version because tenders set limits that long. The answers themselves are in the master files named on the Library sheet.
| Case study | Kind of work | Value | Completed | Used in bids | Now |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CS-01 Sewer renewal for a district council, 1.2 km | Drainage | £640,000 | 31 Mar 2025 | 8 | Usable |
| CS-02 Estate groundworks package, 86 homes | Groundworks | £1,150,000 | 29 Nov 2024 | 5 | Usable |
| CS-03 Water main diversion for a junction scheme | Utility diversions | £420,000 | 15 Aug 2025 | 5 | Usable |
| CS-04 Emergency drainage repairs, framework year one | Emergency repairs | £380,000 | 31 Dec 2025 | 3 | Usable |
| CS-05 Highway drainage and kerbing on an A-road scheme | Highways | £520,000 | 30 Jun 2021 | 3 | Too old |
| CS-06 Surface water drainage for 40 homes | Drainage | £290,000 | 28 Feb 2023 | 4 | Too old |
Each bid now picks case studies of the same kind of work, completed within the buyer's limit (three years unless the bid says), with referee consent dated before the bid. The log shows how often that wasn't so before the library: one reason case studies scored 49%. No usable highways case study exists: that is one for the Customer Case Study Programme.
| Theme | Tenders | Average score | Gap | Action | Owner | Due |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Insurance | 15 | pass/fail only | Failed a pass/fail question | Ask the broker for a £5m professional indemnity quotation before the next PQQ that asks | Dev K | 13 Nov 2026 |
| KPIs and performance | 8 | 56% | Scores low; not reviewed since | Add how we put things right when a KPI is missed (the feedback's point) | Simon T | 6 Nov 2026 |
| Supply chain and subcontractors | 3 | 53% | Asked; no approved answer | Finish the draft and have it approved | Simon T | 20 Nov 2026 |
| Business continuity | 2 | too few | Asked; no approved answer | Write a 300-word answer from the business continuity plan | Dev K | 27 Nov 2026 |
| Case studies | 17 | 49% | Scored low; rewritten: watch the next scores | – | Nia R | – |
| Environmental management | 12 | 57% | Scored low; rewritten: watch the next scores | – | Lauren H | – |
| Social value | 12 | 37% | Scored low; rewritten: watch the next scores | – | Gareth P | – |
| Modern slavery | 7 | 47% | Scored low; rewritten: watch the next scores | – | Dev K | – |
| Mobilisation | 7 | 52% | Scored low; rewritten: watch the next scores | – | Simon T | – |
| Carbon reduction | 7 | 55% | Scored low; rewritten: watch the next scores | – | Lauren H | – |
Gaps to fix come first. "Scored low; rewritten" answers were rewritten after the feedback: watch their next scores, which tend to rise by chance anyway, so read them as direction only.
| Evidence expiring within six months | Evidence held | Expires | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quality management | ISO 9001 certificate (renewal audit booked 24 Nov 2026); sample inspection and test plan | 15 Dec 2026 | Lauren H |
| Insurance | Broker's certificate for all policies (to 31 Jan 2027) | 31 Jan 2027 | Dev K |
| Data protection | ICO registration (renews 12 Mar 2027); data protection policy | 12 Mar 2027 | Dev K |
| Procurement basics (checked 16 Oct 2026; not legal advice) | Applies | Status | Checked | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Registered on the Central Digital Platform (Find a Tender) with a unique identifier | Yes | Done | 1 Sep 2026 | Dev K |
| Core supplier information complete and declared (basic details, accounts, connected persons, exclusions) | Yes | Done | 1 Sep 2026 | Dev K |
| Social value answer mapped to each buyer's framework (PPN 002 for central government; councils' own) | Yes | Done | 5 Oct 2026 | Gareth P |
| Carbon Reduction Plan published (PPN 006) | Yes | Done | 1 Oct 2026 | Lauren H |
| Modern slavery statement or policy | Yes | Done | 15 Sep 2026 | Dev K |
| Construction pre-qualification held (Common Assessment Standard) | Yes | To do | – | Lauren H |
| Invoicing set up for the Act's 30-day payment terms (s.68) | Yes | Done | 1 Sep 2026 | Dev K |
| Bid | Commitment | Promised | Delivered | Due | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| LC-2601 | Local hires from priority postcodes | 3 people | – | Not won: nothing owed | |
| LC-2603 | Local hires from the estate's postcodes | 2 people | 2 | 30 Jun 2026 | Delivered |
| LC-2603 | Apprentice for the contract's length | 1 apprentices | 1 | 30 Apr 2026 | Delivered |
| LC-2603 | Careers sessions at a nearby school | 4 sessions | 2 | 31 Mar 2027 | In progress |
| LC-2607 | Resident drop-in session before works | 1 sessions | 1 | 15 May 2026 | Delivered |
| LC-2610 | Spend with suppliers within 30 miles | 40 % of spend | 44 | 31 May 2027 | Delivered |
| LC-2610 | Local hires | 2 people | 1 | 30 Sep 2026 | Behind |
| LC-2610 | Community volunteering days | 10 days | 6 | 31 May 2027 | In progress |
| LC-2611 | Apprentices across the framework | 2 apprentices | 1 | 31 May 2027 | In progress |
| LC-2614 | Careers sessions at local schools | 4 sessions | – | Not won: nothing owed |
A social value promise in a won bid becomes a contract KPI. Central government buyers use the Social Value Model (PPN 002); councils consider social value under the Public Services (Social Value) Act 2012 and use their own frameworks, so the library answer is mapped to each buyer's and only promises what the business can deliver.
| Date | Theme | What's due | Owner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Nov 2026 | KPIs and performance | Review | Simon T |
| 15 Dec 2026 | Quality management | Evidence expires | Lauren H |
| 31 Jan 2027 | Insurance | Evidence expires | Dev K |
| 12 Mar 2027 | Data protection | Evidence expires | Dev K |
| 9 Apr 2027 | Case studies | Review | Nia R |
| 30 Apr 2027 | SSIP membership | Evidence expires | Lauren H |
| 20 May 2027 | Cyber Essentials | Review; evidence expires | Dev K |
| 30 Jun 2027 | Health and safety | Evidence expires | Lauren H |
| 31 Aug 2027 | Street works qualifications (NRSWA) | Evidence expires | Simon T |
| 15 Sep 2027 | Modern slavery | Review | Dev K |
| 15 Sep 2027 | Equality and diversity | Review | Dev K |
| 24 Sep 2027 | Environmental management | Review | Lauren H |
| 30 Sep 2027 | Financial standing | Review | Dev K |
| 30 Sep 2027 | Carbon reduction | Evidence expires | Lauren H |
| 2 Oct 2027 | Method statement | Review | Simon T |
| 2 Oct 2027 | Traffic management (Chapter 8 and sector schemes) | Review | Lauren H |
| 5 Oct 2027 | Social value | Review | Gareth P |
| 7 Oct 2027 | Mobilisation | Review | Simon T |
| Catalogue product | What it needs from the library | Why | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tender Bid Decision ROI product | Writing hours per bid | Its bid cost is bid hours × hourly cost; the measured hours per bid replace a guess. | Ready now |
| Tender Bid Decision ROI product | Approved answers to frequent themes | With the frequent answers ready, each bid takes fewer hours, so more of the right tenders fit the hours available. | Ready now |
| Proposal Rewrite Foundation | Approved case studies | Its "Why us: a similar job" section uses the library's approved case studies, with permission held. | Ready now |
| Customer Case Study Programme ROI product | Case-study themes evaluators ask for | Shows which kinds of job tenders ask for and how the case studies scored, so it writes up the right customers. | Ready now |
Measure later. Writing hours per bid on full tenders and framework applications, from the timesheet bid code only: 58.9 hours now, from 9 bids (give or take 11.1); 2 measured bids are shown separately, not mixed in. 12.0 hours per 1,000 words asked for, across 4,894 words a bid. About 6 more measured bids should be submitted by 16 Apr 2027, counting only bids whose bid code was opened after the library was approved, so a change under 18 hours could be chance, and the smallest change this can show at 80% power is 25 hours. The owner's target of 40 hours (an assumption) is inside that. There is no comparison group, which departs from the Foundations standard: every bid uses the library. So the change is also read per 1,000 words asked for, and the re-measure is best taken over 12 months to compare the same months; the bid code started in January 2026, and booking still bedding in can push hours up. Not yet measured: fill in the Value Case after 16 Apr 2027.
For scale only: reaching the target would be worth £10,527 a year of writing time at £38 an hour, against £6,200 of fee, build and a year's upkeep. It is not a forecast; the library pays mainly through the bids it lets the team write and the Tender Bid Decision it feeds.
Questions and scores come from tender portal downloads and the bid folder for the questions; evaluators' feedback letters and assessment summaries for scores; timesheets (a bid code since January 2026) for hours, over 9 months; the log holds 96% of a year's bids. Scores are shares of each question's maximum on the buyer's own scheme; evaluators and schemes differ, so averages show direction, not size. The hours baseline rests on 9 measured bids (full tender; framework application) with hours from the main source, timesheet bid code, give or take 11.1 hours; 2 measured bids are left out (no hours, or another source). By the re-measure about 6 more should be submitted, so a change under 17.5 hours could be chance. There is no comparison group, which departs from the Foundations standard: every bid uses the library, so the change is read per 1,000 words asked for and, where possible, against the same months a year on; a bid code still bedding in can push booked hours up. The target of 40 hours is the owner's assumption, not a forecast; the £ lines price writing time only, at £38 an hour. The re-measure shows whether hours moved, not proof the library moved them. The procurement facts were checked on gov.uk and legislation.gov.uk on 16 October 2026: not legal advice.
The scores show where the team writes weakest, not why bids were won or lost: price usually decides more.
Fictional, continuing the example: Linnetford Civils, its bids and every figure here are invented, and buyers are named by type. The counts were tallied from the story, not by rerunning the workbook; seven of the agent’s log rows are on the Agent sheet of the worked-example workbook.
Linnetford chose done for you. At handover on 19 October Geoff set up the bid answer agent in Linnetford’s own account, in an AI assistant the business already uses, with its IT’s agreement: connected read-only to the bids folder, the library’s master copies, the certificates folder and the timesheet bid codes, and writing only to the workbook and a shared drafts document in each bid’s folder. Before it ran, Linnetford updated its privacy notice, because case studies name clients and referees. The thresholds are on Inputs: the first draft within 2 working days of the bid code opening (B36), the answers with the approver 3 working days before the deadline (B37), and evidence flagged 6 months before it expires (B16). The run details are on the Agent sheet: Nia R reads the note, and Gareth P signs off every bid and every change to a library answer. The agent drafted; the lead writers wrote every “for this contract” section and a person uploaded every bid. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it. The agent’s first tender was LC-2619, whose bid code opened on 22 October, so the check-in was 30 days after that, on Monday 23 November: Geoff went through the log with Nia R and Gareth P, on screen in Linnetford’s account, and his upkeep of the set-up ended there.
| Date | What the agent prepared or flagged | Approved or decided by | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 19 Oct 2026 Flag | Quality management The ISO 9001 certificate expires on 15 December, inside the 6 months’ warning; renewal audit booked for 24 November. | Lauren H | Kept the audit; the old certificate left out of any bid due after 15 December. New certificate filed on 1 December. |
| 23 Oct 2026 Draft | LC-2619 (council drainage tender) 15 questions listed with limits and marking; 13 drafted from approved answers at the right length, pass/fail first, each narrative answer ending in a blank “for this contract” section. | Nia R | First draft ready a day after the bid code opened. She wrote the tailored sections. |
| 23 Oct 2026 Flag | LC-2619 (council drainage tender) Supply chain asked, with no approved answer; only one drainage case study within the buyer’s three years. | Nia R | Wrote the supply chain answer, approved into the library on 6 November. Used CS-01 alone; the gap logged for the Customer Case Study Programme. |
| 9 Nov 2026 Draft | LC-2619 (council drainage tender) Sign-off due, 3 working days before the deadline; social value within what the register shows delivered. | Gareth P | Signed off on 10 November; submitted by Nia R on 11 November. |
| 13 Nov 2026 Draft | LC-2615 (mini-competition) Won: scores and feedback filled from the assessment summary for checking. | Simon T | Checked. The two commitments promised went on the Social Value register with owners. |
| 30 Nov 2026 Flag | Social value: LC-2610 local hires Behind: 2 promised by 30 September, 1 delivered. | Gareth P | Second hire starts 11 January; the next KPI report says so. |
| 7 Dec 2026 Flag | LC-2621 (main contractor PQQ) A pass/fail question asks for £5m professional indemnity; the library holds £2m, which failed on LC-2609. | Gareth P | Withdrew at the go or no-go. Cover to be raised at the April renewal. |
The other two bids drafted were a housing association tender and a framework application in December; the fourth, the main contractor’s PQQ LC-2621, was withdrawn at the go or no-go on 7 December and not drafted. The two December bids’ writing hours are on the bid code for the early read on 14 January 2027, counted the same way as the baseline. A rising share of answers from the library is not success on its own: the scores of library answers are compared with fresh ones as results arrive, and the first, LC-2619, is not due until January. Reading the note and checking the agent’s question rows took Nia R about 20 minutes a week (estimate). The months after add nothing to the value case above.