Buyer Journey Gap Analysis · October 2026

Penhallow Kitchen Ventilation Ltd

Design, installation and maintenance of commercial kitchen extraction and ventilation for restaurants, schools and care homes in the South West. 55 staff.

Worked example. Penhallow Kitchen Ventilation and its figures are fictional. All figures come from the worked-example spreadsheet: ALL CHECKS PASSED (with 3 notes).
The headline

10 of 12 buyer questions have no good answer, and they cost deals

First-year net
£40,750
£45,720 in year one for £4,970 all in; £22,843 if the pieces save half as much
A year once live
£60,960
about 12 deals saved, capped by capacity; win rate 40% to 44%
Lost deals
89
of 180 last year where a gap was a reason
Sales time
33 h
freed a year, not counted as money

Verdict: 12 buyer questions, 10 with no answer or a weak one (Awareness 1 · Consideration 3 · Decision 6 · After purchase 0). They were a reason in about 89 of the 180 deals lost last year. 9 planned pieces (£4,970 all in) should save about 12.0 deals a year (capped by what can be delivered), taking the win rate from 40% to 44% and adding £60,960 of gross profit a year; £45,720 in the first year, a net of £40,750 (payback 4 months). If the pieces save half as much, the first-year net is £22,843. Most is at stake on “How do you compare with buying from a catering equipment supplier?” Sales should also get back about 33 hours a year. 1 gap has nothing planned yet.

Where buyers get stuck

Most gaps are at the decision stage

Awareness1 of 1 unanswered or weakConsideration3 of 3 unanswered or weakDecision6 of 7 unanswered or weakAfter purchase0 of 1 unanswered or weak
Question by question

Most at stake first

QuestionLost deals a yearAnswer nowPlanned pieceGross profit a year, before the cap
How do you compare with buying from a catering equipment supplier?
Consideration · sales team · asked 50 times a year
18NoneComparison page: supply only against design and install£22,860
How much will it cost for a kitchen our size?
Consideration · sales team · asked 160 times a year
25NonePrice guide with typical ranges by kitchen size£19,050
How long will the kitchen be closed for the installation?
Decision · lost-deal review · asked 70 times a year
14NoneInstallation day by day, with two case studies£10,668
Is a cheaper canopy just as good?
Consideration · lost-deal review · asked 45 times a year
20WeakVideo: what's inside a canopy£7,620
Can you show us a similar kitchen you've done?
Decision · sales team · asked 110 times a year
12WeakSix case studies by kind of kitchen£4,572
Can we pay for it over time?
Decision · sales team · asked 35 times a year
8*NoneFinance options page£3,048
What does maintenance cost each year?
Decision · sales team · asked 60 times a year
5NoneMaintenance plan page with prices£2,540
Will it pass the environmental health officer's inspection?
Decision · customer interview · asked 40 times a year
6WeakInspection checklist£2,286
Do we need a gas interlock, and which regulations apply?
Awareness · search data · asked 90 times a year
4WeakRewrite the regulations guide£1,524
What happens if the extraction isn't strong enough after fitting?
Decision · customer interview · asked 25 times a year
2Nonenothing planned–
Do you handle the fire-suppression system too?
Decision · sales team · asked 30 times a year
3Good––
How often must the ductwork be cleaned?
After purchase · search data · asked 80 times a year
0Good––

* An estimate from the sales team, counted at half. Gross profit per question is before the capacity cap and includes £600 of later maintenance work per customer: Penhallow can fit about 12 more installations a year, so that is all that’s counted in total. The comparison page is credited with saving a quarter of its lost deals and the maintenance page a tenth, against 15% for the rest. Publishing typical prices helps buyers rule themselves in or out; competitors will see them too, so give ranges, not a price list.

How confident are we?

What this rests on

The questions come from the sales team, lost-deal reviews, customers and search data; the lost deals where each was a reason, from the business’s records (estimates count 50%). A gap counts in full if there’s no answer, 50% if the answer is weak; reasons are scaled down if they add up to more than the 180 deals lost. A good answer is taken to save 15% of those deals, capped at 12 extra jobs a year, each worth the first order × margin plus £600 of later work, starting 3 months from now. Costs include 2 internal hours a piece. Sales hours freed are shown, not counted as money. Better content’s effect on enquiries, and quoting time saved on buyers who rule themselves out, are not counted.

Record why each deal is lost from now on, and ask the sales team which pieces they sent; re-run in a year.

The months after

What the agent gathered, and what people decided

Fictional and illustrative. This continues the worked example from the fieldwork in September 2026 to January 2027. Every name and figure is invented.

Penhallow set up the question agent in its own accounts at the start of the project: its AI assistant, the enquiry inbox, the CRM and Search Console, all read-only. The rules are on Inputs, rows 25 to 29. Kerensa Pascoe, the sales manager, confirmed every question it matched or proposed; Martin Penrose, the managing director, approved and sent every call invitation. During the project it collated the sales team's and search questions and drafted the call invitations; people ran the calls. After handover it read new enquiries and lost deals each Monday. It records the question and the reason, never who asked. The signed-off plan is unchanged; the agent fills a working copy for the October 2027 re-run.

Lost-deal reasons recorded
43 of 45
38 at the time, 5 after a call; recorded reasons count in full at the re-run, estimates only 50%
Enquiries read
112
64 questions matched to the list, each confirmed
New questions added
1
after it came up 3 times
Call invitations sent
10
7 calls, run by people; one buyer asked not to be contacted
DateWhat the agent foundDecided byWhat they decided
21 Sep 2026Candidate questions from four weeks of forwarded sales emails and a year of Search Console queries: 8 distinct questions after merging repeats
Sales inbox folder 'Buyer questions'; Search Console
Kerensa PascoeKerensa confirmed all 8, put two into buyers' own words and added how often each is asked.
22 Sep 2026Call invitations drafted for 6 lost buyers and 5 recent customers
CRM: deals lost and won since April 2026; Do not contact list
Martin PenroseMartin held one (a customer with an open complaint) and sent 10 on 23 Sep. Four lost buyers and three customers took a call; Kerensa ran them.
29 Sep 2026A lost buyer asked not to be contacted again
Reply in Martin's mailbox, 28 Sep
Martin PenroseAdded to Do not contact the same day. No reminder drafted; never to be invited again.
2 Nov 2026October enquiries: 38; 21 questions matched to the list (cost 9, closure time 5, similar kitchen 4, finance 3); one new question asked twice
Enquiry inbox and CRM notes; Questions sheet
Kerensa PascoeMatches confirmed. The new question, 'Can you fit it overnight so we don't close?', is held until it comes up 3 times (Inputs B27).
30 Nov 2026Deals lost in November: 16, of which 4 with no reason recorded (25%, above the 20% on Inputs B28)
CRM lost deals
Martin PenroseMartin asked the estimators to record the reason the day a deal is lost. Three reasons were added after a call; the reasons are copied exactly as recorded.
7 Dec 2026New question reached 3 times: 'Can you fit it overnight so we don't close?'
Enquiries of 3 Nov, 18 Nov and 2 Dec
Kerensa PascoeAdded to the working copy for the re-run (Decision stage, Sales team, content None). The installation day-by-day page will answer it.
4 Jan 2027Price guide live since 8 Dec: recorded as sent on 6 quotations; 2 won, 1 lost, 3 open
CRM field 'Piece sent'
Martin PenroseToo few to compare. Keep recording; compared at the October 2027 re-run.

Nothing reached a buyer that Martin hadn't read and sent himself, and the agent never changed a recorded reason. The flag on unrecorded reasons in November changed a habit: by January almost every lost deal had its reason recorded the same day. One new question, about fitting overnight so the kitchen needn't close, came up three times and was added for the re-run. The price guide has been sent on a handful of quotations; it is far too early to compare win rates. Kerensa spent about 15 minutes a week confirming matches (estimate). The October 2027 re-run starts with a year of questions and lost-deal reasons already gathered, from records rather than estimates.