CNC machining, fabrication and assembly of parts and sub-assemblies for equipment makers in agriculture, food processing, rail, medical devices and packaging machinery, from one site in Staffordshire. 84 staff.
Verdict: The board has 8 members from 7 segments. 13 of 13 sections written; agreed 30 Jun 2026 by managing director and the chair. 1 held, 3 in the first year against 3 a year set; next on 4 Feb 2027. You said, we did: 9 recommendations and issues raised; 6 answered (5 acted on, 1 declined with the reason), 3 under review, 0 with no response yet. Main measures now: decisions tested with customers first, before the board 2 of 13 (15%, give or take 21 points); since the first meeting 1 of 2 (too few for a rate); members' issues resolved within 30 days, before the board 16 of 26 (62%, give or take 18 points); other customers 67%; since the first meeting 1 of 1 (too few for a rate); recommendations answered within 90 days, none old enough to judge yet (9 raised, the oldest under 90 days). At 7 decisions by the re-measure, the decisions measure can only show a change of about 57 points or more, so read it as direction and read the counts. Members' spend kept is 99% (give or take 5 points) against 101% for other existing customers: a direction only. Read again on 10 Dec 2026 and 10 Mar 2027, the same way; spend on 16 Oct 2027. The first year costs £12,306 in full (£8,526 cash, including outside advisers and VAT you can't reclaim). Not yet measured: fill in the Value Case after 10 Mar 2027.
Last year's sales by customer; dark for high-value members, grey for middle, light for lower or not serving. The two makers that compete directly with a member (agricultural and food equipment) are on reserve rather than in the room: competitors round one table risk sharing prices or plans, which the CMA warns against. Every member signed short mutual confidentiality terms (drafted by the company's solicitor), declared their own competitors, products and any conflict, and confirmed their employer agrees; the NHS member recorded the conflict with the trust, as public buyers must identify conflicts (Procurement Act 2023 s81). Terms run 12 to 24 months, so they end at different times. The NHS member follows the trust's own gifts and hospitality policy, so receives no thank-you; the others receive £40 a year, within the £50 policy in the charter.
Thirteen sections, each written in plain words and agreed before the first meeting: purpose (the three questions), membership, meetings (each ending with members alone with the chair), what it isn't (not a sales meeting: no selling, no prices, no discount for members), confidentiality (we may share our own figures; members never share their own sensitive information with each other), competition law (the board agrees nothing collectively, least of all on prices), our commitments (an answer to everything within 90 days), members' commitments (employer agreement, their own competitors and conflicts declared), thank-you and expenses, the chair, ideas members contribute (no ownership claims), personal data and review. The chair is an independent non-executive, a retired operations director with no part in selling. The full charter is in the example's board documents.
| Date | Status | Theme | Members | Items raised | Venue and travel |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 10 Sep 2026 | Held in person | What would make you put more of your work with us, and what stops you now? | 7 | 9 | £1,200 |
| 4 Feb 2027 | Planned video | Price rises: how you want them explained and how much notice you need | – | 0 | £0 |
| 10 Jun 2027 | Planned in person | Where we should invest next: larger five-axis work, kitting or finishing | – | 0 | £1,330 |
Each meeting takes one of the three purpose questions. The first had pre-reads nine days ahead, notes in five days and the "you said, we did" report on 14 October 2026. 7 places taken of 8.
| What they said | Our answer | Owner | Feeds |
|---|---|---|---|
| Certificates of conformity arrive days after the parts, so parts sit in quarantine Rail vehicle refurbisher · issue · service | Acted on Certificates now emailed on dispatch and packed with the parts | Quality manager | Customer Experience Map |
| Give a firm delivery date at order acknowledgement, not "week commencing" Several members · recommendation · service | Acted on Firm dates on every acknowledgement from November, once the planning system change is in | Operations manager | Customer Experience Map |
| Offer kitting and sub-assembly so we order one part number, not twelve Packaging machinery maker · recommendation · product | Acted on A trial with two members, first kits delivered by 4 December, priced per kit | Managing director | Value Proposition and Messaging |
| The £150 minimum order charge makes small repeat orders uneconomic Forklift attachment maker · recommendation · pricing | Declined with reason The charge covers machine set-up; repeat parts can go on a stocking agreement instead, with no minimum | Managing director | Price Rise Plan |
| Explain price rises with the cost figures behind them, and give three months' notice Several members · recommendation · pricing | Under review Being worked through; answer by 30 November, before the January price review is decided | Finance director | Price Rise Plan |
| Show how your total cost compares with offshore machining once inspection and freight are included Medical imaging equipment maker · recommendation · product | Under review Comparison being built on three recent quotations; answer by 4 December | Sales manager | Competitive Positioning Map |
| A named contact in the planning office for each customer Agricultural machinery maker (Shropshire) · recommendation · service | Acted on Each customer now has a named planner, on every acknowledgement | Operations manager | Customer Experience Map |
| Long parts arrive bent because the packaging is too light Scientific instrument maker · issue · service | Acted on Parts over a metre now go in crates | Dispatch supervisor | None |
| Add capacity for larger five-axis parts Food processing equipment maker · recommendation · product | Under review Being weighed with next year's investment plan; members told the answer and the timetable by 4 December, before the plan is decided in March | Managing director | Investment Priorities Plan |
Every item has an owner and an answer: acted on, or declined with the reason, told to members in the report. Items still under review are due by 4 December, inside the 90 days, and before the business decides: the price-rise explanation by 30 November, ahead of the January price review; the five-axis answer before the investment plan in March. Nothing is yet 90 days old, so the answered-in-time rate starts at the early read.
| Date | Decision (from the management minutes) | Kind | Tested first? | Period |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 14 Oct 2025 | Raise the hourly machining rate by 6% from 1 January | Pricing | No | before |
| 11 Nov 2025 | Quote a firm four-week lead time for repeat parts | Service | No | before |
| 9 Dec 2025 | Introduce a £150 minimum order charge | Pricing | No | before |
| 13 Jan 2026 | Offer kitting and sub-assembly as a service | Service | Yes interviews | before |
| 10 Feb 2026 | Buy a second five-axis machining centre | Product or capability | No | before |
| 10 Mar 2026 | Send zinc plating out instead of doing it in-house | Service | No | before |
| 10 Mar 2026 | Add an annual price review linked to a steel cost index | Pricing | No | before |
| 14 Apr 2026 | Run a Saturday morning shift for urgent work | Service | No | before |
| 12 May 2026 | Make first-article inspection reports standard on new parts | Service | Yes trial with customers | before |
| 9 Jun 2026 | Offer stocking agreements for repeat parts | Service | No | before |
| 9 Jun 2026 | Offer laser marking of part numbers | Product or capability | No | before |
| 14 Jul 2026 | Charge carriage on orders under £500 | Pricing | No | before |
| 11 Aug 2026 | Promise quotations within 48 hours | Service | No | before |
| 22 Sep 2026 | Give a firm delivery date at order acknowledgement | Service | Yes advisory board | since |
| 13 Oct 2026 | Cut the Christmas shutdown from ten working days to five | Service | No | since |
A decision is what the definition on Inputs says: a change to what is sold, how it is delivered or what it costs, agreed in the minutes. The chair scored the minutes from copies with dates removed, old and new mixed, and will do the same at the re-measure. The £150 minimum order charge, the 6% rate rise and carriage on small orders were all decided without asking a customer; at the first meeting members raised two of them.
| Main measure | Before the board | Since the first meeting (so far) | Background |
|---|---|---|---|
| Decisions tested with customers first | 2 of 13 (15% ± 21) | 1 of 2 (too few) | – |
| Recommendations and issues answered within 90 days | no board yet | 6 of 9 answered; none 90 days old yet | charter: all of them |
| Members' issues resolved within 30 days | 16 of 26 (62% ± 18) | 1 of 1 (too few) | other customers 39 of 58 (67%) |
Every measure starts at the board's own start, the first meeting on 10 September 2026: the baseline is the 12 months before it, from the same sources each time. At about 6 decisions by the re-measure, only a change of about 57 points in the share tested first could be shown reliably (80% power); the owner's target of 50% is closer than that, so this measure shows direction and the counts matter. Members' issues were resolved a little less often than other customers' before the board (62% against 67%); the re-measure nets members' change against other customers' from the same log.
| Members against the candidates not on the board | Members | Reserves and decliners |
|---|---|---|
| Issues resolved within 30 days, before the board | 16 of 26 (62%) | 6 of 8 (75%) |
| Spend kept, last 12 months ÷ the 12 before | 99% ± 5 | 110% ± 10 |
The rail refurbisher was invited partly because of late certificates, a problem the issues measure counts, so its issues may fall back by chance: without it, members resolved 70% (14 of 20). The reserves and decliners resolved more of their few issues and grew their spend faster, so the members are not a flattering sample. And if members' issues get attention at other customers' expense, netting off the others' change would count the gain twice: read the members' change on its own as well.
| Direction only | Members' accounts | Other existing customers |
|---|---|---|
| Spend kept, last 12 months ÷ the 12 before | 99% ± 5 | 101% |
| Accounts kept | 8 of 8 | – |
Direction only. With eight accounts, one order won or lost moves spend kept more than any board could. For scale only, reaching the owner's assumed 104% would be worth £67,057 a year in gross profit, and keeping one member account of median size £183,400; neither is a forecast.
| First year | £ |
|---|---|
| Chair's fees (3 meetings, from the chair's quotation) | £1,950 |
| Venue and catering | £1,630 |
| Members' travel at cost | £900 |
| Thank-yous (within the £50 policy; none for the NHS member) | £280 |
| Consultant's fee | £3,000 |
| Solicitor for the confidentiality terms (quotation) | £400 |
| Accountant for the VAT, gifts and payroll points (quotation) | £150 |
| Employer NIC on the chair's fees (paid through payroll; under the £5,000 threshold) | £0 |
| VAT on food and drink that can't be reclaimed | £216 |
| Cash | £8,526 |
| Team time (84 hours at £45) | £3,780 |
| In full | £12,306 |
Members give about five hours a meeting, 120 hours a year between them: their time is theirs and is not costed, but the invitation says how much it is.
| Catalogue product | What it needs from the board | Items in the Log so far |
|---|---|---|
| Value Proposition and Messaging | Why members put work with us and what stops them, in their own words, and their view of new services such as kitting | 1 |
| Price Rise Plan | How members want price changes explained and how much notice they need, heard together before the January review | 2 |
| Customer Experience Map | The moments members say go wrong between order and invoice: acknowledgements, certificates, packaging | 3 |
| Competitive Positioning Map | Who members compare us with, including offshore machining, and on what | 1 |
| Investment Priorities Plan | What members say they would bring to us if we added capacity or new processes | 1 |
Decisions come from the management meeting minutes, issues from the quality and complaints log and sales from the sales ledger, each to be read the same way again. Every measure starts at the first meeting (10 Sep 2026): the baseline is the 12 months before it. The decisions baseline is 13 decisions, so the share has a give or take of 21 points and only a change of about 57 points could be shown reliably by the re-measure; the counts matter more than the percentage. Decisions are those meeting the fixed definition on Inputs, scored blind (dates hidden) by the chair, the same way both times. Members' issues are 26 before the board against 58 for other customers and 8 for the candidates not on the board, from the same log; a change there shows direction, not proof that the board caused it, and if members' issues get attention at others' expense, netting off the others' change counts the gain twice. 1 member was invited because of a problem this measure counts, so it is also shown without them. Spend kept compares 8 members' accounts over two 12-month periods, give or take 5 points, so it is direction only. The targets (50% of decisions tested first, 104% spend kept) are the owner's assumptions; gross profit is estimated from the margin for 3 members; team hours are the owner's estimates and members' time is shown but not costed. The products the board Unlocks measure their own results.
Fictional, continuing the example; the log is on the Agent sheet of the worked-example workbook, and the months after add nothing to the figures above.
Wraxholme took the guided route. At handover on 23 October 2026 the managing director and Geoff set up the agent together, in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to the board's folder on the shared drive (the workbook, the owners' written updates and the chair's notes) and to the shared calendar; Wraxholme's IT confirmed the connections beforehand. Before it ran, the company updated its privacy notice, and the charter's section on personal data already said what is kept and who sees it; the notes stay in Wraxholme's own files. Every Monday it checks each open item on the Log against its due date and the 90-day promise, and warns 14 days ahead (the managing director's setting on Inputs). It drafts each meeting's pack 14 days before the pre-reads are due, and the "you said, we did" updates from the owners' written answers, all into one shared drafts document. The chair agrees each agenda; the managing director approves every draft and sends each one. It never writes to a member, never puts prices or one member's own information in a pack, and never scores the minutes: the chair does that, blind. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it.
| Date | What the agent prepared or flagged, and the evidence | Kind | Approved or decided by | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 26 Oct 2026 | Firm delivery dates at acknowledgement (due 30 Oct) will be late. Drafted a short note telling members the new date Log row 2; the operations manager's update in the board folder: the planning system change moves to 13 November | Draft | Managing director | Sent by the managing director on 27 Oct with the new date of 13 November. Firm dates on every acknowledgement from 13 November; done date entered on the Log |
| 16 Nov 2026 | Price-rise explanation due to members on 30 Nov, 14 days away; the January price review is decided on 5 Jan. No draft answer yet Log row 5 (due 30 Nov; business decision 5 Jan); nothing from the finance director in the board folder | Flag | Managing director | The finance director to bring the answer by 25 Nov, so members hear back before the price review |
| 30 Nov 2026 | "You said, we did" update for members: the four items under review or due by 4 Dec (price rises, kitting trial, offshore cost comparison, five-axis capacity) Log rows 3, 5, 6 and 9; the owners' written updates in the board folder; the charter's 90-day promise (members told by 9 Dec) | Draft | Managing director | The chair read it first. Sent by the managing director on 2 Dec: three months' notice of rises with the cost figures; first kits delivered 4 Dec; the comparison in the February pre-reads; the five-axis answer after the March plan. Date told entered on the Log |
| 11 Jan 2027 | Pack for the 4 Feb video meeting: agenda on the price-rise theme with members' time alone with the chair, pre-reads list, open items and the December update Meetings row 2 (4 Feb, video; pre-reads due 28 Jan); the charter; the Log; the facilitation guide | Draft | Chair; managing director | The chair added ten minutes for members alone with the chair (15 Jan). The managing director approved the pack on 20 Jan and sent it on 26 Jan, nine days ahead. No prices or contract terms in it |
| 8 Feb 2027 | Six log rows drafted from the chair's signed-off notes of the 4 Feb meeting, each with an owner and a due date by 5 May (90 days) The chair's notes of 4 Feb in the board folder; Members (who raised each item) | Draft | Managing director | Five confirmed as drafted; one owner changed from the sales manager to the finance director. Entered on the Log on 9 Feb |
| 15 Feb 2027 | Weekly check: no item within 14 days of its due date; nothing decided before members hear back The Log; the management meeting dates in the shared calendar | Logged | – | Nothing to decide |
At the 30-day check-in on 23 November, Geoff and the managing director read the first month's log together, with a test run of the February pack drafted from the charter and the Log and not sent; his upkeep of the set-up ended there. By mid-February every item from the first meeting had its answer, and members had heard back on the price rises on 2 December, before the price review on 5 January. The February pre-reads went out nine days ahead. One date slipped, the firm delivery dates, and members were told before the due date passed rather than after. Reading the weekly note and approving drafts took the managing director about 20 minutes a week (estimate). The value case is unchanged: the early read, the re-measure and the spend read are still taken by people, from the same minutes, log and ledger.