Designs, supplies and fits kitchens and bathrooms for homeowners, and refits for housing associations, across Staffordshire and Cheshire; worktops cut in its own workshop. 64 staff.
Verdict: Failures cost about £101,958 a year (£77,120 cash, £21,438 staff time already paid in wages, £3,400 lost profit on cancelled orders): 1.6% of sales, or £1.59 in every £100. 39% of it was found by the customer. The biggest causes: Worktop template or cut error (31%); Survey measurement error (13%); Fitting workmanship (snagging) (12%); 6 of 12 causes make 80% of the cost. Customers lost: 4 lost (1 repeat or contract, 3 one-off); 1 not known, valued at £18,350 a year at the share counted, kept apart because it rests on estimates. The 5 fixes to do should save about £18,306 a year for £12,253 in the first year (£8,600 of it cash), staff time counted at the same share both ways: a first-year net of £3,765 (-£4,244 if they do half as well; £5,670 in cash alone), and £16,034 a year after. Worth doing if they work as expected, not at half.
Red: the causes that together make 80% of the cost. Last in: Design or order specification wrong (to 82%); next out: Damaged in our van or on site (7%, to 89%). Grey extensions: lost customers’ value at the share counted, which isn’t in the cost. With it, missed or late appointments would rank second: one housing association that didn’t renew outweighs every credit on that cause. That is why it shouldn’t stay parked for long, even though it barely registers on cost alone. Worktop template and cut errors are almost a third of the cost: quartz worktops recut in the workshop, with the hours estimated because the workshop doesn’t book them to jobs.
| Type | Found | Failures | Cost a year | Share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scrap | Internal | 32 | £39,376 | 39% |
| Re-delivery or call-back | External | 42 | £11,832 | 12% |
| Warranty claim | External | 14 | £10,596 | 10% |
| Rework | Internal | 15 | £10,574 | 10% |
| Customer complaint | External | 16 | £10,026 | 10% |
| Supplier fault | Internal | 16 | £8,316 | 8% |
| Return or credit | External | 8 | £7,449 | 7% |
| Internal error caught | Internal | 58 | £3,791 | 4% |
Prevention and appraisal already cost £26,088 a year (5% prevention, 16% appraisal, 80% failure). Most of that is inspection: handover checks and survey checks that find failures rather than stop them. Four of the fixes build on those checks rather than adding new ones.
| Line | Sales a year | Cost a year | In every £100 | Customers lost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Retail kitchens One-off | £3,300,000 | £66,566 | £2.02 | 2 |
| Retail bathrooms One-off | £1,150,000 | £21,001 | £1.83 | 1 |
| Housing refits Repeat or contract | £1,750,000 | £10,180 | £0.58 | 1 |
| Trade worktops Repeat or contract | £200,000 | £4,211 | £2.11 | 0 |
| Figure | Log | Accounts | Difference | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Credit notes and refunds for quality reasons (credits marked credit note or refund) | £6,970 | £7,400 | -6% | Within 10% |
| Scrap and damaged stock: materials on the types chosen on Inputs | £47,750 | £46,500 | 3% | Within 10% |
| Warranty met: cash on warranty rows, less credit notes (checked above); own labour usually sits in wages | £6,255 | £6,000 | 4% | Within 10% |
The bookkeeper confirmed the write-off covers workshop scrap and damaged supplier goods; rework materials are charged to the job, so they are left out of that comparison. Warranty is compared on cash the provision would meet: refunds given as credit notes are checked once, against the ledger, not twice.
| Cause and fix | Plan | Expected saving a year | First-year cost | First-year net | Cash only, first year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Worktop template or cut error Digital templating at the existing template visit, after the carcasses are fitted; cut list checked against the template before cutting Error Proofing Design · worked elsewhere · 60% less if it works, 50% chance | Do | £9,188 | £6,860 | £1,180 | £1,152 |
| Survey measurement error Laser measures and one standard survey sheet, checked by the senior surveyor at the existing survey check Standard Work Documentation · root cause confirmed · 60% less if it works, 60% chance · relies on: senior surveyor checks every survey before ordering | Do | £4,176 | £2,100 | £1,554 | £1,246 |
| Plumbing leak after handover Pressure test and a 30-minute leak check, photographed, before every handover Error Proofing Design · worked elsewhere · 70% less if it works, 50% chance · relies on: handover inspection on every job | Do | £2,917 | £1,883 | £670 | £1,882 |
| Fitting workmanship (snagging) Root cause analysis of the last 30 call-backs, then a photographed checklist used at the existing handover inspection Root Cause Analysis · best practice · 40% less if it works, 30% chance · relies on: handover inspection on every job | Do | £1,134 | £1,080 | −£88 | £704 |
| Supplier sent damaged or wrong goods Photos from the existing goods-in check sent with a claim to the supplier within 48 hours Supplier agreement · best practice · 40% less if it works, 30% chance · relies on: goods-in check of deliveries | Do | £891 | £330 | £450 | £686 |
| Missed or late appointment Text every customer two days before with the fitter's name and arrival window Other · hunch · 30% less if it works, 20% chance | Park | – | – | – | – |
Staff time is counted at the same 50% share whether a fix saves it or spends it. The leak check adds a quarter of an hour to every plumbing handover, about 390 a year, and that per-job time is in its cost.
The log covers 12 months from 1 Oct 2025, scaled to a year; every cost comes from the business’s own records, labour at each role’s cost an hour (18% of it estimated rather than booked). Credits are net of goods resold; lost gross profit counts only where a cancelled order is evidenced. Failures nobody wrote down aren’t here: the check against the accounts shows how far the log and the accounts agree. Lost customers are valued at 50% of the owner’s estimate (assumed), less any lost order already counted, and kept out of the headline. Each fix counts at the chance it works (60% root cause confirmed, 50% worked elsewhere, 30% best practice, 20% a hunch: assumed), staff time at 50% both for time saved and time spent (assumed), building up over 3 months. No benchmark is used: the yardstick is your own cost, year on year.
The design and specification errors (7% of the cost) have no fix yet: a Root Cause Analysis would find out whether they start at the showroom or in ordering. Re-run the review in a year: the yardstick is this year’s own figure, not anyone else’s. Not legal or accounting advice.
After the review, Kelsmoor chose the guided route. In the final working session the agent was set up in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to the job sheets, the sales ledger and the warranty file (its IT confirmed this before it committed). On the first Monday of each month it adds the new failures to a new year's log in a dated copy of the review, runs the checks and sends the managing director a short note. It uses the rules on Inputs: a cause is trending up if, after three months, it runs 25% above its cost at the review and at more than £2,000 a year. Nothing left Kelsmoor, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it. These events continue the fictional example.
| Date | What the agent found | What was decided |
|---|---|---|
| 2 Nov 2026 No flag | The new year's log started: 15 October failures added from the job sheets, credit notes and warranty file. Two records had no hours, so they waited for the office instead of being guessed. | Nothing needed. The office manager completed the two records. |
| 7 Dec 2026 Flag | A trade worktop customer, a kitchen fitter, closed its account after two worktops were cut short in November: a customer lost. | The managing director phoned the customer, but the account stayed closed. Digital templating, already planned, was brought forward to start in December. |
| 4 Jan 2027 Flag | A credit typed as text on a row the office completed by hand put a CHECK on the Checks sheet. The note said so, named the check and gave no figures. | The office manager re-entered it. Checks passed the same morning, and the note followed. |
| 1 Feb 2027 Flag | Plumbing leaks after handover were trending up: four months of the new log put them at £15,300 a year, against £9,543 at the review. | The managing director booked a Root Cause Analysis with the plumbing lead for 9 February. It found a batch of faulty push-fit connectors, replaced in February. |
| 1 Mar 2027 No flag | Worktop cut errors were running at £11,800 a year against £32,106 at the review, with none since digital templating started in mid-December. | Nothing needed. The managing director read the note. |
| 5 Apr 2027 No flag | Plumbing leaks were back within the 25% rise: £10,900 a year against £9,543 at the review. | Nothing needed. They will be watched for two more months before the cause is closed. |
At the check-in on 30 November, after the first monthly run (about day 45), Geoff and the managing director read the first log together. No rule needed changing.
What the agent added. The method is unchanged: same spreadsheet, same checks, same costs. The agent made sure the log kept being filled every month, so the leaks were caught in February instead of at next October's re-run, and the yearly re-run will start from a full log. The figures in these events are fictional log readings, not new savings: the review's value case above is unchanged and no new £ figure is claimed for the agent.
Fictional and labelled: these events continue the worked example. The same six events are the sample rows in the Agent log of the worked-example spreadsheet. The agent is part of the guided and done-for-you routes; the self-implement kit does not include it.