Industrial fasteners, fixings, tools and site safety supplies for contractors, fabricators and maintenance teams across West Yorkshire and the North West. 42 staff. 1,102 invoice lines over 12 months, reconciled to the accounts, and 260 decided quotations.
Discount runs at 8.4% of list in quarter-end months against 5.8% in other months: the usual sign of discounts given to hit a period target rather than to win a customer.
Quotations with a discount over 5% won 42%, against 36% with none. Discount helps a little, but most of the difference comes with the first 5%; larger discounts add little. This shows association, not cause.
| Person | List value | Discount | Over limit, not signed off | Outside the rules | With no reason | Win rate |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Priya Desai Sales team | £1,474,470 | 9.8% | 161 | £69,669 | 30% | 39% |
| Tom Hollis Sales team | £1,355,350 | 5.3% | 36 | £7,044 | 11% | 44% |
| Sam Ridley Sales team | £1,040,680 | 3.7% | 4 | £2,136 | 6% | 39% |
| Amy Clarke Sales team | £323,270 | 1.9% | 0 | £157 | 3% | 39% |
| Neil Barton Sales manager | £1,635,930 | 7.7% | 0 | £616 | 2% | 38% |
Patterns, not blame. Priya Desai's accounts carry 87% of the discount outside the rules, mostly above the limit without sign-off; the fix is a sign-off step that is quick to use, not a reprimand. Some of the largest discounts are on the biggest accounts, with a reason and sign-off: those are policy, not leakage.
Share of all discount, by the reason recorded. "None given" is the easiest to stop.
| Customer | Discount | % of list | Outside the rules |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gildersome Logistics | £49,165 | 7.6% | £0 |
| Aire Valley Fabrications | £48,393 | 10.5% | £21,518 |
| Heckmondwike Rail Services | £42,775 | 7.9% | £616 |
| Brightside Steel Erectors | £42,270 | 11.0% | £24,602 |
| Idle Water Utilities Contractors | £34,444 | 7.7% | £0 |
| Ilkley Mechanical Services | £28,473 | 6.7% | £2,446 |
| Role | Without sign-off, up to | Above that, signed off by |
|---|---|---|
| Sales team | 5% | Sales manager, up to 10%; above that, Managing director |
| Sales manager | 10% | Managing director |
| Managing director | Any discount | Not needed |
Every discount also needs a reason from the list. Each month, check discount as a share of list by person, lines over the limit without sign-off, and lines with no reason; the quarter-end months first.
Invoices total 99.6% of sales in the accounts, over 12 months. Discount is measured against your price list, so it is only as right as the list. Discount outside the rules counts discount above each person's limit without sign-off, and any discount with no reason and no sign-off. The margin to recover assumes you keep 30% to 60% of it, a judgement; some customers will push back. The win-rate comparison rests on 260 decided quotations; it shows association, not cause.
Fictional, continuing the example. Calderbrook chose the guided route and, in the final session, set up an agent in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to the sales ledger (its IT confirmed this before it committed). On the first working day of each month it copies the month's invoice lines into the workbook, tests every line with the audit's own rules, sets each person's discount against their rate in the audit, and sends the managing director a short note. It names any line at least £25 outside the rules, and flags anyone 2 points or more above their audit rate. It never changes a price, an invoice or a customer's terms. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it.
| Date | What the agent flagged | What was decided |
|---|---|---|
| 15 Oct Flag | Test run at set-up on September, the audit's last month: 23 lines over the limit without sign-off, £13,638 outside the rules, and two people well above their audit rates in a quarter-end month. | As the audit found. The sign-off rule starts on 1 November, after the team briefing. |
| 2 Nov Flag | October, the month before the rule: 17 lines over the limit without sign-off, £6,910 outside the rules. | The sales manager briefed the team: sign-off before the price is quoted, and a reason on every discount. October's invoices stand. |
| 1 Dec No flag | November: 4 lines outside the rules, £740; 5% of the discount with no reason. | Nothing needed. |
| 1 Dec Flag | Six site safety lines priced above list: the price list in the export was out of date. | The office manager updated the export; the six lines were within the rules. |
| 4 Jan Flag | December, a quarter-end month: one salesperson's discount at 12.1% of list against 9.8% in the audit. | The managing director went through her three largest discounts with her: two now carry the competitor-match reason, one goes to the March price review. |
| 4 Jan No flag | December: 5 lines outside the rules, £1,180, against £13,638 in September, the last quarter-end. | Nothing needed; the audit is rerun in April. |
The test run on September, the audit's last month, matched the audit's own figures for it (92 lines, £13,638 outside the rules), which is how the set-up was checked. At the check-in on 27 November, after the first monthly run, Geoff and the managing director read the log together; no rule needed changing. The sign-off rule started on 1 November: the discount outside the rules fell from £13,638 in September to £740 in November and £1,180 in December, the next quarter-end. These are the audit's own measures, read monthly; the agent's part was making sure the check happened every month and the reopening in one salesperson's quarter-end was raised in January, not at the April rerun. No £ figure is claimed for the agent.