Steel-framed agricultural and industrial buildings, mezzanine floors and storage racking, designed and fabricated at Brigg and erected across the north of England; founded in 1974 by the present directors' father. 284 staff; two family branches holding half the shares each.
Who is covered: Branch A 50% (3 people); Branch B 50% (3 people). Parties appear by role throughout; first names stay in the workbook.
Verdict: The framework gives the family members of Ottersley Structures Ltd a ladder of 6 steps, in order, 226 days from the first conversation to the last step before court, with every step's trigger, timescale and owner set and confidentiality agreed. 5 of 5 protocols for the common disputes are written. 2 live disputes are mapped to a step, with 3 decisions frozen now. 2 steps only bind through a clause; each is in place or on the solicitor's list (7 items, 0 adopted). How the value is shown (risk avoided, not a forecast): the largest event, “A shareholder exit forced at a poor valuation: a 10% holding sold to an outside buyer at a minority discount”, would cost £636,600 from the owner's figures and the solicitor's estimates. With the owner's assumed likelihoods the events cost £133,655 a year on average; if the framework works as assumed it cuts that by £95,555 (£47,777 if half as well), against £9,070 a year including the advisers' fees with the build spread over 5 years. Early read 24 Feb 2027; re-measure 26 May 2027.
Days to start Days to finish The longest road before court; expert determination is used only for the price of shares, so most disputes reach court, if at all, sooner.
| Step | Who can trigger it | Who runs it | Timescale | Cost and who pays | Legal status |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| S1 Talk directly, by the agreed rules Direct conversation | Any owner, or any family member employed in the business, who disagrees with another about the business | The two people involved; either may ask the panel chair to set the date | start within 7 days, finish within 14 | none Each side pays its own | Not needed |
| S2 A facilitated conversation with the trusted neutral Facilitated discussion | Either party once step 1 has run out of time or failed; or the panel chair | The panel chair arranges it; the trusted neutral runs it Neutral: The trusted neutral named in advance by both branches: a retired chartered accountant and former finance director with no current tie to either branch | start within 7 days, finish within 21 | £1,200 a case (quotation) The company | Not needed |
| S3 The family panel Family council | Either party once step 2 has run out of time or failed; the panel chair; or any protocol that starts here | The independent non-executive chair, with one panel member from each branch named in the framework, neither of them party to the dispute Neutral: The independent non-executive chair of the board, who chairs the panel | start within 14 days, finish within 30 | none The company | Not needed |
| S4 Mediation with a registered mediator Mediation | Either party once step 3 has run out of time or failed; or the panel chair | The panel chair proposes three mediators; the parties choose one together within 7 days Neutral: A mediator registered with the Civil Mediation Council, with family business experience, chosen together | start within 14 days, finish within 45 | £5,200 a case (quotation) Shared equally | On the solicitor's list |
| S5 Expert determination of the fair value of shares Expert determination | Only for the value of shares on a transfer or an exit, once the parties agree the facts but not the price, or mediation has failed on price | The panel chair asks the president of the valuer's professional body to appoint the expert if the parties can't agree one within 14 days Neutral: An independent chartered accountant experienced in valuing private company shares, using the method in the articles | start within 14 days, finish within 60 | £9,000 a case (estimate) Shared equally | On the solicitor's list |
| S6 Court, as the last resort Court | Either party, only after mediation (or expert determination for a price) has failed; the right to petition under s994 stays with every owner, and any owner may seek an urgent court order at any time to protect the business or their position | Each side's own solicitor Neutral: A judge | only after the steps above | about £110,000 a side (estimate) Each side pays its own | Not needed |
| Dispute | The rule | Enters at | Meanwhile | Linked product |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pay and roles A family member's pay, bonus, car or job title is set or changed, and another branch thinks it is above the market or not earned | Pay for family members follows the Family Employment Policy: the remuneration committee (the independent chair and the finance director) sets it against an independent benchmark for the role, and every branch sees the benchmark | S3 The family panel decides: The board, on the remuneration committee's recommendation | Pay stays as it is; no further change for any family member until the panel has reported | Family Employment Policy |
| Dividends and drawings The board's dividend recommendation, or a branch's request for a larger one | The board recommends a dividend under the Dividend Policy after the reinvestment the plan needs; the shareholders declare it, never above the recommendation | S1 Talk directly, by the agreed rules decides: The shareholders, on the board's recommendation | No dividend is declared until the protocol has run, unless both branch heads agree an interim one | Dividend Policy |
| Strategy and investment A capital project, a new site, borrowing or a sale of assets on which the branches disagree, or a board or shareholder vote that ties | Projects over £250,000 come to the board with an appraisal under the Investment Priorities Plan; a tie goes to the panel within 14 days, then mediation | S3 The family panel decides: The board, or the shareholders where the law or the articles reserve it | No new commitment over £250,000 while the protocol runs; everything already contracted continues | Investment Priorities Plan |
| Exits and share valuations An owner wants to sell some or all of their shares, or has an approach from a buyer | Shares are offered first to the owner's own branch, then to the other branch, at a fair value set by the method in the articles without a minority discount; the price, if disputed, goes to expert determination | S3 The family panel decides: The independent expert, on the price; the owners, on whether to buy | No transfer to anyone outside the family while the protocol runs (binding once the articles are changed) | Ownership Transfer Plan |
| Between generations The next generation asks for a say in who leads, how they are prepared, or when the senior generation steps back | The family panel hears the next generation once a year; succession to managing director is decided by the board, after the panel has been consulted; a family constitution is the place to settle the longer-term rules | S1 Talk directly, by the agreed rules decides: The board | Present roles continue until the board decides | Family Constitution |
| Early-warning sign | What it looks like here | Who watches | First step |
|---|---|---|---|
| Questions raised through someone else | A branch head hears about a pay or dividend concern from a spouse, a manager or the finance director rather than from the person | Panel chair | S1 |
| A decision deferred twice | The same item comes back to the board or a family meeting twice without a decision | Independent chair | S3 |
| A solicitor's letter or a 'without prejudice' approach | Any owner instructs a solicitor about their shares, pay or treatment | Independent chair | S3 |
| Talks with an outside buyer or valuer | An owner asks for the accounts for a buyer, or a buyer approaches the company about a holding | Finance director | S3 |
| An owner stops coming | An owner misses two board, family or shareholder meetings in a row, or stops replying | Panel chair | S1 |
| Staff or customers hear about it | A manager, customer or supplier mentions a disagreement between the branches | Branch A head; managing director | S1 |
| Dispute | Type and parties | The issue | Status | Decisions frozen | Cost so far |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| D1 23 June 2026 | Pay and roles Branch B head; non-executive director and Branch A head; managing director | The sales director's pay rise in April 2026 was set by his own branch head without a benchmark; the other branch says it is above the market for the role and is a dividend by another name | Live now at S3, The family panel; step ends 8 November 2026 | 2 frozen: The 2026 dividend; the search for the next managing director | £6,400 |
| D2 14 July 2026 | Exits and share valuations Branch B; shareholder not employed and Branch A head; managing director | A shareholder who does not work in the business wants to sell her 10% holding and has an approach from an outside buyer; the other branch will buy only at a minority-discounted value; there is no agreed valuation method | Live now at S4, Mediation with a registered mediator; step ends 19 November 2026 | 1 frozen: The £1.6m powder-coating line: the bank wants both branch heads' guarantees until ownership is settled | £4,100 |
| D4 14 February 2022 | Pay and roles Branch A head; managing director and Branch B head; non-executive director | Whether a family member from one branch should be promoted to operations manager over a non-family candidate | Resolved finished at S2 after 165 days | 5 months frozen | £1,800 |
| D3 6 March 2023 | Dividends and drawings Branch B head; non-executive director and Branch A head; managing director | One branch wanted a larger dividend after a record year; the other wanted the cash for the new press brake | Resolved finished at S1 after 150 days | 3 months frozen | £0 |
| D5 2 September 2024 | Strategy and investment Branch A head; managing director and Branch B head; non-executive director | Whether to lease a second fabrication bay at Scunthorpe or extend at Brigg | Resolved finished at S1 after 49 days | 1 months frozen | £0 |
| D6 22 April 2025 | Between generations Branch A; sales director and Branch A head; managing director | The next generation asked for a say in choosing the next managing director and a date for the senior generation to step back | Withdrawn withdrawn after 210 days | 0 months frozen | £0 |
Cost so far is outside fees already paid by anyone (counted from invoices). It is spent, so the value case does not count it.
| Rule | Topic | What it means for the framework, and the source (checked 16 October 2026) |
|---|---|---|
| L1 | Unfair prejudice petition | The framework can't take this right away. Owners promise to use the ladder first. An arbitration clause can send the complaints behind such a petition to arbitration (the Court of Appeal in Fulham FC (1987) Ltd v Richards [2011] EWCA Civ 855), though some relief, such as winding up, stays with the court: a question for the solicitor before any arbitration step is added Companies Act 2006 s994(1), legislation.gov.uk (up to date to 15 October 2026); Fulham FC v Richards [2011] EWCA Civ 855 as described in 'Football and the Law' (a judicial speech, judiciary.uk, 2022; the judgment on BAILII could not be opened when checked); checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L2 | What the court can order on a petition | A court-ordered purchase moves value between members: not counted as a loss to the owners as a whole. The legal costs, the time and the frozen decisions are Companies Act 2006 s996(1) and (2)(e), legislation.gov.uk; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L3 | Deadlock: winding up on the just and equitable ground | Where two groups hold half each, an unbroken deadlock can end in a petition to wind up a solvent business. A deadlock clause and the ladder are the way through Insolvency Act 1986 s122(1)(g), legislation.gov.uk (up to date to 11 October 2026); checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L4 | Arbitration needs a written agreement | An arbitration step binds only through a written clause, usually in a shareholders' agreement drafted by the solicitor. Private and final, but each side usually pays lawyers. The Arbitration Act 2025 came into force on 1 August 2025; it left these sections unchanged Arbitration Act 1996 s5(1), s9(1) and (4), s58(1), legislation.gov.uk (no outstanding effects); Arbitration Act 2025 (Commencement) Regulations 2025, SI 2025/905; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L5 | Expert determination binds only by agreement | Treat a binding valuation of shares as needing a clause in the articles or a shareholders' agreement that sets the method and who appoints the expert; the solicitor confirms how it would work for share valuations Civil Justice Council, 'Guidance Note on Boundary Disputes' (August 2018), judiciary.uk: a general description only, not a source on share valuations; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L6 | Mediation with a registered mediator | Step 4 uses a mediator registered with the Civil Mediation Council, chosen together, fee quoted in advance. Any settlement is written and signed GOV.UK 'A guide to civil mediation' (published 20 July 2021); Civil Mediation Council mediator search; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L7 | The courts expect dispute resolution first | Going straight to court doesn't avoid mediation: a court can order it, so the ladder saves the cost of being sent back Civil Procedure Rules 1.1(2)(f) and 3.1(2)(o), inserted by the Civil Procedure (Amendment No. 3) Rules 2024 (SI 2024/839), justice.gov.uk and legislation.gov.uk; Churchill v Merthyr Tydfil CBC [2023] EWCA Civ 1416, caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L8 | Share transfers under standard articles | Pre-emption (family or owners first) and an agreed valuation exist only if the articles or a shareholders' agreement create them. The solicitor reads the actual articles Companies (Tables A to F) Regulations 1985, Table A reg 24; Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008, Sch 1, art 26(5); legislation.gov.uk; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L9 | Employees keep the grievance route | A family member or owner who is also an employee keeps the grievance procedure for their own pay and treatment; the ladder runs alongside it, never instead of it Acas Code of Practice on disciplinary and grievance procedures (in force from 11 March 2015; Acas consulted on a revised draft in 2026: check the version in force), acas.org.uk; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L10 | Personal data in the dispute log | The log holds the minimum (roles, dates, stage, cost, decisions frozen; no health or other special category detail), is kept only for the months set on Inputs, and anyone named in it can ask for a copy UK GDPR Article 5(1)(c) and (e) and Article 15; ICO 'Principle (e): Storage limitation' and 'A guide to subject access' (updated 16 July 2026); checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L11 | Changing the articles needs 75% | The clauses on the solicitor's list that go into the articles need 75% of the votes: where two groups hold half each, both must agree Companies Act 2006 s21(1) and s283(1), legislation.gov.uk; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L12 | Casting votes | A tie is not always a deadlock: who chairs the board, and whether the old articles kept a casting vote at general meetings, are questions for the solicitor, who reads the articles as they now stand Table A reg 88 and reg 50 (annotated as ceasing to have effect 1.10.2007, SI 2007/2826), legislation.gov.uk; Companies Act 2006 (Commencement No. 3) Order 2007, Sch 3 para 23A, inserted by SI 2007/3495; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| L13 | One solicitor for both branches | The company's solicitor drafts the clauses; where the branches' interests differ (pre-emption prices, deadlock), each branch takes its own advice, and those fees are on Inputs SRA Code of Conduct for Solicitors, RELs and RFLs, paragraph 6.2, sra.org.uk; checked 16 Oct 2026 |
| The solicitor's list | Document | From | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shareholders' agreement: the ladder, with mediation by a Civil Mediation Council registered mediator before any proceedings between shareholders, binding on every shareholder | Shareholders' agreement | S4 | Briefed |
| Articles: expert determination of the fair value of shares on any transfer, by an independent chartered accountant appointed as the framework says, final and binding | Articles | S5 | Briefed |
| Articles: pre-emption on transfer, own branch first and then the other, at fair value without a minority discount; transfers outside the family only if no family member buys | Articles | P4 | Briefed |
| Shareholders' agreement: a deadlock on a board or shareholder vote goes to the family panel within 14 days, then mediation | Shareholders' agreement | P3 | Briefed |
| Board terms of reference: a remuneration committee (the independent chair and the finance director) sets family members' pay against an independent benchmark | Board terms of reference | P1 | To brief |
| Question: which way of breaking a deadlock suits us? Options, not advice: the chairman's casting vote at board meetings (Table A reg 88) and any casting vote kept at general meetings under the 2007 saving; a 'shotgun' (Russian roulette) clause; put and call options; an independent director with a deciding vote on named matters; expert determination of named questions | Shareholders' agreement | P3 | To brief |
| Question: timing. Changing the articles while the exit dispute is live can itself be complained of as unfairly prejudicial to the seller (s994): whether to adopt the pre-emption and valuation clauses now, with her agreement, or after the dispute is settled | Articles | P4 | To brief |
The two branches hold half the shares each, so the articles changes (75%) need both; the board is not split evenly (two Branch A directors, one Branch B, the finance director and the independent chair). Where the branches’ interests differ, each takes its own advice (SRA Code 6.2); those fees are in the build cost. The solicitor's and valuer's fees are the family's own cost, paid directly; the valuer's is not yet quoted.
Without the framework With it (the owner's assumption)
| Event | Cost without | With the framework | Reduction | Likelihood (assumed) | Expected cost a year | Break-even: once in N years (half as well) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 A dispute that freezes the dividend, the powder-coating line and the successor search for months legal costs: solicitor's estimate | £120,580 | £58,461 | £62,119 | 1 in 2 own history | £48,232 | 7 (3) |
| E2 A shareholder exit forced at a poor valuation: a 10% holding sold to an outside buyer at a minority discount legal costs: solicitor's estimate | £636,600 | £106,200 | £530,400 | 1 in 10 adviser's view | £63,660 | 58 (29) |
| E3 An unfair-prejudice petition by one branch over the other's pay and control (Companies Act 2006 s994) legal costs: solicitor's estimate | £362,707 | £68,254 | £294,454 | 1 in 17 adviser's view | £21,762 | 32 (16) |
Each cost is gross profit lost while decisions are frozen (£942,500 a month, counted from the accounts, times the months and the share lost), legal costs (the solicitor's estimates; with the framework, the mediator's quotation), other loss to the family as a whole (value passing to an outside buyer and, with the framework, the interest the buying branch pays to borrow; never money moving between family members, so a court-ordered or family purchase of shares is not counted) and the owners' hours. With the owner's assumed likelihoods (not a forecast) the events cost £133,655 a year across 3 events on average; if the framework works as assumed it cuts that by £95,555 a year; £47,777 if half as well; £42,515 (£21,257 half as well) without the events that wait on clauses not yet adopted. Cost in full: £9,500 consultant; £6,600 owners' time; £18,000 outside advisers; £2,250 a year to keep up; £9,070 a year with the build spread over 5 years. The forced-exit reduction holds only once the pre-emption and expert-determination clauses are adopted; without it the reduction is £42,515 a year (£21,257 half as well). Changing the articles while the exit dispute is live can itself prompt an unfair-prejudice complaint, so timing is on the solicitor's list. The months frozen with the framework are never shorter than the ladder's own time to the step where each event settles.
| Measure | Now | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Disputes opened in the five years before adoption | 6 | counted from the register |
| Finished; resolved before any outside neutral | 4; 3 | talk, a trusted neutral or the panel |
| Old enough to count: finished within 120 days | 1 of 4 | average 144 days to finish |
| Decisions frozen now | 3 | in 2 live disputes; the longest for 4 months |
| Solicitor's list adopted | 0 of 7 | documents aligned |
A snapshot: too few disputes to tell a change from chance; read each dispute's own record (days, step, decisions frozen). Early read and re-measure: 24 Feb 2027; 26 May 2027.
The ladder, protocols and signs are as agreed with the owners on 16 Oct 2026; it binds as a promise between those who sign it, and as a contract only once the solicitor's list is adopted (the articles changes need 75%). The legal rules on Inputs were checked on official sources on 16 October 2026 and are cited, not legal advice; nothing in the framework removes an owner's right to petition the court. Gross profit a month is counted from the accounts; legal costs are the solicitor's estimates or quotations as each row says; the advisers' fees are quoted or assumed as Checks shows. Months frozen, other losses and how far the framework reduces them are the owner's estimates and assumptions; only losses to the business or the owners as a whole are counted, never money passing between members, and costs already spent on the live disputes are not counted. Part of the reduction depends on clauses not yet adopted (£42,515 a year does not), and changing the articles during a live dispute can itself prompt a complaint: the solicitor advises on timing. Each likelihood a year is an assumption the owner agrees, never a fact, so the expected costs hold only with those likelihoods. The measures rest on 4 past dispute(s) old enough to count: a snapshot: too few disputes to tell a change from chance; read each dispute's own record (days, step, decisions frozen).
The framework is finished when every owner has signed it and the log is running; the solicitor's list makes the binding parts binding. Review it every year and after any dispute reaches mediation.