Wire and sheet-metal components (shop display fittings, machine guards, baskets and racking parts) made in Cradley Heath for shopfitters and equipment makers; family-owned since 1968. 96 staff; seven shareholders in two share classes.
Verdict: The policy has an agreed clause in 12 of 12 sections. Dividends have been decided without written tests: 0 of 12 past decisions named the accounts, wrote down the reserves, cash and covenant tests and were minuted, and dividends fell within today's range in 1 of 4 years with a range. The proposed £200,000 passes the reserves, cash and covenant tests, with the accountant's sign-off, and brings the year to £320,000 (within the range); the most the tests and the policy allow now is £220,000, set by cash. In a bad year its tests would allow £0; paying last year's £520,000 instead would need £520,000 of short-term borrowing. How the value is shown (risk avoided, not a forecast): the largest event, “Unlawful dividend: paid without distributable reserves”, would cost £295,800 from the owner's own figures. With the owner's assumed likelihoods, the 4 events cost £14,268 a year on average; if the policy works as assumed it cuts that by £9,366 (£4,683 if half as well), against £3,680 a year, the advisers' fees included. Tax-efficiency is for the accountant and each shareholder's tax adviser; this is not tax or legal advice. Re-measure on 16 Oct 2027.
| Shareholder | Class | Shares | Share | Works here? | Proposed dividend |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Morven | A ordinary | 220 | 22% | Working · director | £44,000 |
| Gideon | A ordinary | 160 | 16% | Working · director | £32,000 |
| Alasdair | A ordinary | 120 | 12% | Not working | £24,000 |
| Rosalind | A ordinary | 100 | 10% | Not working | £20,000 |
| Tamsin | B ordinary | 80 | 8% | Working | £16,000 |
| Bryony | B ordinary | 200 | 20% | Not working | £40,000 |
| Hector | B ordinary | 120 | 12% | Not working | £24,000 |
A and B ordinary shares carry the same rights to dividends and capital; B shares have no vote. Every dividend is paid at the same rate a share on both. Working shareholders are paid for their work by salary, under the Family Employment Policy.
Today's policy range for the year Paid, within the range Paid, outside it
| Year | Profit after tax | Paid | Today's range | Against it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year to 31 Mar 2022 | £640,000 | £300,000 | £0 to £0 | No earlier year |
| Year to 31 Mar 2023 | £820,000 | £450,000 | £224,000 to £320,000 | Above |
| Year to 31 Mar 2024 | £150,000 | £380,000 | £255,500 to £365,000 | Above |
| Year to 31 Mar 2025 | £700,000 | £200,000 | £169,750 to £242,500 | Within |
| Year to 31 Mar 2026 | £900,000 | £520,000 | £148,750 to £212,500 | Above |
£1,550,000 paid over 4 years with a range (each from the years before it) against a range of £798,000 to £1,140,000; within the range in 1 of 4 (3 above, 0 below). The range is 35% to 50% of profit after tax averaged over the two years before each year, as for this year; the first year has no earlier year, so no range. In the year to March 2024 profit fell to £150,000 and £380,000 was paid; year-end cash fell to £210,000 and the overdraft was used.
| Item | £ |
|---|---|
| Profit and loss reserve at that date (£) | £2,500,000 |
| Less: unrealised profits included in it (£) | £185,000 |
| Other adjustments the accountant has advised in writing (£; + or −) | £0 |
| Less: dividends paid or declared since that date (£) | £120,000 |
| Profit since counted, or loss deducted (£) | £0 |
| Distributable reserves available now (£) | £2,195,000 |
The £310,000 profit since the year end is not counted because no interim accounts were prepared (s838); a loss would have been deducted. Test: Pass. Not legal advice.
| Step | Normal | A bad year |
|---|---|---|
| Cash at the decision date | £780,000 | £780,000 |
| + Forecast cash from operations, next 12 months | £860,000 | £344,000 |
| − Loan and lease repayments due | −£300,000 | −£300,000 |
| − Committed investment not funded by borrowing | −£350,000 | −£350,000 |
| − Minimum cash buffer (months × fixed costs) | −£420,000 | −£420,000 |
| Leaves: cash available to distribute over the next 12 months | £570,000 | £54,000 |
| Lowest forecast month-end cash before any new dividend | £640,000 | £124,000 |
| − Minimum cash buffer | −£420,000 | −£420,000 |
| Leaves: room above the buffer at the low point | £220,000 | −£296,000 |
| Cash limit: the lower of the two (not below 0) | £220,000 | £0 |
Cash test: Pass. Lowest forecast cash after the dividend £440,000, against a buffer of £420,000. The bad year assumes profit after tax down 82% (the worst fall in the history), EBITDA down 50% and cash from operations down 60%, all agreed with the owner.
| Covenant | Threshold | Before | After | Passes? | Largest dividend it allows |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Leverage: net debt to EBITDA at most Term loan | 2.00x | 0.50x | 0.63x | Pass | £2,180,000 |
| Debt service cover at least (distributions deducted) Term loan | 1.50x | 2.62x | 2.14x | Pass | £470,000 |
| Dividend cap: share of profit after tax Term loan | 60% | 13% | 36% | Pass | £420,000 |
| Minimum net worth Term loan | £2,000,000 | £2,950,000 | £2,750,000 | Pass | £950,000 |
| Not affected by a dividend Invoice finance | – | – | – | Pass | no limit |
From the facility letters, as the owner read them. The bad-year column pro-rates the falls to the next test date (31 December): net debt rises and cash falls with the lost operating cash; the dividend cap rests on last year's audited profit, which a bad year doesn't change.
| Section | Clause |
|---|---|
| Purpose and principles 2 clauses · board | This policy sets how Varleigh Wireforms Ltd decides dividends, so that every shareholder knows in advance what can be paid, what is kept first and when they will hear. It does not promise any dividend. |
| What can be paid: the reserves test 3 clauses · finance director | No dividend is paid unless the distributable reserves on the relevant accounts cover it (Companies Act 2006, sections 830 and 836). The relevant accounts are the last annual accounts circulated to the shareholders; interim accounts are prepared whenever profits since the year end are relied on (section 838). |
| What is kept first: the cash waterfall 2 clauses · finance director | Before any dividend the business keeps, in this order: a cash buffer of one month's fixed costs; the loan and lease repayments due in the next 12 months; the investment the board has committed to; and the headroom the bank's covenants need. Only the cash left after these is available. |
| Covenants and the bank 2 clauses · finance director | Every financial covenant and dividend restriction in the facility letters is tested after the proposed dividend at the next test date. No dividend is paid that would break one, and none that needs the bank's consent until the consent is given in writing. |
| The target range 2 clauses · board | Dividends paid in each financial year aim to fall between 35% and 50% of profit after tax, averaged over the last two years, always subject to the tests above. The range is a target, not a promise. |
| A bad year 1 clause · board | In a bad year the tests come first: if they allow less than the range, the lower figure is paid, and nothing is paid if any test fails. Shareholders are told now that this can happen. |
| Timing: interim and final 2 clauses · board | An interim dividend may be considered in November, after the half-year management accounts, and a final dividend after the annual accounts are circulated, usually in September. There are no other dividends. |
| How the board decides 3 clauses · finance director | Every decision uses the board paper template: the relevant accounts named, the reserves test, the cash test, the covenant test, the range for the year and the accountant's sign-off. |
| Share classes 2 clauses · board | A and B ordinary shares carry the same rights to dividends and to capital; B shares carry no vote. Every dividend is paid at the same rate a share on both classes. |
| Working shareholders 2 clauses · managing director | Shareholders who work in the business are paid for their work by salary and benefits set as for any other employee, under the Family Employment Policy. Dividends are a return on shares only and are never used as pay. |
| Telling the shareholders 2 clauses · managing director | Within a week of each decision every shareholder receives the same letter: the amount a share, the payment date, the result of each test and what the policy expects for the rest of the year. |
| Advice and review 2 clauses · finance director | This policy is not tax or legal advice. The accountant confirms each reserves test; each shareholder's tax is a matter for their own adviser; the tax pointers in the workbook are dated and checked again every year. |
£0 allowed by the tests (the range for the year after a bad year: £185,850 to £265,500); last year's £520,000 would need £520,000 of short-term borrowing.
The range for the year after a bad year would be £185,850 to £265,500 (the bad year averaged with last year), but the tests come first: over a bad 12 months the cash test, taking the full year's fall as a cautious assumption, would allow nothing, so nothing would be paid. Shareholders hear this now, not in the bad year.
| Event | Cost of one event | Likelihood (assumed) | Policy removes (assumed) | Expected a year | Break-even, years (half as well) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Unlawful dividend: paid without distributable reserves £280,800 at stake, £12,000 fees, 40 hours | £295,800 | 1 in 100 owner's judgement | 90% | £2,958 | 72.3 (36.2) |
| Covenant breach caused by a distribution £20,500 at stake, £3,000 fees, 30 hours | £25,750 | 1 in 10 own history | 70% | £2,575 | 4.9 (2.4) |
| Cash squeeze: expensive borrowing to fund a dividend £24,800 at stake, £0 fees, 25 hours | £26,675 | 1 in 5 own history | 60% | £5,335 | 4.3 (2.2) |
| Shareholder dispute over dividends £0 at stake, £25,000 fees, 120 hours | £34,000 | 1 in 10 owner's judgement | 50% | £3,400 | 4.6 (2.3) |
E1: the directors' net personal exposure if a dividend like last year's £520,000 were paid without reserves, assuming every shareholder who works in the business (Tamsin included, though not a director) knew and repays their own part, and the 54% held by those who don't work in it can't be recovered (s847 reaches only shareholders who knew). Directors can be liable to the company for the full amount (s847 and case law); repayments go back to the company, so they are not lost. Likely only once in 100 years because the reserves are £2.2m. Not legal advice. E2: the facility letter's £7,500 waiver fee and 2% margin step-up on £1.3m for six months. E3: paying last year's dividend in a bad year would need £520,000 of short-term borrowing at 8% over the normal rate for six months, plus a £4,000 fee. E2 and E3 can be caused by the same bad year, so the owner judged their likelihoods together. With the owner's assumed likelihoods (not a forecast), the four events cost £14,268 a year on average; if the policy works as assumed it cuts that by £9,366 a year (£4,683 if half as well). Cost in full: £9,150 to build (consultant £3,600; advisers' fees £3,300, paid by the client directly; team time £2,250); £1,850 a year to keep up; £3,680 a year with the build spread over 5 years, the accountant's and solicitor's fees paid by the client directly (the solicitor's is assumed until quoted). The break-even needs no likelihood: the yearly cost is covered if, without the policy, the event would happen once in that many years.
| Measure | Baseline | Now, and how it is taken again |
|---|---|---|
| Dividends with the accounts named, all three tests written down and minuted | 0 of 12 | every decision, logged the same way |
| Years when dividends fell within today's range | 1 of 4 | this year: within the range |
| Lowest forecast cash after the dividend, above the buffer | – | £20,000 |
At two decisions a year the count moves slowly: it shows whether the rules are followed, not proof of what they are worth.
The policy clauses, the range, the buffer and the share classes are as agreed with the board and the shareholders on 16 Oct 2026. The history, holdings and reserves are counted from the accounts, the register of members and the management accounts; the reserves test follows Companies Act 2006 ss830 and 836-838, reviewed by the company's accountant, and is not legal advice. The cash test rests on Rolling Forecast and Monthly Pack, September 2026 update; the covenant tests on the facility letters as the owner read them. The bad-year falls, each event's likelihood and the share of it the policy removes are the owner's assumptions, not tested; so the expected costs hold only with those likelihoods, and 1 adviser's fee is assumed until quoted. The tax pointers were checked on 16 Oct 2026 for the accountant to apply: which mix of salary and dividend is tax-efficient for anyone is for the accountant and their own tax adviser to decide.
The tax pointers (dividend allowance £500; rates 10.75%, 35.75% and 39.35% for 2026-27, from GOV.UK) are for the accountant to apply. The policy does not recommend any level of dividend: the range is the shareholders' choice.