Online retailer of garden furniture, parasols and outdoor heating, selling across the UK. 35 staff.
Verdict: 49,270 contacts, of whom 43% are active. Removing 10,870 and trying to win back 16,300 (about 815 likely to return), with 4 set-up fixes, takes 20 hours and £880. Once done it should save £1,920 a year in fees (the firmest figure), add £4,812 from contacts won back and £7,561 from better inbox placement (the least certain: re-test it): £14,293 a year, a first-year net of £11,031 (payback 3 months). With complaints above 0.1%, the £124,000 of gross profit a year that email truly adds is exposed if Google starts rejecting the mail.
| Group | Contacts | Share | Action | Won back a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Engaged: opened or clicked in the last 90 days | 14,200 | 29% | Keep | – |
| Cooling: last opened or clicked 91 to 180 days ago | 6,800 | 14% | Keep | – |
| Unengaged: last opened or clicked 181 to 365 days ago Three-email win-back, then remove non-responders | 9,400 | 19% | Win back | £2,775 |
| Dormant: no open or click for 1 to 2 years Same sequence | 6,900 | 14% | Win back | £2,037 |
| Dormant: no open or click for over 2 years (or never) | 6,200 | 13% | Remove | – |
| Hard bounced but still on the list | 1,450 | 3% | Remove | – |
| Invalid or duplicate addresses | 900 | 2% | Remove | – |
| Role addresses (info@, sales@, accounts@) Trade customers buy through these | 1,100 | 2% | Keep | – |
| Unsubscribed or complained but still mailed Platform import error: fix the sync | 120 | 0% | Remove suggested: suppress | – |
| No record of consent or another lawful basis Bought list from a 2021 trade show | 2,200 | 4% | Remove | – |
The trade-show list from 2021 goes: there’s no record that anyone on it agreed to hear from Ashlowe. Role addresses stay because trade customers order through them.
| Check | Status | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| SPF set up for every service that sends as your domain | Pass | – |
| DKIM: emails signed with your own domain | Pass | – |
| DMARC record published, and its reports read | Fail | 2 h |
| Marketing sent from your own domain, not a free address | Pass | – |
| One-click unsubscribe in every marketing email | Fail | 1 h |
| Unsubscribes acted on within two days | Pass | – |
| Spam complaint rate below 0.1% (Google Postmaster Tools) | Fail | 0 h |
| Sending domain and addresses not on the main blocklists | Pass | – |
| Sender name and postal address in every email | Pass | – |
| Sending volume steady: no sudden blasts to old contacts | Fail | 1 h |
| Engaged contacts mailed first; dormant ones not mailed every campaign | Fail | 2 h |
| Consent recorded with date and source for new sign-ups | Not known | – |
The complaint rate (0.25%) is close to Google’s 0.3% limit, above which Gmail starts rejecting bulk mail: the £124,000 of gross profit a year that email truly adds is exposed. Mailing dormant contacts every campaign is the likely cause, and the cleaning deals with it. It isn’t counted as a gain.
The list breakdown and sales come from the business’s own email platform. Only 50% of email sales are treated as truly extra, at a 40% margin. Fees saved are the platform’s own prices at the smaller list. The inbox gain is counted only if measured (Seed test) and only if a failing set-up check is being fixed, at 50% of the rise from 82% to 92%. Win-back assumes 5% return, each worth what an active contact brings now. Gains start once the clean-up is done (2 months). Sales to contacts removed are taken to be nil: by definition they haven’t clicked in two years, can’t receive email, or can’t lawfully be mailed.
Re-run the seed test a month after the fixes: if placement hasn’t moved, take the inbox gain out.
Fictional, continuing the example. After the check, Ashlowe chose the guided route and set up the agent in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to its email platform, Google Postmaster Tools and the mailbox that receives its DMARC reports (its IT confirmed this before it committed). On the first Monday of each month it loads the latest figures into a new dated copy of the workbook, runs the 18 checks, compares the results with the lines the managing director set on Inputs, logs what it finds and sends the marketing manager a short note. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it: the agent never deleted a contact, sent an email or changed a DNS record.
| Date | What the agent found | What people decided |
|---|---|---|
| 2 Nov 2026 Flag | Spam complaint rate down but still above your 0.1% line | Contacts dormant for over 2 years taken out of every campaign now, not at the end of the clean-up; their removal finished by 30 November |
| 2 Nov 2026 No flag | Two set-up fixes in place: DMARC record published, one-click unsubscribe in every marketing email | None needed |
| 7 Dec 2026 No flag | Clean-up finished: removals deleted and win-back non-responders deleted | None needed |
| 7 Dec 2026 No flag | Win-back brought back slightly fewer than assumed | Left at 5% on Inputs for now; the next full check uses the actual |
| 4 Jan 2027 Flag | SPF failing for a new helpdesk tool that sends as the company's domain | Asked the web agency to add the helpdesk to the SPF record; done on 6 January and passing in the next DMARC report |
| 4 Jan 2027 Flag | Hard bounce rate above your 2% line on the 28 December sale email | Most were Christmas pop-up sign-ups with typing errors. Confirmed opt-in turned on for the pop-up form; bounced addresses removed |
At the check-in on 27 November, after the first monthly run, Geoff and the managing director read the first log together and left every line where it was. After that the agent, its accounts and its log were Ashlowe's.
The fees saving the check counted (£1,920 a year) arrived on the December invoice, as planned. The agent caught two problems that would otherwise have waited for the next yearly check: a new tool failing SPF, and a sign-up form letting in bad addresses. Each was fixed within days. Reading the monthly note and recording decisions took the marketing manager about 20 minutes a month (estimate). The seed test is booked for February; the agent will flag it if placement comes back below the 85% line. The months after add nothing to the figures above.
Fictional and labelled: these events continue the worked example. The same six events are the sample rows in the Agent log of the worked-example spreadsheet. The agent is part of the guided and done-for-you routes; the self-implement kit does not include it.