Chilled and frozen pies and savoury pastries for retailers and food service, Staffordshire. 85 staff.
Verdict: Energy costs about £503,217 a year ex VAT (1,538,100 kWh of electricity, 1,540,600 of gas, 482 tCO2e); £9,713 of it is standing and other charges no saving touches. Out-of-hours use is 30% of electricity where there is half-hourly data; leaving out what must run round the clock, about £35,308 a year of it could be switched off. The 7 chosen measures should save about £63,567 in year one after running costs (14% of the spend; 34.6 tCO2e), for £192,688 now (£191,400 of it cash): expected payback 3.0 years and a net present value of £242,652 at 8% (£10,462 if they save half as much; £153,674 to £331,631 if unit rates move 20%). Best by value: “Solar PV, 150 kWp, on the cold store roof”. Quickest payback: Switch-off routine: oven controls and kit left idling (0.1 years). Levy: £24,232 a year; an agreement would cut it by about £22,317 if your process qualifies. Next contract to end: Bakery electricity, 31 Mar 2027 (5 months); each 1p per kWh is £30,787 across all supplies; £10,976 on the next contract to end. Get surveys and quotations before committing.
| Site and fuel | kWh a year | Spend ex VAT | Standing and other charges | Average paid per kWh | Saved per kWh saved |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bakery · electricity contract ends 31 Mar 2027 · 5 months · out of hours 30% | 1,097,600 | £282,782 | £5,217 | £0.258 | £0.253 |
| Bakery · gas contract ends 30 Sep 2027 | 1,540,600 | £102,405 | £949 | £0.066 | £0.066 |
| Cold store · electricity contract ends 31 Oct 2027 | 440,500 | £118,030 | £3,547 | £0.268 | £0.260 |
A kWh saved is worth the unit rate plus the climate change levy, not the average paid: standing and capacity charges stay whatever you use. The bakery electricity contract ends in under nine months: each 1p per kWh on renewal is £10,976 a year on that supply alone. Renewing it is a buying decision to start now, outside this plan. Levy: £24,232 a year; an agreement would cut it by about £22,317 if your process qualifies; food processes may qualify, so ask the sector association.
Dark bars rest on a sub-meter, equipment ratings × hours or the summer gas baseload; light bars on an estimate. Red is the share the chosen measures should cut if they work. Out of hours the bakery still draws 30% of its electricity; leaving out the refrigeration and IT that must run round the clock, about £35,308 a year of it could be switched off. The switch-off trial names the extraction fans and the kit left idling.
| Measure | Plan | Cost now | Net saving in year one | Expected payback | Net present value | If half as well |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Solar PV, 150 kWp, on the cold store roof Cold store · all uses · 135,000 kWh a year, 90% used on site · supplier quotation or survey, 75% chance | Do | £122,280 | £22,888 | 5.3 yrs | £108,167 | −£15,846 |
| LED high-bay and panel lighting with presence sensors Bakery · lighting · 55% cut if it works · supplier quotation or survey, 75% chance | Do | £38,224 | £11,455 | 3.3 yrs | £48,104 | £4,940 |
| Cold store: strip curtains, condenser cleaning, controls reset Cold store · refrigeration · 12% cut if it works · supplier quotation or survey, 75% chance | Do | £8,812 | £7,131 | 1.2 yrs | £24,154 | £6,284 |
| Find and fix compressed-air leaks; compressor off at weekends Bakery · compressed air · 30% cut if it works · supplier quotation or survey, 75% chance | Do | £2,968 | £6,262 | 0.5 yrs | £22,034 | £7,066 |
| Switch-off routine: oven controls and kit left idling Bakery · other · 20% cut if it works · measured trial, 90% chance | Do | £368 | £6,770 | 0.1 yrs | £17,079 | £7,417 |
| Variable-speed drives on the extraction fans and pumps Bakery · motors and drives · 15% cut if it works · estimate, 50% chance | Do | £19,668 | £4,790 | 4.1 yrs | £12,476 | −£3,596 |
| Switch-off routine: extraction fans off out of hours Bakery · motors and drives · 8% cut if it works · measured trial, 90% chance | Do | £368 | £4,271 | 0.1 yrs | £10,638 | £4,197 |
| Heat recovery from oven flues to pre-heat hot water Bakery · hot water · 50% cut if it works · supplier quotation or survey, 75% chance | Park | £45,280 | £1,588 | 28.5 yrs | −£31,686 | −£41,479 |
| Air-source heat pump for the offices and canteen Bakery · heating · 35% cut if it works · estimate, 50% chance | Park | £50,168 | −£2,022 | never | −£67,473 | −£67,473 |
Each gain counts at the chance it delivers on its evidence; a loss counts in full. Measures on the same use apply to what the ones above leave: the drives act on the fans the switch-off routine has already turned off at night, and the solar panels on what the cold store work leaves, with 0.5% a year less output and an inverter at year 12. The heat recovery is £31,686 short at 8% and parked; the heat pump would cost more in electricity than it saves in gas at today’s unit rates (a net present value of −£67,473), and has no survey yet.
Spend and kWh come from the last 12 months of bills by site and fuel, annualised by the months they cover. Savings are valued at the unit rate plus the climate change levy (after any agreement), held at today’s rates; standing and other charges don’t change. Uses are split on the stated evidence (11% of the kWh by estimate); the switch-off prize leaves out uses that run 24/7. Each measure saves its share of what the chosen measures above it on the same use leave, and whole-site measures act on what’s left after those; each gain counts at the chance it delivers (90% measured trial, 75% quotation or survey, 60% published guidance, 50% estimate: assumed), but a loss (a heat pump costing more in electricity than it saves in gas) counts in full. Values are before tax, at 8% a year over each measure’s life, with any yearly fall in the saving and replacement parts, your team’s time at £28 an hour and savings from day one. Carbon uses the UK government’s factors on Inputs.
The biggest single value, the solar panels, rests on the installer’s yield estimate and on 90% of it being used on site; ask for both in writing, check them against the half-hourly data, and get the network operator’s connection approval. Kilnbury is well below the size where SECR or ESOS apply, and it isn’t part of a larger group. This is a planning tool, not regulated or tax advice: get surveys and quotations before committing, and the capital allowances from your accountant.
Fictional, continuing the example. After the plan, Kilnbury chose the guided route and set up the agent in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to the suppliers' online accounts, the half-hourly data and the inbox where the bills arrive (its IT confirmed this before it committed). On the 10th of each month it adds the new bills to a new dated copy of the workbook in place of the same month a year earlier, refreshes the out-of-hours share, runs the 20 checks, compares the results with the lines the managing director set on Inputs, logs what it finds and sends the operations manager a short note. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it: the agent never queried a bill, changed a contract or touched a control.
| Date | What the agent found | What people decided |
|---|---|---|
| 10 Nov 2026 Flag | Bakery electricity: October bill's unit rate above the contract rate | Queried with the supplier, who found a charge wrongly billed in the unit rate and agreed a credit |
| 10 Dec 2026 No flag | Bakery electricity: credit received; November billed at the contract rate | None needed |
| 10 Dec 2026 No flag | Out-of-hours share of the bakery's electricity down after the switch-off routine started | None needed |
| 11 Jan 2027 Flag | Out-of-hours share above your 25% line in December | Fans added to the shutdown checklist, signed off by the last person out |
| 11 Jan 2027 Flag | Bakery gas: December up more than your 10% line on December 2025 | Weather checked: December was no colder than last year. The maintenance engineer found oven 2's burner out of adjustment; serviced on 14 January |
| 11 Jan 2027 Flag | Bakery gas contract now ends within your 9 months | Asked two suppliers for quotations by the end of February, alongside the electricity renewal due 31 March |
At the check-in on 30 November, after the first monthly run, Geoff and the managing director read the first log together and left every line where it was. After that the agent, its accounts and its log were Kilnbury's.
The billing error was credited in full (£1,472, a correction, not a saving from the plan). The other flags kept the plan on track: the switch-off routine slipped over Christmas and was put right, an oven fault showed up in the gas bill within a month, and the gas renewal was started in time to buy before the contract ends. Reading the monthly note and recording decisions took the operations manager about 20 minutes a month (estimate). The LED lighting is due in February; the agent will show whether the bakery's electricity falls as the plan expects. The months after add nothing to the figures above.
Fictional and labelled: these events continue the worked example. The same six events are the sample rows in the Agent log of the worked-example spreadsheet. The agent is part of the guided and done-for-you routes; the self-implement kit does not include it.