Three country-house and coastal hotels in North Yorkshire with restaurants, weddings and events; founded in 1968 by the present directors' parents. 112 staff; the third generation now joining the second.
Verdict: The constitution covers 9 adults in 3 branches; every adult was interviewed one-to-one. They raised 12 issues: 11 are answered by a clause, a linked policy or the solicitor, 1 still open. The matrix gives each of 12 decisions an owner; 5 need the solicitor to change the articles or a shareholders' agreement, and 5 shareholder decisions can be blocked by one branch alone. 15 clauses cover 9 of the 9 required sections; 0 of 13 items on the solicitor's list are adopted. Before the work, 42% of the family's answers about who decides were right as things stood (target at the re-measure, against the agreed matrix: 85%): direction only: the target change shows only if every answer counts on its own, which they don't. The articles are based on Table A (1985); the solicitor must read the actual articles. New articles need 75%, so 3 holders (branches voting as blocs) can each block them, and a shareholders' agreement binds only those who sign it. How the value is shown (risk avoided, not a forecast): the largest event, “An unfair-prejudice petition by a family shareholder (Companies Act 2006 s994)”, would cost £232,380 from the owner's figures and the solicitor's estimates. With the owner's assumed likelihoods, the 4 events cost £32,932 a year on average; if the constitution works as assumed it cuts that by £25,067 (£12,533 if half as well), against £11,843 a year including the solicitor's fees, paid directly. Re-measure on 16 Apr 2027; first review 28 Nov 2029.
| Member | Branch | Gen | Circles and role | Shares | Council |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Marguerite | Marguerite's branch | 2 | owner, director Chair of the board | 25% | Yes |
| Anselm | Anselm's branch | 2 | owner, director, employee Property and maintenance director | 33% | Yes |
| Philippa | Philippa's branch | 2 | owner None (retired GP) | 20% | Yes |
| Corin | Marguerite's branch | 3 | owner, director, employee Managing director | 10% | No |
| Saffron | Marguerite's branch | 3 | family only None (lives in Bristol) | – | Yes |
| Thaddeus | Anselm's branch | 3 | employee Operations manager, the coast hotel | – | No |
| Lowenna | Anselm's branch | 3 | family only None (teacher) | – | Yes |
| Ivo | Philippa's branch | 3 | owner, employee General manager, the Dales hotel | 6% | No |
| Clemency | Philippa's branch | 3 | owner, employee Marketing and events manager | 6% | Yes |
Shares: Marguerite's branch 35%; Anselm's branch 33%; Philippa's branch 32%; outside the family 0%. Every branch holds more than 25%, so any decision that needs 75% needs all three branches: the constitution’s conflict route is the way through a block. Spouses and partners, and 4 members under 18, are not on the register.
| Theme | Issues | Mentions | High | Answered | Open |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides | 2 | 9 | 1 | 2 | 0 |
| Information and communication | 1 | 5 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
| Working in the business | 2 | 7 | 1 | 2 | 0 |
| Pay and dividends | 1 | 5 | 1 | 1 | 0 |
| Shares and succession | 3 | 9 | 2 | 2 | 1 |
| Conflict between members | 1 | 4 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
| Values and direction | 1 | 3 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
| Family membership | 1 | 2 | 0 | 1 | 0 |
| Issue (in the consultant’s words) | Members | Branches | Severity | Answered by |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nobody is sure whether the board or the family decides who runs each hotel Who decides | 6 | 3 | High | Addressed by a clause C6 |
| Branches that don't work in the business hear about results only at the annual meeting Information and communication | 5 | 3 | Medium | Addressed by a clause C7 |
| Some think working family members are paid above the market; others that they are underpaid for the hours Working in the business | 4 | 3 | High | Referred to a linked policy Family Employment Policy |
| Dividends have been irregular and nobody knows how they are set Pay and dividends | 5 | 3 | High | Referred to a linked policy Dividend Policy |
| Shares could pass to a spouse on divorce, or by will to someone outside the family Shares and succession | 4 | 2 | High | Addressed by a clause C12 |
| There is no agreed way for a member who wants to sell to get out, or at what price Shares and succession | 3 | 2 | High | Addressed by a clause C11 |
| Big decisions need all three branches, and one branch has said no before Who decides | 3 | 2 | Medium | Addressed by a clause C14 |
| A disagreement about the coast hotel refurbishment was never settled and still comes up Conflict between members | 4 | 3 | Medium | Addressed by a clause C14 |
| The next generation don't know what is expected of them if they want to work here Working in the business | 3 | 2 | Medium | Referred to a linked policy Family Employment Policy |
| Selling one of the hotels has been discussed without everyone being asked Values and direction | 3 | 2 | Medium | Addressed by a clause C13 |
| Who leads the business after the present generation is never discussed Shares and succession | 2 | 2 | Medium | Open |
| Spouses and partners feel shut out of family discussions Family membership | 2 | 2 | Low | Addressed by a clause C5 |
| Decision | Who decides, by what vote | How it binds | Fewest branches to pass | Branches that can block |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| D1 Set the strategy and the three-year plan consulted first: The family council, on the values and long-term direction | Board more than half | Already binding | ||
| D2 Appoint a director (each branch may nominate one family director) consulted first: The family council, on the nominee | Shareholders more than half | Binding once the shareholders' agreement is signed | 2 | 0 |
| D3 Remove a director consulted first: The family council first, unless the board must act at once | Shareholders more than half | Already binding | 2 | 0 |
| D4 Employ a family member, and set their pay consulted first: The family council confirms they meet the Family Employment Policy | Managing director one person decides | Family agreement (moral) | ||
| D5 Declare a dividend (the board recommends under the Dividend Policy) consulted first: The family council, on the policy | Shareholders more than half | Already binding | 2 | 0 |
| D6 Transfer shares to anyone who is not a founder's descendant consulted first: The other family shareholders get first refusal | Shareholders 75% or more | Binding once the articles are changed | 3 | 3 |
| D7 Sell the business, or one of the hotels consulted first: The family council and the family assembly | Shareholders 75% or more | Binding once the shareholders' agreement is signed | 3 | 3 |
| D8 Borrow more than £500,000, or give security over a hotel consulted first: The family council | Shareholders 75% or more | Binding once the shareholders' agreement is signed | 3 | 3 |
| D9 Issue new shares other than to existing holders in proportion consulted first: The family council | Shareholders 75% or more | Binding once the shareholders' agreement is signed | 3 | 3 |
| D10 Change the articles consulted first: The family council and the solicitor | Shareholders 75% or more | Already binding | 3 | 3 |
| D11 Decide who may join the family council and the family assembly consulted first: The family council proposes | Family assembly two-thirds or more | Family agreement | ||
| D12 Change this constitution consulted first: The family council proposes; clauses with legal effect also need the shareholders | Family assembly two-thirds or more | Family agreement |
Checked against the company-law rules on Inputs (Companies Act 2006 ss21, 168, 283, 561, 569; the model articles; checked on legislation.gov.uk on 16 October 2026; not legal advice). The company’s 1987 articles are based on Table A (1985), so the table shows Table A’s provisions (reg 24 lets the board refuse only partly paid shares, so a fully paid share can go to anyone today; dividends under regs 102–103); the solicitor must read the actual articles. A director can be removed by ordinary resolution whatever an agreement with the director says (s168), but weighted voting rights in the articles (Bushell v Faith [1970] AC 1099) or a voting agreement between shareholders can protect one: whether to protect each branch’s nominated director is on the solicitor’s list as a question. The voting test assumes each branch votes as a bloc. Adoption: {esc(K[29])}.
| Clause | Kind | Linked policy | Issues it answers |
|---|---|---|---|
| C1 Our values Values | Family agreement | – | 0 |
| C2 Why we own Kelderwick together Purpose | Family agreement | – | 0 |
| C3 Who is a member of the family Membership | Family agreement | – | 0 |
| C4 The family council Family council | Family agreement | – | 0 |
| C5 The family assembly Family assembly | Family agreement | – | 1 |
| C6 Who decides what Decision rights | Needs legal effect Shareholders' agreement | – | 1 |
| C7 Meetings and what every owner is told Meetings and information | Family agreement | – | 1 |
| C8 Working in the business Family employment | Family agreement | Family Employment Policy | 0 |
| C9 Dividends Dividends | Family agreement | Dividend Policy | 0 |
| C10 Who may own shares Shares and transfers | Needs legal effect Articles | Ownership Transfer Plan | 0 |
| C11 Selling shares within the family Shares and transfers | Needs legal effect Articles | Ownership Transfer Plan | 1 |
| C12 Shares on divorce or death Shares and transfers | Needs legal effect Articles | Ownership Transfer Plan | 1 |
| C13 Selling the business Shares and transfers | Needs legal effect Shareholders' agreement | – | 1 |
| C14 When we disagree Conflict route | Needs legal effect Shareholders' agreement | – | 2 |
| C15 Reviewing and changing this constitution Review and amendment | Family agreement | – | 0 |
When we disagree. 1. Talk directly, within 14 days. 2. If that fails, either side asks the family council chair, who appoints two council members from branches not involved to help, within 30 days. 3. If that fails, mediation with a mediator registered with the Civil Mediation Council, chosen together, within 60 days, the fee shared equally. 4. Only then will any of us start legal proceedings: a promise between us that does not take away anyone's right to petition the court under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006. Nobody speaks to the staff, guests or press about a family disagreement.
| Step | Who | Within (days) | What happens |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Talk directly | The members involved | 14 | Meet in person; say what each needs; agree the next step in writing |
| 2. Family council | The council chair and two council members from branches not involved | 30 | Hear each side separately, then together; propose a way forward |
| 3. Mediation | A mediator registered with the Civil Mediation Council, chosen together | 60 | Confidential; the fee shared equally; any agreement written and signed |
| 4. Legal action | Each side's own solicitor | – | Only after mediation; the right to petition under section 994 of the Companies Act 2006 stays with every member |
The first meeting, 10 December 2026, The Dales hotel, private dining room:
| Agenda item | Led by | Minutes |
|---|---|---|
| Welcome; the constitution as adopted on 28 November; ground rules | Philippa (chair) | 10 |
| Adopt the terms of reference; confirm the chair and secretary | Philippa (chair) | 15 |
| The decision-rights matrix: who decides what, and why | Consultant | 25 |
| What the one-to-ones raised: answered, referred and still open | Consultant | 20 |
| The Family Employment and Dividend policies: timetable | Corin | 15 |
| The solicitor's list: what changes in the articles and a shareholders' agreement | Marguerite | 20 |
| Dates for 2027; actions and owners | Clemency (secretary) | 15 |
| What must change | Document | Source | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| L1 New articles: only the founders' descendants and family trusts may hold shares (permitted transferees) | Articles | C10 | Briefed |
| L2 New articles: pre-emption on transfer, own branch first, at a fair value set by an independent valuer, no minority discount | Articles | C11 | Briefed |
| L3 New articles: compulsory transfer if shares pass by court order or will to someone who may not hold them | Articles | C12 | Briefed |
| L4 New articles: no transfer registered to anyone other than a founder's descendant or a family trust without 75% of the shareholders | Articles | D6 | Briefed |
| L5 Shareholders' agreement: reserved matters listed from the decision-rights matrix, binding on every shareholder | Shareholders' agreement | C6 | Briefed |
| L6 Shareholders' agreement: each branch may nominate one family director | Shareholders' agreement | D2 | Briefed |
| L7 Shareholders' agreement: reserved matter, selling the business or a hotel needs 75% | Shareholders' agreement | D7 | Briefed |
| L8 Shareholders' agreement: reserved matter, borrowing over £500,000 or security over a hotel needs 75% | Shareholders' agreement | D8 | Briefed |
| L9 Shareholders' agreement: reserved matter, issuing shares other than in proportion needs 75% | Shareholders' agreement | D9 | Briefed |
| L10 Shareholders' agreement: drag-along and tag-along at 75% on a sale of the whole business | Shareholders' agreement | C13 | Briefed |
| L11 Shareholders' agreement: mediation before any legal proceedings between shareholders | Shareholders' agreement | C14 | Briefed |
| L12 Wills: each shareholder asked to leave shares to descendants or a family trust (each with their own solicitor) | Wills | C12 | To brief |
| L13 Question: should each branch's nominated director be protected against removal, by weighted voting rights in the articles (Bushell v Faith) or a voting agreement in the shareholders' agreement? | Articles | D2 | To brief |
Without the constitution With it (the owner's assumption)
| Event | Cost without | With it | Reduction | Likelihood (assumed) | Expected cost a year | Break-even: once in N years (half as well) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A deadlock between branches that freezes a big decision legal costs: solicitor's estimate | £109,240 | £33,963 | £75,277 | 1 in 7 own history | £16,386 | 6 (3) |
| Shares passing to an ex-spouse by a court order on divorce legal costs: solicitor's estimate | £158,600 | £33,350 | £125,250 | 1 in 25 adviser's view | £6,344 | 11 (5) |
| An unfair-prejudice petition by a family shareholder (Companies Act 2006 s994) legal costs: solicitor's estimate | £232,380 | £32,007 | £200,373 | 1 in 33 adviser's view | £6,971 | 17 (8) |
| Shares left by will to someone outside the family legal costs: owner's estimate | £107,700 | £15,900 | £91,800 | 1 in 33 owner's judgement | £3,231 | 8 (4) |
Each cost is gross profit lost while a decision is frozen (£357,667 a month, counted from the accounts, times the months and the share lost), legal and adviser costs (the solicitor’s estimates), other costs such as paying above a fair value to get shares back, and the family’s hours at £45 an hour. Everything “with it” is the owner’s assumption. With the owner’s assumed likelihoods (not a forecast), the events cost £32,932 a year across 4 events on average; if the constitution works as assumed it cuts that by £25,067 a year; £12,533 if half as well. Cost in full: £6,500 consultant; £4,320 family time; £15,240 outside advisers; £7,500 a year to keep up; £11,843 a year with the build spread over 6 years. The break-even needs no likelihood: the yearly cost is covered if the constitution saves its assumed amount on that event once in that many years.
| Measure | Now | Aim | Re-measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Answers about who decides that are right (before: as things stood; then: the agreed matrix) | 42% (30 of 72) | target 85% (assumed) | 16 Apr 2027 |
| Issues from the one-to-ones answered (a clause, a linked policy or the solicitor) | 11 of 12 | all high-severity answered | 16 Apr 2027 |
| Solicitor's list adopted (documents aligned) | 0 of 13 | all adopted | 16 Apr 2027 |
Sized before it was sent out. 8 questions × 9 adults gives 72 answers a round. Showing the owner's target change (43 percentage points) at 80% power needs about 15 answers if every answer counted on its own; but one person's answers move together, and counting each adult once the smallest change the survey can show is 65 points (23 if every answer counted). So: Direction only: the target change shows only if every answer counts on its own, which they don't. Small counts: direction, not proof.
The family register, shares, issues, decision rights and clauses are as agreed with the family on 16 Oct 2026; the issues come from 9 one-to-one conversations and are recorded as counts, not names. The company-law rules on Inputs were checked on legislation.gov.uk on 16 October 2026 for England and Wales, with the standard provisions for Table A (1985); they are not legal advice, and only the family's solicitor, reading the actual articles, can say what they and a shareholders' agreement must say. The voting test assumes each branch votes as a bloc. Gross profit a month is counted from the accounts; legal costs are the solicitor's estimates or quotations as each row says, and the outside advisers' fees are the family's own cost. Months disrupted, other costs and hours, how far the constitution reduces them, and each event's likelihood a year are the owner's estimates and assumptions, not tested and never facts, so the expected costs hold only with those likelihoods. The survey rests on 9 adults and 8 questions, scored before against the rules as they stood and later against the agreed matrix: it shows direction, not proof.
The constitution is finished when the family signs it at the assembly and the solicitor has the list. It binds morally from that day; the clauses marked “needs legal effect” bind only once the new articles and the shareholders’ agreement are adopted.