Tractors, combines and farm machinery sold, serviced and repaired from two depots on the Welsh border, with a parts counter and field service engineers. 88 staff, six of them family.
Verdict: 6 family employees are on the register and 6 have been assessed against the policy. Now: 2 paid within band, 3 outside it and 1 below the legal minimum wage (arrears £180 to pay now); £23,600 a year of family pay is more than the hours worked would earn at the band maximum, which HMRC could disallow; 4 report to a relative and 1 had a review by a non-family reviewer in the last 12 months. Under the policy: 5 of 6 staying are within band (1 exception agreed by the board in writing), 0 report to a relative, and 6 have a named non-family reviewer. The policy has 16 clauses covering 13 of 13 areas, agreed by the board 14 Oct 2026. How the value is shown (risk avoided, not a forecast): the largest event, “An equal pay or discrimination claim”, would cost £46,000. With the owner's assumed likelihoods the 4 events cost £11,034 a year on average; if the policy works as assumed it cuts that by £4,250 (£2,125 if half as well), against £9,217 a year in full (pay increases, among them £4,720 a year raising non-family colleagues to close an equal pay gap, reviews and the build spread over 5 years), so on these risks alone it doesn't pay its way unless it works better than assumed or the events are more likely. 37% of the non-family staff who answered agree the rules are the same for everyone; with 41 responses the survey shows direction only, not proof. Re-measure on 16 Apr 2027.
| Family member | Pay now | Now | Under the policy | Under the policy | Non-family reviewer |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dermot owner · Managing director | £96,000 40 paid, 50 worked | In band reports to Board (chair: Gideon, non-executive director) | £96,000 40 hours | In band reports to Board (chair: Gideon, non-executive director) | Gideon (non-executive director) |
| Rosalind spouse or partner · Accounts assistant (part-time) | £30,000 20 paid, 8 worked | Above band reports to Dermot | £7,400 10 hours | In band reports to Tamsin (finance manager) | Tamsin (finance manager) |
| Ewan son · Service manager (north depot) | £54,000 40 paid, 48 worked | Above band reports to Dermot | £54,000 40 hours | Above band (board's reason) reports to Lorna (operations director) | Lorna (operations director) |
| Imogen daughter · Parts adviser | £26,800 40 paid, 40 worked | Below band reports to Nadine (parts manager) | £28,000 40 hours | In band reports to Nadine (parts manager) | Nadine (parts manager) |
| Fergus nephew · Field service engineer | £38,500 40 paid, 42 worked | In band reports to Ewan | £38,500 40 hours | In band reports to Bram (workshop foreman) | Bram (workshop foreman) |
| Harvey grandson · Saturday yard and wash bay | £3,120 8 paid, 8 worked | Below the legal minimum reports to Ewan | £3,546 8 hours | Youth or apprentice rate reports to Bram (workshop foreman) | Bram (workshop foreman) |
First names only; non-family colleagues appear on the Comparators sheet by ID, never by name.
Now (full-time equivalent ÷ band midpoint) Under the policy Harvey, under 18, is paid the young workers’ rate and left out.
Against non-family colleagues in the same role: 2 more than 10% apart; 2 flagged by the equal pay screen. Ewan is above his band and is red-circled: his pay is held, not cut, until the band reaches it, because a cut needs his agreement (the board’s written reason is on the register).
| Finding | Who | What the register shows | Under the policy |
|---|---|---|---|
| HMRC: wholly and exclusively | Rosalind | £30,000 a year for about 8 hours a week worked: £23,600 more than those hours would earn at the band maximum | New contract agreed with Rosalind: 10 hours a week at the band midpoint; the tax adviser on any change to dividends (Dermot) |
| Equal pay screen | Ewan | Full-time equivalent £54,000; 1 colleague of the other sex in the same role more than 10% apart | A prompt to check with the employment solicitor, not a finding |
| Equal pay screen | Imogen | Full-time equivalent £26,800; 1 colleague of the other sex in the same role more than 10% apart | A prompt to check with the employment solicitor, not a finding |
| Legal minimum wage | Harvey | Paid £3,120 a year for 8 hours a week: £7.48 an hour against £8.00 for the age band; arrears of £180 to pay now | Onto the payroll at £8.50 an hour from 1 November 2026; arrears of £180 paid with October's pay (Tamsin) |
Family members working for a limited company are entitled to the minimum wage: the family-household exemption doesn’t apply to a company (HMRC NMWM05160). HMRC can disallow pay set by the relationship rather than the work (BIM47105). Not legal or tax advice.
| Area | Clause (as agreed) | Applies it |
|---|---|---|
| Scope and definitions | Covers anyone related to a shareholder or director by blood, marriage, civil partnership or living together, and their partners, who works here paid or unpaid, including summer and Saturday work. Shareholders who don't work here are outside it. | Managing director |
| Entry | Family members join only into a vacancy that exists and is advertised, in open competition, interviewed by a panel led by a non-family manager. No job is created for a family member. | Operations director |
| Entry | A management role needs at least three years' work outside the business and the same qualifications asked of anyone else. Those already in post without it follow a development plan. | Operations director |
| Pay | Family members are paid on the same bands as everyone else, set from the Pay Structure Review and checked each year. Pay above the band maximum needs the board's written reason; it is held, not cut, until the band reaches it. | Finance manager |
| Pay | Pay reflects the work done and the hours worked. Anything a family member receives as an owner is paid as a dividend or drawing, on the tax adviser's advice, not as wages. | Finance manager |
| Pay | Everyone who works for the company, family included, is on the payroll and paid at least the legal minimum wage for their age. | Finance manager |
| Performance | Family members have the same yearly review, form and ratings as everyone else, held by a non-family manager; the managing director's by the non-executive director. A poor rating leads to the same improvement plan, for the same time. | Operations director |
| Development | Each family member has a written development plan with dates, reviewed at the yearly review. Time working outside the business is encouraged before joining. | Operations director |
| Promotion | Family members apply for promotion like anyone else, against the same criteria, decided by a panel led by a non-family manager. Being family counts neither for nor against. | Operations director |
| Reporting lines | No family member reports to, reviews, or sets the pay of a relative. Where it can't be avoided, the board records why, and a non-family manager reviews them. | Managing director |
| Exit | Family members leave under the same procedures, notice and terms as anyone else, following the Acas Code. A graceful exit is offered to anyone the role no longer fits: a fair date, a reference, help to find work elsewhere, and their place in the family unchanged. | Managing director |
| Younger relatives | Summer and Saturday work for relatives under 18 is paid at the same rate as other young workers, on the payroll. Children of school age work only with the council's permit where its byelaws need one, within the legal hours, never in the workshop, and never supervised by a parent. | Workshop foreman |
| Spouses and partners | Spouses and partners join under the same entry rules, never report to their partner, and have a non-family reviewer. A separation does not end their job; it is handled under the normal procedures. | Managing director |
| Non-family staff | Non-family staff can raise any concern about family favouritism with the non-executive director in confidence, without detriment. Vacancies and promotions are open to them on the same terms; the yearly survey asks whether the rules are the same for everyone. | Non-executive director |
| Exceptions and governance | The board agrees every exception in writing, with a reason and a review date. The non-executive director reports on the policy to the board each year and the policy is reviewed every two years. | Non-executive director |
| Personal data | The register holds first names only for family members and IDs for everyone else, is kept by the finance manager, seen only by the managing director, finance manager and non-executive director, and is used only to apply this policy (UK GDPR; covered by the staff privacy notice). | Finance manager |
| Event | Cost | Likelihood | Removes | Expected | Reduction | Break-even |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| A key non-family manager or engineer leaves over favouritism staff turnover cost review | £14,600 | 1 in 2 own history | 40% | £7,300 | £2,920 | 1.6 |
| An equal pay or discrimination claim estimated | £46,000 | 1 in 20 adviser's view | 40% | £2,300 | £920 | 5.0 |
| HMRC disallows part of family pay as not wholly and exclusively for the business estimated | £44,710 | 1 in 33 adviser's view | 50% | £1,341 | £335 | 4.9 |
| HMRC finds a minimum wage underpayment estimated | £1,860 | 1 in 20 owner's judgement | 80% | £93 | £74 | 0.2 |
Cost: one event. Likelihood a year and the share the policy removes: the owner’s assumptions. Expected cost and reduction: a year, with those assumptions; for HMRC the reduction counts only on the years after the policy (50% of the 6-year window, careless), because years already filed can’t change. Break-even: the yearly cost is covered if the policy prevents the event once in this many years.
With the owner’s assumed likelihoods (not a forecast) the 4 events cost £11,034 a year on average; if the policy works as assumed it cuts that by £4,250 a year (£2,125 if half as well). Cost in full: £6,612 to build (advisers £2,100); £7,895 a year to run, pay increases included; £9,217 a year with the build spread over 5 years. On these four risks alone it doesn't pay its way unless it works better than assumed or the events are more likely. The break-even column needs no likelihood: preventing one key leaver every 1.6 years covers the policy’s yearly cost. About half of that cost is the £4,000 a year (before on-costs) raising the south depot’s service manager so that she and Ewan are within 10%: the correction the equal pay screen found, on the solicitor’s advice. Harvey’s rise to the legal minimum (£256 a year with on-costs) is owed anyway and isn’t counted; the tax effect of taking Rosalind’s pay as dividends instead is for the tax adviser and isn’t counted either way. It doesn’t value better successors, which is the reason most owners do it. The £22,600 a year taken off Rosalind’s pay isn’t counted as a saving: it reaches the family another way.
| Measure | Now | Under the policy | Re-measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Family pay within band (or a youth rate) | 2 of 6 | 5 of 6 | 16 Apr 2027 |
| Reviews by a non-family reviewer | 1 of 6 | 6 of 6 named | 16 Apr 2027 |
| Joined by open competition | 1 of 6 | every future family hire and promotion | 16 Apr 2027 |
| Reporting to a relative | 4 | 0 | 16 Apr 2027 |
| Non-family staff agreeing the rules are the same for everyone (survey) | 37% of 41 | target 60% (assumed) | 16 Apr 2027 (direction only) |
The survey had 41 responses: the smallest change it could show four times in five is 31 percentage points, and the owner’s target needs 72 responses each time. It is a snapshot; the counted measures carry the case.
The register is as the owner gave it from payroll, contracts and review records on 16 Oct 2026; hours actually worked are from timesheets or the owner's estimate. The bands are from the source named on Bands; non-family colleagues are compared by ID, role and full-time equivalent pay, and the equal pay screen is a prompt to check, not a legal finding. The legal minimum wage rates, child employment hours, corporation tax rate and minimum wage penalty were checked on gov.uk on 16 October 2026; this is not legal or tax advice, and the employment solicitor and tax adviser should review the policy and family pay. Each event's cost comes from the owner's figures, the register or an adviser's estimate as its row says; its likelihood a year and the share the policy removes are the owner's assumptions, never facts, so the expected costs hold only with those assumptions; the behaviour HMRC would find (which sets the years it goes back and the penalty) and the penalty share are assumed, and the policy's effect on that event counts only on the years after it; rises to the legal minimum owed anyway are shown but not counted, and so is the tax effect of pay reductions replaced by dividends. The survey rests on 41 responses: direction only, not proof.
The policy is finished when the board has agreed it and it is handed over with the register; its first test is the reviews held by the non-family reviewers.