Online retailer of walking, camping and climbing gear, shipping from its own warehouse. 60 staff. The process: customer returns: from the parcel arriving to the refund and the item back in stock or written off. Event: 4 days from 7 September 2026.
Verdict: A 4-day event with 8 people (4 from the process) cost £8,313. Of 6 measures, 5 were re-measured at 30 days and 3 met their target; 2 slipped after the event. The gains counted free 900 hours a year (300 cutting overtime, the rest capacity), save £6,300 a year in cash and release £19,100 of cash from stock. Net of audits, that’s £14,916 a year; the event paid for itself at once. 3 follow-up actions are still open.
| Measure | Baseline | Target | After | 30 days | Baseline to target: ○ after, ● 30 days |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Time to process a return minutes · lower is better · minutes per unit | 18 | 10 | 11 | 12 | Missed Slipped |
| Days from parcel arriving to refund days · lower is better · not valued | 6 | 2 | 2 | 2 | Met |
| Returns waiting to be processed £ at cost · lower is better · stock (£ one-off) | £42,000 | £12,000 | £15,000 | £16,000 | Missed Slipped |
| Items written off per 100 returns · lower is better · £ a year per unit | 8 | 4 | 4 | – | Not yet re-measured |
| Walking per return metres · lower is better · not valued | 60 | 15 | 15 | 15 | Met |
| Returns graded right first time % · higher is better · not valued | 82% | 95% | 93% | 95% | Met |
Two gains slipped after the event: processing time crept back from 11 to 12 minutes and the returns cage from £15,000 to £16,000, because grading still has no written standard (an action due 30 October). Write-offs can't be confirmed until a full month is counted, so they count at 50% for now. The returns cage is down £26,000, but refunds now go out about four days sooner (£6,900 paid out earlier), so the cash released is £19,100. Only measured results are valued; targets never are.
Cost: 203 team hours and 24 hours of preparation at £19 an hour, £2,400 for the facilitator, £500 of materials and £1,100 of agency cover for the returns desk: £8,313 in all.
| Action | Owner | Due | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
| Move the returns cage next to the bench | Returns team leader | 10 Sep | Done |
| Label printer at the returns bench | IT systems lead | 18 Sep | Done |
| Refund approval limit raised to £150 for the team leader | Operations manager | 14 Sep | Done |
| Standard work for grading a return, with photos | Returns team leader | 30 Oct | Open |
| Return reason codes on the website returns form | IT systems lead | 30 Nov | Open |
| Weekly write-off count posted on the board | Returns team leader | 19 Oct | Open |
Reviewed every Friday by the operations manager with the team leader until the list is empty; the returns process is audited weekly (26 hours a year) to hold the gains.
Only measured results count, never targets: results confirmed at 30 days count in full; those measured only straight after the event count at 50%. Hours freed count as money only up to the overtime or agency hours the process could cut, at that rate; the rest is capacity. Stock released, less any cash paid out sooner (such as faster refunds), is one-off cash, with 10% a year holding cost saved. The event’s cost includes everyone’s time, preparation included, at the full hourly cost, the facilitator, materials and cover. Faster refunds, happier customers and the skills the team gained are not valued.