Lease or Buy Decision · October 2026

Ellerby Fresh Produce Ltd

Wholesale fruit, vegetables and salads to restaurants, schools and care homes across East and North Yorkshire. 38 staff. A 2.5-tonne electric forklift truck and charger for the cold store, compared over 5 years.

Worked example. Ellerby Fresh Produce and its quotations are fictional. All figures come from the worked-example spreadsheet: ALL CHECKS PASSED. The tax treatment is simplified and is not tax advice: check it with your accountant.
The headline

Buy outright is cheapest, but only just: hire purchase keeps £33,950 in the bank for £546 more

Cheapest
£28,965
Buy outright: after tax, in today's money; equivalent to £560 a month
Cash kept
£33,950
Hire purchase needs £4,050 at the start against £38,000
Close behind
+£546
Hire purchase costs this much more over 5 years, in today's money
The price of flexibility
+£16,972
Short-term hire: hand it back any month, but the dearest by far

Verdict: Buy outright costs least: £28,965 after tax in today's money, £546 less than Hire purchase; Short-term hire needs least cash at the start. Buying outright and hire purchase are within £546 of each other over five years, so the real question is cash: if paying £38,000 now would mean using the overdraft or leave the business short, hire purchase is the better choice at almost no extra cost. If the business has spare cash earning 4%, buying outright wins more clearly (Buy outright is cheapest at that rate too). Contract hire costs £3,266 more but takes maintenance and resale risk away; short-term hire costs £16,972 more for the freedom to hand it back any month.

Side by side

The options

Buy outrightHire purchaseContract hireShort-term hire
TypeBuy outrightBuy with financeLeaseHire
Cash out at the start£38,000£4,050£2,340£0
Total paid, before tax£36,000£43,709£48,400£69,000
Tax relief£9,000£10,927£12,100£17,250
Total cost after tax£27,000£32,782£36,300£51,750
In today's money at 8%£28,965£29,512£32,232£45,938
Equivalent cost a month (not the payment)£560£571£623£888
In today's money at 4%£28,053£31,055£34,154£48,687
If the value at the end is 30% lower£30,500£31,047£32,232£45,938

"In today's money" puts every future payment, tax relief and resale on the same footing as money spent now, at the cost of money shown less tax relief on interest. Ranked cheapest first at 8%. Cash at the start excludes VAT, which is paid up front on a purchase and reclaimed later.

How confident are we?

What this rests on

Each option is costed over 5 years from its quotation: what is paid at the start, finance or rental payments, running costs you pay, fees and, if you own it, what it is worth at the end. Tax relief at 25% is on capital allowances (100% in the first year, 18% a year on the rest, with a balancing adjustment on sale as if it were a single asset), interest, rentals as paid, and running costs, received nine months after each year end. Future amounts are put in today's money at the after-tax cost of money (8.0% before tax), with payments in the middle of each year. VAT is assumed reclaimable and left out, though it is paid up front on a purchase. Under the accounting rules for leases from 2026, tax relief on some leases may follow the accounts rather than the rentals. The tax treatment is a simplification: check it, and the right rates for your business and asset, with your accountant before deciding. Flexibility (handing a hired asset back) and the risk of owning (breakdowns, value) are not priced; weigh them yourself.