Bespoke joinery, staircases and fitted furniture for housebuilders and architects across the West Midlands. 46 staff. Borrowing £400,000 for a five-axis cnc machining centre and dust extraction.
Verdict: Lender A: high-street bank is cheapest at 7.60% a year including fees; but if Bank Rate rises, Lender B: asset finance house would cost less; Lender B: asset finance house has better terms. The two offers within your limits are £1,972 apart over five years. For that, the fixed hire purchase removes the rate risk, the personal guarantee and the debenture, and is in hand today. Which matters more is your call; the numbers say it is close on cost and not close on terms.
| Lender A: high-street bank | Lender B: asset finance house | Lender C: challenger bank | Lender D: online lender | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Product | Term loan | Asset finance | Term loan | Term loan |
| Amount, term | £400,000 60 months | £400,000 60 months | £400,000 72 months 6 interest-only | £350,000 48 months |
| Headline rate | 6.50% variable | 7.40% fixed | 6.20% fixed | 9.90% fixed |
| Fees | £8,500 | £300 | £20,000 | £8,750 |
| True annual cost, including fees | 7.60% | 7.69% | 8.20% | 11.84% |
| Total cost of borrowing | £78,088 | £80,060 | £105,491 | £84,035 |
| If Bank Rate rises 2 points | £100,897 | £80,060 | £105,491 | £84,035 |
| Monthly payment | £7,826 → £8,207 | £7,996 | £7,168 | £8,860 |
| Cover, if Bank Rate rises | 1.70× | 1.75× | 1.95× | 1.58× |
| Personal guarantee | £100,000 | None | £400,000 | £350,000 |
| Security | Debenture | Asset | Debenture and owner’s home | Debenture |
| Covenants | Light | None | Strict | None |
| Early repayment charge | None | 3% | 4% | 2% |
| How firm | Credit-approved | Offer in hand | Indicative only | Offer in hand |
| Terms score | 60 | 81 | 4 | 52 |
| Deal-breaker | – | – | Charge over your home, counted as a guarantee of the whole loan. | Less than you need. Guarantee above your limit. |
Grey = an offer with a deal-breaker against your limits: a guarantee above £150,000, less than £400,000, or cover below 1.50× your £14,000 a month of cash available. True annual cost spreads the fees over the loan, so offers with different fees and terms can be compared fairly.
Each offer is costed from its own terms: interest at the rate now (variable offers at Bank Rate of 3.75% plus the margin, held for the whole term), arrangement and other upfront fees, and account fees. The true annual cost is the yearly rate that makes the loan received, less upfront fees, equal to everything paid back; it lets offers with different fees and terms be compared. Variable offers are also tested with Bank Rate 2.00% higher for the whole term, and cover uses that higher payment. Early repayment charges are not costed, because they only bite if you repay early; nor are VAT or deposits on asset finance. A charge over your home counts as a guarantee of the whole loan. Cover is your cash available each month divided by the highest monthly payment. This is a comparison of the offers in front of you, not financial advice: take advice from your accountant or a broker, and independent legal advice before signing a personal guarantee.