Local Search and Reviews Plan · October 2026

Quillbrook Plumbing and Heating Ltd

Boiler servicing, repairs and bathroom plumbing for homes in and around Leicester. 22 staff.

Worked example. Quillbrook Plumbing and Heating and its figures are fictional. All figures come from the worked-example spreadsheet: ALL CHECKS PASSED (with 1 note).
The headline

Fifth in the map results with a third of the leaders’ reviews; five actions worth £20,340 a year

First-year net
£13,420
£4,945 if the actions do half as well
New customers
60
a year, capped at what the team can take on, from 195 extra enquiries
Rating
115
five-star reviews in a row to reach the top three’s 4.7
Cash
£240
of the £3,530 first-year cost; the rest is your time

Verdict: Your Google profile brings about 101 enquiries a month. Your rating is 4.3 against 4.7 for the top three in the map results, and your reviews 86 against 260. Catching up on reviews, allowing for their own: not even asking every customer: they add about 9 a month, against your 8. The 5 actions to do should bring about 195 extra enquiries and 60 new customers a year, £20,340 of gross profit (£11,340 on first jobs alone), for £3,530 in the first year (£240 of it cash): a first-year net of £13,420 (£4,945 if they do half as well). Best for the money: “Fix the main category; add every service and the areas served”. Risks: 6 failing; 1 not known.

Against the map results

Reviews, rating and recent reviews

Quillbrook (you)86 reviews · 4.3★ · 3 in 3 months · position 5Rival A410 reviews · 4.8★ · 45 in 3 months · position 1Rival B220 reviews · 4.6★ · 18 in 3 months · position 2Rival C150 reviews · 4.7★ · 22 in 3 months · position 3

The three businesses above Quillbrook add about nine reviews a month between them on average; Quillbrook gets one. Asking every customer by text the day the job’s done (eight a month) won’t catch them on numbers, but it stops the gap widening fast and is the quickest way to lift the rating. Include an opt-out and no offer in the text, so it stays a service message.

Action by action

Most gross profit first

ActionPlanExtra enquiries a yearGross profit a yearFirst-year costFirst-year net
Text every customer a review link the day the job is done
Reviews · test result elsewhere · 15% lift if it works, 50% chance
Do91£13,839£1,220£10,313
Fix the main category; add every service and the areas served
Profile · google’s own guidance · 10% lift if it works, 50% chance
Do60£9,226£105£7,584
Add ten photos of real jobs a month
Profile · best practice · 5% lift if it works, 30% chance
Do18£2,768£875£1,432
Make name, address and phone match on 20 directories
Listings elsewhere · best practice · 4% lift if it works, 30% chance
Do15£2,214£210£1,635
Reply to every review within two days
Reviews · best practice · 3% lift if it works, 30% chance
Do11£1,661£875£509
A page on the website for each town served
Website · hunch · 6% lift if it works, 20% chance
Park0–––
Reputation risks

6 failing; 1 not known

CheckStatusFix
Profile claimed and verified by the businessPass–
Opening hours, phone and service areas correctFail1 h
No duplicate or old listings for the businessFail2 h
Every review from the last year answeredFail2 h
No unanswered review of three stars or fewerFail1 h
A review in the last 30 daysFail0 h
Business name, address and phone the same on every directoryFail0 h
No reviews that break Google’s rules left unreported (fake, abusive)Not known1 h

Two unanswered one-star reviews sit near the top of the profile, and an old listing at a previous address still shows. Each is an hour or two to fix.

How confident are we?

What this rests on

Calls, clicks and direction requests come from the Google Business Profile; 60% of calls and 8% of website clicks are new enquiries; 45% become customers, each worth the first job × margin + 50% of £300 later. Each action’s lift counts at the chance it works (50% Google’s guidance or a test elsewhere, 30% best practice, 20% a hunch), building up over 4 months; lifts are added, which is optimistic, and assumed to last. Distance from the searcher matters most in the map results and can’t be changed; competitors were checked on one search from one place.

Track the profile’s calls and clicks monthly; they’re the measure, not the ranking. The extra enquiries would bring more customers than the team can take on (60 a year), so the gain is capped: the next question is hiring or prices.

The months after

What the agent prepared and flagged, and what people decided

Fictional, continuing the example; the log is on the Agent sheet of the worked-example workbook, with no reviewer named, and the months after add nothing to the figures above.

Quillbrook took the guided route. At handover on 20 October 2026 the managing director and Geoff set up the agent together, in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to the Google Business Profile (reviews, details and performance); Quillbrook's IT made the connection beforehand, and the company updated its privacy notice before the first run. Each working morning it drafts a reply to each new review, to be posted within 2 working days, and flags any review of 3 stars or fewer at once, with its reply drafted for the managing director; the office manager approves and posts the rest. A reply thanks the reviewer, or apologises and offers a call, and says nothing about a customer beyond what they wrote. It also checks the profile's details against the Risks sheet, and on the first working day of each month reports the calls, clicks, direction requests and new reviews against the plan. It never posts, never asks anyone for a review and never changes the profile. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it.

DateWhat the agent prepared or flagged, and the evidenceKindApproved or decided byWhat happened
21 Oct 2026Replies drafted to the two unanswered one-star reviews: an apology and an offer to call, nothing about either job beyond what the reviewers wrote
The profile's reviews; Risks, check 5 (no unanswered review of three stars or fewer)
DraftManaging directorPosted by the managing director on 22 Oct. One reviewer rang on 23 Oct and the boiler was re-checked free; nobody was asked to change a review
2 Nov 2026October report: 151 calls, 224 website clicks and 14 direction requests from the profile (the plan's base: 140, 210 and 15); about 109 enquiries at the plan's shares (101); 6 new reviews against the 8 a month expected
Google Business Profile performance for October; the profile's reviews; Inputs (base figures, shares, reviews expected)
DraftManaging directorRead with the plan. No action: the review-request texts only started on 26 Oct
12 Nov 2026The profile's Saturday hours changed to Closed by a Google-suggested edit; the hours recorded on Risks say 8am to 1pm
The profile's details against Risks, check 2 (hours, phone and service areas correct)
FlagOffice managerSaturday hours put back the same day; email alerts for suggested edits switched on for the profile's owner
16 Nov 2026Replies drafted to the 5 new four- and five-star reviews since 2 Nov
The profile's reviews; the reply rule (2 working days)
DraftOffice managerAll 5 posted within 2 working days of each review; two reworded so the replies don't all read alike
1 Dec 2026November report: 162 calls, 231 website clicks and 12 direction requests; about 116 enquiries at the plan's shares; 9 new reviews against 8 expected; rating 4.4
Google Business Profile performance for November; the profile's reviews; Inputs
DraftManaging directorRead with the plan. Keep asking every customer; the photos action to start in January
4 Jan 2027A new one-star review from an account with no other reviews, describing a job the office can't find: it may break Google's rules
The profile's reviews; Risks, check 8 (rule-breaking reviews reported)
FlagManaging directorReported to Google through the profile on 5 Jan, with a short reply saying the office can't find the job and asking the reviewer to call. Google removed it on 19 Jan

At the 30-day check-in on 19 November, Geoff and the managing director read the first month's log and the October report together; his upkeep of the set-up ended there. By January every review had a reply within two working days, the two old one-star reviews were answered, a suggested edit that closed the business on Saturdays was caught the morning it appeared, and a review that broke Google's rules was reported and removed. New reviews ran at about the 8 a month the plan expects. The monthly figures are a direction, not a result: the plan's extra enquiries are judged over a full year, because the season moves calls more than any one action. Approving replies took the office manager about 10 minutes a week, and reading the monthly report the managing director about 15 minutes (estimate).