Mystery Shop Review · Foundation · October 2026

Mardlecote Windows and Doors Ltd

Replacement windows, doors and conservatories for homeowners, surveyed and fitted from three showrooms in Worcestershire. 72 staff.

Worked example. Mardlecote Windows and Doors and its figures are fictional. All figures come from the worked-example spreadsheet: ALL CHECKS PASSED (with 3 notes).
The headline

A prospect got 43% of the standard on average

Average shop score
43%
share of the 13 standard points met, over 36 shops; give or take 9 points
Responded in time
50%
within the owner's standard (15 seconds; 4 working hours; 2 minutes); 14% got no response at all
Followed up in time
35%
within 2 working days, where a follow-up was due; 48% followed up at all
Re-shop
10 Feb 2027
shopping 11 Jan 2027 to 29 Jan 2027 (moved clear of Christmas and New Year)

Verdict: In 36 shops of the business, a prospect got 43% of the standard points on average (give or take 9 points). 50% were responded to within the time standard and 14% got no response at all; where a follow-up was due, 35% came within the standard and 48% came at all. By channel: Walk-in best (71%), Web form worst (31%). By branch: Worcester showroom best (58%), Kidderminster showroom worst (30%). Lowest points: Asked for the survey or appointment (35%); Followed up within the standard (35%); Picked up the cue the shopper dropped (39%). Rivals: Rival A 37% (6 shops) against our 35% (18 shops); Rival B 36% (6 shops) against our 35% (18 shops). Fix list: 8 fixes (8 with an owner and a due date); the three lowest points with a fix: 3 of 3; last due 20 Nov 2026. Scorers: 8 of 36 shops double-scored, blind to the first score; agreement 93%; scored on the consultant's side, so use an independent or the owner's own scorer for the re-shop. Re-shop 11 Jan 2027 to 29 Jan 2027 (moved clear of Christmas and New Year) with the same scenarios, standard and shopper brief, and score the before and after write-ups together, blind; a change under 13 points could be chance. Not yet measured: re-shop 11 Jan to 29 Jan 2027 and fill in the Value Case after 10 Feb 2027.

By channel

Walk-in best (71%), Web form worst (31%)

Phone38% · responded within the standard 44% · followed up 29%Web form31% · responded within the standard 22% · followed up 43%Email33% · responded within the standard 67% · followed up 12%Walk-in71% · responded within the standard 67% · followed up 56%
Response time, our shopsWithin the standardUp to twiceSlowerNo responseShops
Phone
standard: 15 seconds
43029
Web form
standard: 4 working hours
21429
Email
standard: 4 working hours
60219
Walk-in
standard: 2 minutes
62109

Walk-in visitors were greeted quickly and asked about the job. Web forms were answered slowly, if at all; emails were answered quickly, but mostly with a brochure and few questions. Two of nine phone calls rang out with no voicemail. Nine shops a channel is a small base: read the differences as direction.

By point and branch

The three lowest: Asked for the survey or appointment (35%); Followed up within the standard (35%); Picked up the cue the shopper dropped (39%)

Standard pointAllPhoneWeb formEmailWalk-inFixes
1. Gave the business name and their own name65%71%100%50%44%1
2. Took the shopper's name and a way to contact them44%43%––44%0
3. Asked at least two questions about what the shopper needs42%43%14%12%89%1
4. Asked when the shopper wants the work done52%43%43%25%89%0
5. Picked up the cue the shopper dropped
Lowest 3
39%57%0%12%78%1
6. Gave the right answer to the key question77%71%86%75%78%0
7. Explained in plain words68%57%57%62%89%0
8. Gave a specific reason to choose us52%29%29%50%89%0
9. Gave a price range or said when a quotation would come45%43%29%38%67%0
10. Offered a next step with a day or time45%43%43%12%78%0
11. Asked for the survey or appointment
Lowest 1
35%43%14%25%56%1
Timed: Responded within the time standard50%44%22%67%67%3
Timed: Followed up within the standard
Lowest 2
35%29%43%12%56%1
BranchShopsAverage scoreResponded in timeFollowed up in time
Worcester showroom1258%67%64%
Kidderminster showroom1230%42%27%
Bromsgrove showroom
Fewer than three people: results may identify someone
1241%42%11%

Worcester showroom best (58%), Kidderminster showroom worst (30%). Results are by branch, never by person; Bromsgrove has two people handling enquiries, so its figures could identify them, and are shared with them on that basis.

What a prospect experienced

The best and the worst, anonymised

Best example Walk-in, bi-fold doors · Worcester showroom · shop score 100%
Greeted within a minute by name and role. Asked five questions about the opening, the floor level and how the garden is used; asked about the neighbour's leaking doors and showed the drainage track on a display door. Gave the 6-8 week lead time, offered a survey on Tuesday at 10 or Thursday at 2 and asked to book it. Called next day to confirm.

Worst example Web form, replacement windows · Kidderminster showroom · shop score 0%
Web form sent at 10.20 on a weekday morning. No reply, no call and no email in 8 working days. The form's confirmation page said "we'll be in touch within 24 hours".

Worst example Phone, composite front door · Kidderminster showroom · shop score 15%
Answered after 27 seconds (about nine rings) with "Hello, showroom". Gave a price range when asked but no questions about the house or the door; didn't take up the mother and the walking frame. Ended "have a look on the website and give us a ring back". No name taken.

Staff are referred to by role only; the shoppers wrote notes, nothing was recorded.

The rivals

Shopped on the same scenarios, by phone and web form

Rival (never named)ShopsTheir scoreResponded in timeFollowed up in timeOurs on the same (shops)
Rival A637%33%40%35% (18)
Rival B636%33%0%35% (18)

Rivals were asked the same questions as an ordinary enquiry, with no surveys or visits booked, and their staff aren't named; once their follow-up was recorded the shoppers closed the loop (“we’ve decided to go elsewhere”) and unsubscribed. On like-for-like phone and web-form shops the business is no better than either rival: the gap is a few points, well inside the give or take. They are shopped again at the re-shop as the background: they get none of the fixes, so a change in their scores shows how much the shoppers, scorers and season moved. With six shops each, that background has a wide give or take of its own, shown beside it on the Value Case.

The fix list

8 fixes (8 with an owner and a due date); the three lowest points with a fix: 3 of 3; last due 20 Nov 2026

Problem foundThe fixOwnerDue
Advisers don't ask the shopper to book the survey
Asked for the survey or appointment · All showrooms
End every enquiry with two survey times; practise it in the Monday huddleClaire B20 Nov
Nobody follows up a quotation request or a visit
Followed up within the standard · All showrooms
Every enquiry gets a follow-up task for two working days later in the CRMClaire B13 Nov
Cues about the household go unasked
Picked up the cue the shopper dropped · All showrooms
A five-question enquiry sheet beside every phone and in the reply template, ending "anything else we should know?"Tom H20 Nov
Written replies send a brochure but no questions
Asked at least two questions about what the shopper needs · Web form and email
New reply template: thanks, two questions, two survey times, the adviser's direct lineRachel M13 Nov
Showroom phones ring out while advisers are with visitors
Responded within the time standard · Kidderminster and Bromsgrove
Calls not answered in five rings go to the sales office; a missed-call list is cleared by 10am and 2pmRachel M6 Nov
Web forms and emails sit unread until the end of the day
Responded within the time standard · All showrooms
Forms and emails go to one shared inbox checked on the hour; first reply is a call, not a brochureRachel M6 Nov
The form's confirmation page promises a reply within 24 hours
Responded within the time standard · Website
Change it to "we'll call you within four working hours" once the shared inbox is liveRachel M13 Nov
Walk-in visitors aren't told who they're talking to
Gave the business name and their own name · All showrooms
Name badges; greet with name and roleAsif R30 Oct
How the value is shown

Measure later: the same shops again, 11 Jan 2027 to 29 Jan 2027 (moved clear of Christmas and New Year)

The main measure is the average shop score (43%, give or take 9 points), with the share responded to within the standard (50%) and followed up within the standard (35%). At the re-shop the same four shoppers use the same three scenarios and brief on the same channels and branches; the before and after write-ups are scored together, mixed, with the dates hidden, by the same two people, and each channel is weighted to today's mix. Blind scoring is only partial: once replies follow the new template, a scorer can tell an after shop from its wording. 8 of 36 shops double-scored, blind to the first score; agreement 93%; scored on the consultant's side, so use an independent or the owner's own scorer for the re-shop. With 36 shops again, a change under 13 points could be chance; the owner's target of 80% is well outside that. The window was moved clear of Christmas and New Year, and every fix is due before it starts. Not yet measured: re-shop 11 Jan to 29 Jan 2027 and fill in the Value Case after 10 Feb 2027.

Illustration only, not a forecast: enquiry-to-order conversion is 17.0% (109 orders from 640 enquiries over 3 months; give or take 3.0 points). If it reached the owner's assumed 19%, that would be worth £103,704 a year in gross profit (£51,852 if it moved half as far); as an illustration of scale, one point of conversion is worth £52,675. Conversion is re-read from the records on 3 May 2027 and compared with the same months a year earlier, but with about 640 enquiries a change under 4.2 points could be chance, and the owner's target is inside that: the re-read shows direction only, and the shop scores can't prove what moved it. Cost in full: £6,720 cash (fee and shoppers) and £1,120 of team time.

The months after

What the agent did, and what people decided

Fictional and illustrative. This continues the worked example from the baseline shops in September 2026 to the end of the January 2027 re-shop. Every name, figure and event is invented.

Mardlecote set up the agent before the first shop, in its own accounts: its AI assistant, the shared folder where the shoppers save their write-ups, and the CRM, read-only. The consultant approved and sent every schedule, brief and reminder to the shoppers; the showroom managers never saw a shop's date or time. The shoppers made every shop and two people scored every judged point from the notes; the agent filled only the response, the times and the follow-up from the shoppers' logs, for the scorers to check. The rules are on Inputs: a missing write-up flagged after 2 hours, "no follow-up" only after 8 working days, fix reminders 7 days ahead, and the re-shop prepared 3 weeks ahead. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of Mardlecote's people approving it.

Fixes done
8 of 8
by 24 November 2026, before the 4 December date
Overdue fixes flagged
2
both done within the week
Invented enquiries removed
31
from the CRM, by the sales office
Re-shop
48 shops
36 of ours and 12 of the rivals, 11 to 29 January
DateWhat the agent prepared, collated or flaggedKindWho decidedWhat happened
11 Sep 2026Shop schedule drafted: 36 of our shops (3 showrooms, 4 channels, 3 scenarios) and 12 rival shops, spread over 15 working days and 4 shoppers
Teams, Scenarios and Shoppers sheets; the shopper brief
DraftThe consultant
Approved with changes
The consultant swapped two walk-ins so no shopper visited the same showroom twice, then sent each shopper their own list.
17 Sep 2026MS-025 (a phone shop by SH3): write-up not in the folder 2 hours after the shop
The schedule; the shared write-up folder; Inputs (2 hours)
FlagThe consultant
Decided
SH3 had saved it in the wrong folder; moved the same day. No other write-up was late.
21 Sep 2026MS-038: Rival A's follow-up recorded on a bi-fold doors phone shop. Close-the-loop reply drafted for the shopper
Shops sheet (rival row, follow-up Yes); the shopper brief
DraftThe consultant
Approved
The shopper replied "thank you, we've decided to go elsewhere" and unsubscribed on 22 Sep.
6 Oct 20268 of our 36 shops (22%) picked for the second scorer; their write-ups sent without the first score
Shops sheet; Inputs (20% double-scored)
LoggedThe consultant
Approved
Double-scored by 9 Oct. Agreement 93%.
14 Oct 2026Follow-up wait of 8 working days passed for the last shops: Not yet changed to Yes or No from the shoppers' logs, for the scorers to check
The shoppers' logs; Inputs (8 working days)
LoggedHannah W
Approved
No shop left Not yet. Baseline recorded on 16 Oct.
19 Oct 202631 of the shoppers' invented enquiries found in the CRM, listed for removal
The CRM, read-only: the shoppers' review phone numbers and email addresses
FlagRachel M
Decided
The sales office removed them on 20 Oct; none had a quotation raised.
2 Nov 2026Fix 7 (name badges, due 30 Oct) not marked done
Fix List (due by, done on); Inputs (7 days' notice)
FlagRachel M
Decided
Asif R had the badges in use from 28 Oct; Done on entered.
23 Nov 2026Fix 5 (the five-question enquiry sheet, due 20 Nov) not marked done
Fix List (due by, done on)
FlagRachel M
Decided
Tom H had the sheets beside every phone on 24 Nov. All 8 fixes done before the 4 Dec date.
21 Dec 2026Re-shop prepared for 11 to 29 Jan 2027 (moved clear of Christmas): the same scenarios, standard, brief and 4 shoppers; 36 of our shops and 12 rival shops. Flag: both scorers are on the consultant's side
Value Case (window, re-measure 10 Feb 2027); Inputs (scorer independent: No)
DraftRachel M
Approved with changes
Rachel asked for an independent scorer for the blind scoring; the consultant arranged one. Schedules went to the shoppers on 4 Jan.
29 Jan 2027Re-shop closed: 48 shops made, 48 write-ups in. Blind set prepared: our 72 write-ups, before and after mixed, dates hidden
Shops sheet; the shared write-up folder
LoggedThe consultant
Approved
Scoring booked for 11 Feb, after the follow-up wait, with the independent scorer and Hannah W.

While the baseline shops ran, one write-up was late (saved in the wrong folder) and one rival's follow-up was closed off the next working day, as the shopper brief says. After handover the notes went to Rachel M. Two fixes slipped by a few days and were done within the week; all 8 were done by 24 November 2026. On 21 December the agent prepared the re-shop: the same scenarios, standard, brief and shoppers, moved clear of Christmas to 11 to 29 January, and flagged that both scorers were on the consultant's side. Rachel asked for an independent scorer, as the review had advised.

The re-shop closed on 29 January. The before and after write-ups (72 of ours, mixed, dates hidden) are scored together after the follow-up wait ends on 10 February, so this example stops before the result: nobody yet knows whether the average shop score has moved, and a change under 13 points could be chance. The coordinator spent about 20 minutes a working day while shops ran, and Rachel about 10 minutes a week after handover (estimate).

How confident are we?

What this rests on

The baseline rests on 36 of our shops by 4 independent shoppers, scored from written notes against 13 points the owner agreed; the average shop score has a give or take of 9 points, and a branch or channel has only a handful of shops, so read those as direction. Response times are counted by the shoppers in seconds, working hours and minutes; a follow-up counts as No only after 8 working days, and a shop with no response at all counts once, against the response. 8 shops were double-scored (agreement 93%). Blind scoring is only partial once replies follow a new template, because a scorer can tell an after shop from its wording. The rivals were shopped on the same scenarios and channels (12 shops) and are re-shopped as the background, because they get none of the fixes. At the re-shop each channel is weighted to today's mix and the before and after write-ups are scored together, blind, by the same people. The target score and the target conversion are the owner's assumptions; enquiries, conversion (109 orders from 640 enquiries) and gross profit per order come from the records, and any £ is an illustration, not a forecast. The re-shop shows whether the measures moved, not proof that the fixes moved them.