Negotiation Playbook · Foundation · October 2026

Ravensdyke Packaging Ltd

Corrugated cases, printed cartons and protective packaging for manufacturers, food producers and distributors across the East Midlands and South Yorkshire. 92 staff; five people quote and negotiate, two approve.

Worked example. Ravensdyke Packaging and its figures are fictional. All figures come from the worked-example spreadsheet: ALL CHECKS PASSED (with 5 notes).
The headline

On won quoted deals, 8.2% of the quoted value is given away: £82,599 a year, counted from the records

Given away now
8.2%
price 7.0%, the rest concessions and extra credit; 60 won deals, give or take 1.3 points
Given away a year
£82,599
on won quoted deals, counted from the quotation log and invoices
Win rate
34%
of 176 closed quotations (30% by value): a guard, it must not fall
Re-measure
16 Apr 2027
six months on, the same way; early read 14 Jan 2027

Verdict: The sheet holds 176 closed quoted deals over 12 months. On won deals the business gives away 8.2% of the quoted value (give or take 1.3 points, from 60 won deals): 7.0% in price and the rest in concessions and extra credit, about £82,599 a year, counted. It wins 34% of closed quotations (30% by value). Highest give-away: Reseller: 10.8% of quoted value (give or take 1.8 points, 18 won deals). Costliest tactic: Final offer: 9.5% given away on won deals when it was used (5 won), against 8.2% overall. 13 won deals (£258,170 quoted) gave £3,241 beyond the walk-away point. The playbook has 17 approved responses (8 practised), covering 36 of 36 tactic and buyer-type pairs with deals. Measure again on 16 Apr 2027, the same way: about 30 won deals are expected by then, so a change smaller than 2.2 points could be chance; the win rate and the margin on won jobs must not fall. As an illustration only, if the give-away fell from 8.2% to the owner's 6.0% (assumed), that would be worth £22,059 a year in gross profit if quoted prices and the win rate held, against £5,520 of fee and team time. Not yet measured: fill in the Value Case after 16 Apr 2027.

By buyer type

What each kind of buyer gets, against the walk-away point the owner has now set

Owner-managed6.1% given away · walk-away 10.0%Procurement-led9.0% given away · walk-away 12.0%Public body4.3% given away (only 4 won: too few to rely on) · walk-away 6.0%Reseller10.8% given away · walk-away 14.0%

Dark: price discount. Red: concessions and extra credit, at the £ costs on the price list. Dashed line: the new walk-away point. Grey: too few won deals to rely on.

Buyer typeClosedWonWin rateGiven away (± give or take)Limit / walk-awayApproves betweenWon beyond it
Owner-managed752837%6.1% ± 1.44.0% / 10.0%Gemma R5
Procurement-led471021%9.0% ± 2.96.0% / 12.0%Gemma R3
Public body16425%too few2.0% / 6.0%Simon K1
Reseller381847%10.8% ± 1.86.0% / 14.0%Gemma R4

13 won deals (£258,170 quoted) gave £3,241 beyond the walk-away point. Resellers get the most, mostly as price; procurement-led buyers are won least often. The walk-away points are new: these deals show what holding them would have meant, and are a reason to check each point is realistic before it is used.

The tactics

Final offer: 9.5% given away on won deals when it was used (5 won), against 8.2% overall

Tactic the buyer usedDealsWonWin rateGiven away on won dealsResponse missing for
Budget squeeze441125%7.5%All four buyer types
Competitor's quotation381539%7.4%All four buyer types
Final offer20525%9.5%All four buyer types
Delay20840%8.8%All four buyer types
Nibble251040%7.9%All four buyer types
Not recorded291138%8.9%–

The main tactic is taken from the order notes and the salespeople. Figures need five won deals; "Final offer" is just at that floor, so read it as a pointer, not a finding. Every tactic has a prepared response for every buyer type with deals. The four tactics added after the review (e-auctions, annual cost-down demands, retrospective rebates, cost breakdown requests) weren't recorded on past deals; they are recorded from now on.

The playbook

17 approved responses, each with a trade: give this only for that

Tactic and buyer typeGiveOnly forPractice
Budget squeeze
All buyer types
A lighter board grade or fewer print colours, re-quoted
at most 0.0% of quoted
A 12-month agreement on a rolling forecastPractised
Budget squeeze
Public body
A standard size from our range instead of a bespoke size
at most 0.0% of quoted
Inclusion for the whole requirement, on the buyer's stated termsNot yet
Competitor's quotation
All buyer types
Free delivery on full-pallet drops
at most 1.0% of quoted
A 12-month call-off schedulePractised
Competitor's quotation
Procurement-led
Up to 3% off the unit price
at most 3.0% of quoted
A 12-month agreement on a rolling forecast, with a board-price index clause that moves both waysPractised
Competitor's quotation
Reseller
Holding stock for call-off (up to 3 months)
at most 4.0% of quoted
A call-off schedule and an obligation to take any printed stock left at the end, at the agreed priceNot yet
Final offer
All buyer types
Up to the salesperson's limit; beyond it only as the buyer type's approver agrees
at most 2.0% of quoted
A signature by a named date on the stated volume and termsPractised
Final offer
Procurement-led
Up to the walk-away point for procurement-led buyers
at most 12.0% of quoted, approved by Gemma R
A 12-month agreement on a rolling forecast with a board-price index clause, and a signature datePractised
Final offer
Public body
Nothing outside the buyer's procedure
at most 0.0% of quoted
A compliant award on the published criteriaNot yet
Delay
All buyer types
Holding the quoted price to a set date, no longer
at most 0.0% of quoted
A decision date in the diary and the first order quantityPractised
Delay
Procurement-led
Free samples or a prototype run
at most 1.0% of quoted
A named decision date and the first orderNot yet
Nibble
All buyer types
Free delivery, or a cutter at cost
at most 2.0% of quoted
Full-pallet drops, or the 12-month agreementPractised
Nibble
Reseller
Up to 30 days' extra credit
at most 0.7% of quoted
A larger first order, or a 12-month forecast with the extra days withdrawn if payments run latePractised
E-auction
All buyer types
Bids within the salesperson's limit; deeper only as pre-approved for that auction
at most 2.0% of quoted
Award of the lot at the bid price, on the tendered specification and volumesNot yet
E-auction
Procurement-led
Bids down to a pre-approved floor, no lower than the walk-away point
at most 12.0% of quoted, approved by Gemma R
Award of the lot on the tendered specification, with a board-price index clauseNot yet
Annual cost-down demand
All buyer types
A share of the saving from a specification or run-length change
at most 0.0% of quoted
The change agreed in writing and a 12-month rolling forecastNot yet
Retrospective rebate
All buyer types
A tiered rebate of up to 2% on spend above the agreed threshold
at most 2.0% of quoted
Spend above the threshold, invoices paid on terms, and the rebate paid after the year endNot yet
Cost breakdown request
All buyer types
The cost structure by share, and board linked to a published index
at most 0.0% of quoted
An index clause that moves both ways and a 12-month rolling forecastNot yet

The full wording (how the buyer says it and the prepared response) is in the playbook document handed over. No give goes beyond the salesperson's limit without the approver, or beyond the walk-away point. 9 responses have not yet been role-played, including the four new ones for e-auctions, cost-down demands, rebates and cost breakdowns; they go into the next sessions.

The concessions price list

What each thing given away costs, and what to ask for in return

ConcessionCostUnitBasisAsk for in returnDealsOn won deals
Extra credit (a day beyond the standard terms, per £1,000 of the price)£0.22Per day per £1,000AssumedA larger first order, or a 12-month rolling forecast35£1,085
Free delivery£68Per deliveryCountedFull-pallet drops only, or a 12-month call-off schedule23£4,284
Free cutter or print plate£420Per dealCountedA 12-month supply agreement, with the cutter recharged if it ends early8£1,680
Free samples or prototype run£180Per dealEstimatedA named date for the decision and the first order19£900
Holding stock for call-off£150Per monthEstimatedA call-off schedule and an obligation to take any printed stock left at the end, at the agreed price13£3,000
Rush production£350Per dealAssumedPayment on the standard terms and the full order quantity17£1,400

Extra credit is counted beyond each buyer type's standard terms (45 days for procurement-led buyers, 30 for the rest) and costed at the owner's 8% cost of money, an assumption; rush production's cost is assumed too. 5 on the price list (2 counted, 2 estimated, 1 assumed), plus extra credit at 8% a year beyond the standard terms. 21 a year quoted at £40,000 or more; given away on those won: 10.2%: each gets a one-page planner before the negotiation.

How the value is shown

Measure later: a baseline now, the same measure on 16 April 2027

Buyer typeWon nowGiven away nowGive or takeWin rate nowAt the re-measure
Owner-managed286.1%1.4 pts37%…
Procurement-led109.0%2.9 pts21%…
Public body4too few–25%…
Reseller1810.8%1.8 pts47%…

The baseline is 8.2% given away on 60 won quoted deals (give or take 1.3 points), and a 34% win rate. About 30 more deals should be won by 16 April 2027, so a change smaller than 2.2 points could be chance; the early read on 14 January 2027 (about 15 won deals) is a first look only. The re-measure uses the same source (Quotation log and invoice), the same 60-day window and the same concession costs; the discount on other sales (2.4% now) is taken again and shown beside the result, not subtracted. Not yet measured: fill in the Value Case after 16 Apr 2027.

Illustration only: a 2-point fall in what is given away would be worth £20,180 a year in gross profit; the owner's 6.0% target, an assumption, would be worth £22,059 (illustration), and a real change that size might not show at the re-measure. Both hold only if quoted prices, costs and the win rate hold: the re-measure checks the win rate by count and value and the gross margin on won jobs, and re-weights to the same mix of buyers. Neither is a forecast. Fee and team time, built up from the hours: £5,520.

How confident are we?

What this rests on

Quoted and final values come mainly from Quotation log and invoice (17% of deals from weak sources: lost-only reasons or memory) over 12 months, deals of £2,000 or more, counted as lost after 60 days without an answer; the sheet covers 96% of closed quotations in the records. Concessions are costed from the price list (1 of the costs assumed) and extra credit beyond each buyer type's standard terms at an assumed 8% cost of money. It rests on 60 won deals, give or take 1.3 points; by the re-measure about 30 more should be won, so a change under 2.2 points could be chance. The target of 6.0% is the owner's assumption, not a forecast, and its £ is an illustration. A lower give-away adds to gross profit only if quoted prices, costs and the win rate hold, so the re-measure checks the win rate by count and value and the gross margin on won jobs, re-weights to the same mix of buyers, and shows the discount on other sales beside the result. It shows whether the measure moved, not proof that the playbook moved it.

The give-away is counted, not estimated: quoted and final values from the quotation log, concessions from the order notes priced from invoices. The softest parts are the assumed costs (rush production, the cost of money) and the 17% of deals taken from memory or lost-quotation reasons. A two-point change is about the smallest six months could show; the owner's target is just inside it, so the re-measure may need to run to a year.

The months after

What the agent flagged, and what people decided

Ravensdyke chose the guided route. At the final session the agent was set up in an AI assistant the business already uses, with read-only access to the quotation log, the sales invoices and order notes, and the open quotations in the CRM. Every Monday at 7:30 it adds the deals closed in the week to a working copy of the deals since the playbook was approved, costs them from the price list exactly as the baseline was costed, runs the checks and sends Gemma R a short note. It uses the owner's rules on Inputs: the limits, walk-away points and approvers by buyer type, the £40,000 planner threshold and 7 days' notice before a big deal's decision. Nothing left Ravensdyke, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it. These events continue the fictional example.

DateWhat the agent foundWhat was decided
26 Oct 2026
No flag
Six deals closed in the week, four won, all within their limits.Nothing needed.
2 Nov 2026
Flag
A reseller deal won at 14.8% of quoted value, £147 beyond the 14% walk-away point.The owner talked it through with the salesperson: it should have been walked away from. Final offer went into that week's role-play.
9 Nov 2026
No flag
The £86,400 deal prepared with a planner won at 5.8%, within the 6% limit, on a 12-month agreement with the index clause.Nothing needed. Shown to the team as the planner working.
16 Nov 2026
Flag
A procurement deal won at 8.4%, above the salesperson's 6% limit, with no approval recorded.The sales manager had approved it by phone. Approvals now go in the order notes the same day.
30 Nov 2026
Flag
A £58,000 quotation due for a decision in a week, with no planner yet.The planner was prepared two days later with the sales manager.
18 Jan 2027
No flag
The early read: 6.9% given away on 19 won deals since the playbook, against 8.2% before; win rate 36%.Too few deals to judge. Keep going and measure again on 16 April, the same way.

At the 30-day check-in on 18 November, Geoff, Simon K and Gemma R read the log together. No rule needed changing.

What the agent added. The method is unchanged: same rules, same price list, same measure. The agent made sure every new deal was checked against the walk-away rules the week it closed, so a breach was talked about while the team still remembered it, and big deals got their planner before the meeting. The early read came from deals already loaded and costed the same way, and so will the re-measure. The early read is a look, not a result: no £ figure is claimed for it, and the value case above is unchanged.