Commercial and packaging printing (folding cartons, labels and brochures) for food, drink and retail brands, from a site in Kettering. 112 staff. Appointing its first managing director from outside the family.
Verdict: Managing Director, the first from outside the family, reporting to the board. All six parts of the deliverable are complete; the decision-rights schedule was agreed by the board on 29 Sep 2026. The package costs £165,187 a year at target bonus, with a base of £108,000 between the median and the upper quartile on the named source. Candidate A is recommended: the highest weighted score among candidates who meet every must-have and whose scorers agree. Hamish hands over 9 responsibilities, the last on day 120. Risk avoided, not a forecast: a failed hire would cost about £232,223 (£28,000 of it the owner's time). With the chances the owner assumes (30% without this work, 15% with), the work cuts the expected cost by £34,833 (£17,417 if half as well) against £21,010 for the work; it pays for itself if it cuts the chance of failure by 9.0 points. With the owner's own chances it covers the cost of the work, but if the work helps only half as well it does not. It feeds 4 catalogue products, 1 of them not yet built.
Run Drennock Print day to day and grow it profitably, so that Hamish can step back to chair the board and the family keeps ownership. The managing director leads the managers, owns the budget and the customer relationships, and keeps the long-serving team and the standards the business is known for.
| Responsibility | Held now by | Handed over | Measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Runs the business day to day: the production, sales, finance and quality managers report to the managing director | Hamish | day 30 | |
| Sets and delivers the annual budget with the finance manager | Hamish | day 60 | Sales invoiced in the year |
| Chairs the monthly management meeting | Hamish | day 45 | |
| Approves quotations and prices for new work over £10,000 | Hamish | day 60 | Gross margin on jobs |
| Owns the relationships with the ten largest customers, with the sales director | Hamish | day 120 | Sales invoiced in the year |
| Approves purchase orders and capital requests within the decision-rights schedule | Hamish | day 30 | |
| Leads hiring, pay reviews and discipline for the managers | Hamish | day 91 | Staff leavers in the last 12 months |
| Day-to-day contact with the bank, insurers and auditors | Hamish | day 74 | Debtor days |
| The director responsible for health and safety | Hamish | day 30 | |
| Continuous improvement on the press floor: waste and make-ready times | Gethin | stays | Board waste as a share of board bought |
| Accreditations (ISO 9001, FSC chain of custody, BRCGS Packaging) | Quality manager | stays | Jobs delivered on the promised date |
What this role is not
| Who | Role now → after | How it affects them | Told by, by when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hamish Family | Owner and managing director → Non-executive chair, two days a week | Gives up running the business day to day; chairs the board and the 30, 90 and 180-day reviews | The board 1 Jul 2026 |
| Maureen Family | Director and company secretary → Unchanged | No longer signs off payroll; as a director she reviews the new managing director's performance | Hamish 1 Jul 2026 |
| Fenella Family | Sales director → Sales director, reporting to the new managing director | Her line manager changes; she sits on the case-exercise panel | Hamish 1 Jul 2026 |
| Gethin Family | Production manager → Production manager, reporting to the new managing director | His line manager changes; his pay and role stay with the board | Hamish 1 Jul 2026 |
| Nerys | Finance manager → Finance manager, reporting to the new managing director | Her line manager changes; she leads the budget with the new managing director | Hamish 6 Jan 2027 |
| All staff | – → – | A new managing director; Hamish stays as chair | Hamish and the new managing director 18 Jan 2027 |
| Area | Decision | Threshold | Who decides |
|---|---|---|---|
| Day-to-day spending | Purchase orders within the approved budget, up to the threshold | £50,000 | Executive alone |
| Day-to-day spending | Spending outside the approved budget above the threshold (smaller amounts reported to the board monthly) | £50,000 | Executive proposes; board decides |
| Capital spending | Capital items within the approved capital plan, up to the threshold | £75,000 | Executive alone |
| Capital spending | Capital items outside the plan or above the threshold, and any press or finishing line | £75,000 | Executive proposes; board decides |
| Hiring and pay | Hiring, pay and dismissal below manager level, within budget | – | Executive alone |
| Hiring and pay | Appointing or dismissing a manager who reports to the managing director | – | Executive proposes; board decides |
| Hiring and pay | The annual pay review across the business | – | Executive proposes; board decides |
| Pricing and customers | Prices, quotations and discounts within the pricing policy | – | Executive alone |
| Pricing and customers | Customer contracts above the threshold a year, or longer than three years | £500,000 | Executive proposes; board decides |
| Suppliers and contracts | Supplier contracts up to the threshold a year | £250,000 | Executive alone |
| Borrowing and banking | New borrowing, guarantees or changes to bank facilities | – | Board only |
| Strategy and budget | The annual budget and the three-year plan | – | Executive proposes; board decides |
| Family members in the business | Pay, promotion or dismissal of a family member employed in the business (day-to-day management stays with the managing director) | – | Board only |
| Ownership and dividends | Dividends, issuing shares or options, transfers of shares | – | Shareholders only |
| Ownership and dividends | Selling the business or any part of it | – | Shareholders only |
| Brand and name | Changing the company name, the brand or its stated values | – | Shareholders only |
Family members' pay and roles, ownership, dividends and the brand stay with the board or the shareholders. Any dispute is logged; owner overrides are reviewed at every review point.
| Measure and baseline source | Baseline | Year-1 target | Better | Bonus weight |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sales invoiced in the year Statutory accounts, year to 31 March 2026 | £14.2m | £15.0m | higher | 20% |
| Gross margin on jobs Management accounts and job costing, 12 months to 30 September 2026 | 29.4% | 31% | higher | 25% |
| Jobs delivered on the promised date Job management system, 6 months to 30 September 2026 | 88% | 95% | higher | 20% |
| Board waste as a share of board bought Stock and waste records, 6 months to 30 September 2026 | 7.8% | 6.5% | lower | 15% |
| Staff leavers in the last 12 months Payroll, 12 months to 30 September 2026 | 19% | 14% | lower | 10% |
| Debtor days Accounting package, 30 September 2026 | 61 days | 52 days | lower | 10% |
| Item | £ a year |
|---|---|
| Base salary | £108,000 |
| Target bonus | £21,600 |
| Cash allowances | £7,800 |
| Benefits in kind | £1,600 |
| Employer NIC (Class 1 and 1A) | £20,100 |
| Employer pension | £5,400 |
| Apprenticeship Levy this pay adds | £687 |
| Employer cost a year at target bonus | £165,187 |
| At the most bonus; with no bonus | £177,661; £140,239 |
Market: Shortlisting recruiter's salary data for managing directors (recruiter data), September 2026: the base is between the median and the upper quartile (104% of the median). £120,000 of options, within the EMI limit per employee; notice 6 months each way; non-compete 6 and non-solicitation 12 months, for the solicitor. The base is 1.69 times the highest-paid existing manager's, so Hamish plans how the gap is explained before the announcement (a note on Checks).
| Criterion and evidence | Assessed at | Weight |
|---|---|---|
| Has run a manufacturing business or site with full profit and loss responsibility Must Explains a past year's profit and loss line by line and the decisions that moved margin, with figures a referee confirms | First interview | 3 |
| Has worked for or alongside an owner or family shareholders and kept their trust Must Describes a disagreement with an owner, how it was settled and what they would do differently; a referee from an owner-managed business | Final interview with the board | 3 |
| Has developed managers who were later promoted Must Names people they developed, what changed and where they are now; a referee confirms | First interview | 2 |
| Reads management accounts and manages cash Must In the case exercise, finds the margin and cash problems hidden in the data pack and says what they would do first | Case exercise | 3 |
| Has led continuous improvement on a production floor Must Gives before-and-after figures (waste, make-ready times, on-time delivery) from a programme they led | Case exercise | 2 |
| Negotiates with large customers and keeps margin Must Walks through a renewal they led with a major customer: the price, the terms and what they gave up | First interview | 2 |
| Knowledge of print or packaging Talks credibly about make-ready, substrates and press scheduling | First interview | 1 |
| Has led a change of job-management or ERP system Describes the scope, their part in it and what they would do differently | Final interview with the board | 1 |
| Has been responsible for packaging accreditations Has owned an audit (BRCGS Packaging, FSC or similar) and its corrective actions | Final interview with the board | 1 |
| Explains plans clearly to staff on the shop floor Case exercise presentation: plain English, answers questions without jargon | Case exercise | 1 |
| Stage | Panel | Non-family adviser |
|---|---|---|
| First interview Interview | Hamish; Anwen | Yes |
| Case exercise Case exercise | Hamish; Anwen; Fenella | Yes |
| Final interview with the board Interview | Hamish; Maureen; Anwen | Yes |
| Meet the managers Meet the team (not scored) | Gethin; Nerys | – |
| References References | Anwen | Yes |
| Right to work Right to work | Finance manager | – |
| Candidate | Weighted score | Must-haves | Agreement | 2-point gaps | Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Candidate A | 3.24 | 6 of 6 | 100% | 0 | Recommended |
| Candidate B | 3.45 | 5 of 6 | 100% | 0 | Misses a must-have |
| Candidate C | 2.89 | 5 of 6 | 90% | 1 | Scorers disagree: discuss first |
Hamish and Anwen scored every criterion 1 to 4, independently, before discussing. A two-point gap on a must-have means the scorers discuss the evidence and score again before that candidate can be recommended; it is never averaged away (Candidate C: a note on Checks).
| Day | Date | Kind | What happens |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 18 Jan 2027 | Stakeholder meeting | Introduced to all staff by Hamish at a site meeting; Hamish says what he is handing over and when Hamish and the managing director |
| 4 | 22 Jan 2027 | Stakeholder meeting | Weekly two-hour meeting with Hamish for the first 90 days: history, customers, the unwritten rules Managing director and Hamish |
| 10 | 28 Jan 2027 | Stakeholder meeting | One-to-ones with each manager, 90 minutes each, Fenella and Gethin included Managing director |
| 21 | 8 Feb 2027 | Stakeholder meeting | Visits to the five largest customers with Fenella: listen, change nothing Managing director and Fenella |
| 30 | 17 Feb 2027 | Owner hands over or stops | Managers report to the managing director; Hamish stops attending the daily production meeting Hamish |
| 30 | 17 Feb 2027 | Owner hands over or stops | Hamish stops signing purchase orders; the managing director signs within the schedule Hamish |
| 30 | 17 Feb 2027 | Owner hands over or stops | Board resolution: the managing director becomes the director responsible for health and safety The board |
| 30 | 17 Feb 2027 | Review point | 30-day review: chair, managing director and Anwen; handovers due so far, disputes logged, anything unclear in the schedule Hamish, the managing director and Anwen |
| 39 | 26 Feb 2027 | Stakeholder meeting | Skip-level conversations with the press and finishing teams on all three shifts Managing director |
| 45 | 4 Mar 2027 | Owner hands over or stops | The managing director chairs the monthly management meeting; Hamish attends the first two only Hamish |
| 60 | 19 Mar 2027 | Owner hands over or stops | Hamish stops signing off quotations; the managing director signs within the pricing policy Hamish |
| 60 | 19 Mar 2027 | Owner hands over or stops | The managing director leads the 2027–28 budget with Nerys; Hamish reviews it as chair Hamish |
| 60 | 19 Mar 2027 | Early decision | First decision within the schedule: the press-hall shift pattern for the busy season, agreed with Gethin Managing director |
| 74 | 2 Apr 2027 | Owner hands over or stops | Joint meeting with the bank; the managing director becomes the main contact for the bank, insurers and auditors Hamish |
| 91 | 19 Apr 2027 | Owner hands over or stops | Hiring, pay reviews and discipline for the managers pass to the managing director Hamish |
| 91 | 19 Apr 2027 | Early decision | Presents a 12-month plan to the board for approval Managing director |
| 91 | 19 Apr 2027 | Review point | 90-day review: as at day 30, plus the first readings of the year-1 measures; any change to the schedule agreed by the board Hamish, the managing director and Anwen |
| 120 | 18 May 2027 | Owner hands over or stops | Joint visits to the ten largest customers, then Hamish steps back from day-to-day contact Hamish |
| 150 | 17 Jun 2027 | Early decision | Decides whether to replace the job-management system (the board decides if it costs over £75,000) Managing director |
| 150 | 17 Jun 2027 | Review point | Probation review, before the six-month qualifying period for unfair dismissal ends: confirm or extend The board |
| 182 | 19 Jul 2027 | Review point | 180-day review: handovers complete, disputes and overrides reviewed, year-1 measures and bonus targets confirmed Hamish, the managing director and Anwen |
| Product | Part it needs and what | Ready? |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership Transfer Plan Not yet built | Decision rights Who decides what once the owner steps back: the schedule the succession route builds on | Complete |
| Ownership Transfer Plan Not yet built | 180-day plan The owner's handover dates: when he is no longer needed day to day | Complete |
| KPI Dashboard Design | Year-1 measures The managing director's year-1 measures and their baselines, for the top page | Complete |
| Investment Priorities Plan | Decision rights The capital spending thresholds: which projects the managing director approves and which go to the board | Complete |
| Rolling Forecast and Monthly Pack | Package The new managing director's full employment cost, at target and at the most bonus can pay | Complete |
| Rolling Forecast and Monthly Pack | Year-1 measures The measures the monthly pack reports to the board | Complete |
| Cost of a failed hire | £ | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| A second search to replace them | £25,260 | Quotation |
| Package paid that bought little before the failure is acted on | £52,590 | Assumed |
| Notice paid on exit | £70,120 | From the package |
| Settlement beyond notice | £15,000 | Assumed |
| Solicitor's fees on the exit | £4,000 | Estimate |
| Gross profit lost while the business is disrupted | £48,000 | Estimate from the records |
| Key staff who leave as a result | £36,000 | Assumed |
| Less: pay saved while the post is empty | −£46,746 | Estimate |
| Owner's time stepping back in (time, not cash) | £28,000 | Estimate |
| Cost of a failed hire, in full | £232,223 |
| Cost of this work | £ | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Consultant's fee | £6,500 | Quotation (the consultant's proposal) |
| Solicitor: service agreement and covenants | £3,200 | Quotation |
| Tax adviser: options scheme and valuation | £4,800 | Assumed (no quotation) |
| Team time | £6,510 | Estimate and Selection |
| Cost of this work, in full | £21,010 |
With the chances Hamish assumes (30% without this work, 15% with: assumptions, never facts), the expected cost of a failed hire falls by £34,833 (£17,417 if the work helps half as well) against £21,010 for the work. It pays for itself if it cuts the chance of failure by 9.0 points. With Hamish's own chances it covers its cost, but if it helps only half as well it does not. The recruiter's £25,260 is paid whether or not this work is done, so it is not counted; only the second search, after a failure, is. Measures that can move: not started: counted at day 30 (17 Feb 2027), 90 and 180. They count handovers done on time, disputes logged and owner overrides, year-1 measures on track.
The role, responsibilities, boundaries, people affected and decision rights are as agreed with the owner and the board on 29 Sep 2026; the year-1 baselines are counted from the records named against each, and the targets are the owner's. The market figures come from Shortlisting recruiter's salary data for managing directors, dated September 2026; employer NIC and pension use the rates on Inputs (2026 to 2027). The scores rest on two scorers marking independently against the evidence on Selection. The chances of a failed hire with and without this work, the months and share of package that bought little, the settlement, the staff who would leave, the gross profit lost and the owner's hours are the owner's assumptions or estimates, not facts or forecasts; at least one adviser's or the recruiter's fee is assumed until a quotation arrives.
Not legal or tax advice: the service agreement, covenants and any options scheme are for the client's solicitor and tax adviser, whose fees the client pays directly.