Contract cleaning for offices, schools, surgeries and light industrial sites across Gloucestershire and Worcestershire. 64 staff, five people who hear objections.
Verdict: The log holds 144 objections on 100 deals. The top three are Price too high; Happy with current supplier; Send me something; on quoted deals where one comes up the business wins 24% (give or take 12 points, from 51 closed deals), against 30% of all quotations. The library has 10 approved responses (6 practised); 10 of the top 10 objections have one. Measure again on 16 Apr 2027, the same way: about 51 closed deals are expected by then, so a change smaller than 17 points could be chance. If the win rate moved from 24% to the owner's 30% (assumed), that would be worth £12,914 a year in gross profit, against £2,956 of fee and team time. Not yet measured: fill in the Value Case after 16 Apr 2027.
Red: the top three, used for the baseline. Grey: outside the top ten. A further 6 objections (4% of the log) were logged as “Other”. Win rates show only with five or more closed deals. “Happy with current supplier” and “Send me something” come up mostly at the first call and are rarely won: the responses for both end with a fixed next step (a free audit of one floor; 15 minutes in the diary) rather than a brochure.
| Objection | Question to ask | Next step | Proof asset | Practice |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Price too high “Your price is more than we pay now.” | What does your current price include: hours on site, supervision, consumables and cover when someone is off? | Agree a side-by-side of the two specifications and a walk-round with the site manager. Never discount in the room: any change to the price or specification comes back as a revised quotation. | Like-for-like cost sheet; audit scores for the last 12 months (average 94%) | Practised |
| 2. Happy with current supplier “We have had the same cleaners for years and they are fine.” | If you could change one thing about the cleaning, what would it be? | Offer a free audit of one floor, with the results left with them whoever they choose. | Sample audit report (anonymised) | Practised |
| 3. Send me something “Just email me something and I will have a look.” | What will you be comparing it with, and who else will read it? | Book 15 minutes on a set day to go through it, before sending. | One-page specification template | Practised |
| 4. Cheaper quotation elsewhere “Someone else quoted less.” | Are the hours on site and the cover arrangements the same in both? | Offer to check the two specifications together, line by line. | Like-for-like cost sheet | Practised |
| 5. Decision-maker not here “I will need to run it past someone.” | Who else decides, and how will it be bought: a quotation, a framework or a tender? | Offer to join the conversation or a site visit with them; for a public body, register for the tender notice and diary the deadline. | Decision-maker summary note; public-sector checklist (insurances, policies, references) | Not yet |
| 6. Not the right time “Not now.” | What has to happen first, and when is that likely? | Agree a date to speak again, six weeks before their event, and put the notice date in both diaries. | 30-day changeover plan; notice-date reminder letter | Not yet |
| 7. Worried about the changeover “Changing cleaners would be a headache.” | What went wrong last time anything like this changed? | Walk through the changeover plan with the dates they would need. | 30-day changeover plan; figure: last 9 changeovers, no missed cleans | Practised |
| 8. Tied into a contract “We are in contract until next year.” | When does it end, and what notice do you have to give? | Agree a review three months before the notice date, in the diary now. | none yet | Not yet |
| 9. Need references “Who else do you clean for?” | What kind of site would be most useful to hear from? | Offer the reference call this week. | Reference list (customers' permission held) | Practised |
| 10. Bad experience before “The last firm let us down.” | What went wrong, and how would you have known sooner? | Offer a three-month review point written into the contract. | Audit and fix promise sheet | Not yet |
Every response has four parts: acknowledge, a question to ask, evidence to show and the next step. The full library, with the acknowledge and evidence lines, is the document handed over. Four approved responses have not yet been practised; they go into the next 30-minute session.
| Stage | Times heard | Closed | Win rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| First call | 50 | 44 | 14% |
| Meeting | 33 | 30 | 30% |
| Quotation | 27 | 24 | 33% |
| Negotiation | 27 | 22 | 18% |
| Close | 7 | 7 | 43% |
Counted per objection, so a deal with two objections counts at each. A third of objections come at the first call, where the win rate is lowest.
| Gap | Deals | Action for operations | Owner | Due |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cleaning before 6am | 1 | Find whether an early shift can be staffed on the Gloucester round | Owen L | 13 Nov 2026 |
| Window cleaning | 3 | Find a window-cleaning firm to subcontract to, and price it | Hollie B | 27 Nov 2026 |
| Washroom supplies | 2 | Cost washroom consumables as an add-on to the contract | Priya S | – |
All six “Other” objections were things Thistlecombe doesn’t yet offer. No script answers them; an action does.
| Rank | Objection | Deals | Closed now | Win rate now (all deals) | At the re-measure |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Price too high | 30 | 29 | 24% | … |
| 2 | Happy with current supplier | 26 | 23 | 13% | … |
| 3 | Send me something | 23 | 21 | 14% | … |
| 4 | Cheaper quotation elsewhere | 14 | 10 | 20% | … |
| 5 | Decision-maker not here | 13 | 12 | 33% | … |
| 6 | Not the right time | 9 | 8 | 12% | … |
| 7 | Worried about the changeover | 8 | 7 | 71% | … |
| 8 | Tied into a contract | 6 | 6 | 33% | … |
| 9 | Need references | 5 | 4 | too few | … |
| 10 | Bad experience before | 2 | 1 | too few | … |
The baseline is counted from the CRM on quoted deals only, so it compares with the quotation win rate: 12 won of 51 closed quoted deals where one of the top three came up. About 51 more should close by 16 April 2027, so a change smaller than 17 points could be chance; the early read on 14 January 2027 (about 25 deals) is a first look only. The re-measure uses the same source (CRM notes) and the same 90-day follow-up window, and nets off any change in the win rate on all quotations. Not yet measured: fill in the Value Case after 16 Apr 2027.
For scale only: a 10-point rise on these deals would be worth £19,958 a year in gross profit; the owner’s 30% target, an assumption, would be worth £12,914. Neither is a forecast. Fee and team time: £2,956.
Objections come mainly from CRM notes (17% of rows from lost-only sources) and outcomes from CRM (quotation log), over 6 months; the baseline counts quoted deals only, each once, won ÷ (won + lost) within 90 days, open deals left out; the log covers 84% of quotations issued. It rests on 51 closed deals, give or take 12 points; by the re-measure about 51 more should close, so a change under 17 points could be chance. The target of 30% is the owner's assumption, not a forecast; the order value (£8,400) and margin (22%) come from the records and count one year only. Season, prices and people change too: the re-measure nets off the change in all quotations, and shows whether the measure moved, not proof that the library moved it.
The give or take of 17 points on the change matters more than the target: the owner’s target is inside it, so even reaching it would not prove much on six months’ deals. A two-week tally run alongside the CRM notes makes the re-measure sharper. What the team said was written down without names; the log holds deal references, not customers.
Fictional, continuing the example. After the library was approved, Thistlecombe chose the guided route and set up the agent in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to the CRM, the team's tally sheet and the quotation log; its IT confirmed this before it committed. Thistlecombe updated its privacy notice first, so customers and staff are told how call notes are used, and completed a data protection impact assessment, since the agent reads named salespeople's calls every week (not legal advice). Every Monday 7:00 it drafts last week's objections as log rows for the person who heard each to confirm, with no names; fills in outcomes from the quotation log; drafts a four-part response to any objection heard on 3 deals in 8 weeks without one, for Hollie B to approve; and proposes the week's two practice objections. Nothing left the business, and no response changed, without one of its own people approving it.
| Date | What the agent prepared or found | Who decided, and what happened |
|---|---|---|
| 19 Oct Decision | 7 new objections drafted as log rows, on 6 deals | Dana K, Marcus T and Priya S (each their own rows): Wording confirmed and no names left in; the 7 rows added with Anonymised? Yes |
| 19 Oct Decision | This week's practice session: two objections proposed | Hollie B: Practised in pairs on 21 October; both marked Practised |
| 9 Nov Decision | "We will do it in-house" heard on 3 deals in 8 weeks (Inputs B27 and B28) with no approved response: a four-part response drafted | Hollie B: Approved on 11 November with the evidence filled in from payroll. Added to the Library and to the next practice session |
| 23 Nov Decision | Service gap "Window cleaning" heard on 2 more deals; its action is due on 27 November | Hollie B: Subcontractor priced on 25 November; offered as an add-on from January |
| 7 Dec Bookkeeping | Outcome and Quoted? filled for 8 deals decided within the 90-day window | Logged; checked at the early read |
| 28 Dec Decision | The early read is 17 days away (Inputs B29: 21 days' warning) | Hollie B: Read on 4 January. Priya S named to check the count; no extra tally needed, as the main source is CRM notes |
| 18 Jan Decision | Early read prepared for the counter to check | Priya S, checked by Hollie B: Counted again by hand and agreed. Too few deals to judge, so direction only; nothing entered on the Value Case until the re-measure on 16 April 2027 |
The 30-day check-in on 16 November read the first four weeks of the log with Hollie B; after that the agent was Thistlecombe's, and Geoff kept no copy and no access. One response was added to the library (doing it in-house), every approved response had been practised by early December, and the window-cleaning gap was closed by operations, not a script. Confirming the drafted log rows took each salesperson about 5 minutes a week, and reading the note about 10 minutes (estimates). The early read on 14 January gave direction only, as the method says it would; the re-measure on 16 April 2027 is the one to judge, counted the same way from CRM notes. The months after add nothing to the figures above.