Designs, makes and repairs hydraulic cylinders and power units for construction plant, agricultural machinery and materials-handling manufacturers, from a works in Cannock; founded by the owner's father in 1979. 84 staff. Graham, 62, hands over the running of it by 31 Mar 2029 and the ownership by 31 Mar 2031.
Verdict: The plan sets out how Graham hands over the running of Hexlowe Hydraulics Ltd by 31 Mar 2029 and the ownership by 31 Mar 2031. One route is preferred so far, with 2 more still considered and 1 ruled out, none decided or ruled out without an adviser's sign-off first; the tax and legal pointers are pointers, not advice. If Graham died or couldn't work tomorrow, 2 of 12 contingency items are in place, and the rest are all due by 31 Mar 2027. Successors: 8 of 15 readiness evidence items are evidenced across 5 roles, and every gap has a dated development action. How the value is shown (risk avoided, not a forecast): the largest event, “Graham dies or can't work suddenly, with no attorney, aligned will or shareholders' agreement”, would cost £1,831,000 (gross profit lost from the owner's records, value lost from the valuer's or an adviser's figure, one-off costs from quotations). With the owner's assumed likelihoods over 4.5 years the 4 events cost £248,710; if the plan works as assumed it cuts that by £135,505 (£67,753 if half as well), against the plan's cost in full of £35,979. Count the contingency items, the evidence and the steps on time again on 16 Apr 2027.
| Holder | Shares now | Share now | At completion | Share then |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Graham Owner stepping back; in the business | 7,000 | 70% | 0 | 0% |
| Carol Spouse or partner; not in the business | 2,000 | 20% | 0 | 0% |
| Janet Other family; not in the business | 1,000 | 10% | 0 | 0% |
| Buy-out company (Emma, Farah D and Declan W) Buy-out company; in the business | 0 | 0% | 10,000 | 100% |
Valuation range (never invented): £7,400,000 to £9,800,000; Maintainable Profit Review, 22 Sep 2026; Equity value (the shares, after debt-like items and surplus cash); an indication for planning, not a valuation. The value case uses the low end. A formal valuation is in the timetable.
| Route | What it involves | Effect on staff and customers | Typical timeline | Sign-off |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Management buy-out Preferred | Emma, Farah D and Declan W form a new company that buys all the shares; Emma becomes managing director; Graham stays as a non-executive chair for two years Funded by: Bank debt to the new company, the managers' own money, and part of the price deferred to Graham and paid from profits over two years | Little change for staff and customers: the same managers; Emma already runs operations. Customers need to meet Declan and Emma without Graham first Concern: Whether the business can carry the debt; fairness to Rory; Janet's 10% | 24 months | Accountant or tax adviser not yet |
| Family transfer Considering | Graham and Carol give or sell shares to Emma over several years; Rory receives other assets of equal value; Janet's shares bought by the company Funded by: No outside money for a gift; a sale to Emma would need her to borrow or pay over time | Little change: Emma already runs operations. Managers who want a stake would have none Concern: Fairness between Emma and Rory; Graham and Carol's retirement income | 36 months | Accountant or tax adviser not yet |
| Employee ownership trust Considering | A trust for all employees buys a controlling interest; the price is paid over years from the company's profits Funded by: The company's future profits; possibly some bank debt | Staff become indirect owners; customers see the same management Concern: A slower, deferred price, and only half the gain relieved since 26 November 2025 | 18 months | Accountant or tax adviser not yet |
| Trade sale Ruled out | Sell all the shares to a larger hydraulics group (one approached the business in 2025) Funded by: The buyer | The works and jobs at risk of being merged into the buyer's sites; customers may move to the buyer's own brands Concern: Graham wants the business to stay independent in Cannock | 12 months | Accountant or tax adviser signed off 30 Sep 2026, decided 2 Oct 2026 |
| Pointer | Figure | Source | Bears on |
|---|---|---|---|
| T1 Business Asset Disposal Relief: the rate Capital gains tax at 18% on qualifying gains on disposals from 6 April 2026 (14% from 6 April 2025 to 5 April 2026; 10% before) | 18% Rate | GOV.UK 'Business Asset Disposal Relief' (gov.uk/business-asset-disposal-relief); checked 16 Oct 2026 | buy-out, trade sale |
| T2 Business Asset Disposal Relief: limit and conditions £1 million of gains over a lifetime. For shares: an officer or employee, and a 'personal company' (at least 5% of the shares and votes and of profits or sale proceeds), for at least 2 years up to the sale; a trading company. Claim by the first 31 January after the end of the tax year following the sale (31 January 2028 for 2025 to 2026). Not available where employee ownership trust relief is claimed | £1,000,000 Lifetime limit (£) | GOV.UK 'Business Asset Disposal Relief: eligibility' and 'How to claim'; checked 16 Oct 2026 | buy-out, trade sale |
| T3 Capital gains tax: main rates 18% on gains within the basic rate band and 24% above it, for gains from 30 October 2024 (basic rate band £37,700 and annual exempt amount £3,000 for 2026 to 2027) | 24% Higher rate | GOV.UK 'Capital Gains Tax: what you pay it on, rates and allowances: rates'; checked 16 Oct 2026 | family, buy-out, EOT, trade sale |
| T4 Gift hold-over relief Giving shares in an unlisted trading company (or a personal company) to someone: no capital gains tax for the giver; the recipient takes over the giver's cost and pays on a later sale. Giver and recipient claim jointly on the form in helpsheet HS295 with the tax return | – | GOV.UK 'Gift Hold-Over Relief' (gov.uk/gift-holdover-relief); HS295 (2026); checked 16 Oct 2026 | family |
| T5 Inheritance tax on gifts: the seven-year rule A gift is generally not taxed if the giver lives 7 years after it; if not, taper from 3 to 7 years where gifts in the 7 years before death exceed the £325,000 threshold; £3,000 annual exemption | £325,000 Threshold (£) | GOV.UK 'How Inheritance Tax works: rules on giving gifts'; checked 16 Oct 2026 | family |
| T6 Business Property Relief from 6 April 2026 100% relief on the first £2.5 million of combined business and agricultural property (raised from £1 million, announced 23 December 2025), 50% above it; unused allowance passes to a surviving spouse or civil partner; tax on qualifying shares payable in 10 interest-free yearly instalments; transitional rules for gifts made on or after 30 October 2024 where the giver dies within 7 years and on or after 6 April 2026 | £2,500,000 100% allowance (£) | IHTA 1984 s124D and s124E, inserted by the Finance (No. 2) Act 2025-26, Schedule 12; HMRC Inheritance Tax Manual IHTM25520 (updated 7 April 2026); GOV.UK policy paper 'Agricultural property relief and business property relief changes' (updated 3 March 2026); checked 16 Oct 2026 | family, contingency |
| T7 Employee ownership trust: the relief For disposals to the trustees on or after 26 November 2025, 50% of the gain is relieved and 50% is taxed at the disposal; the relieved half reduces the trustees' base cost. Business Asset Disposal Relief is not available where this relief is claimed | 50% Share of the gain relieved | GOV.UK policy paper 'Capital Gains Tax: employee ownership trusts relief reduction' (26 November 2025); TCGA 1992 s236H(2A), as substituted by Finance Act 2026 s35; checked 16 Oct 2026 | EOT |
| T8 Employee ownership trust: the conditions A trading company; the trust benefits all eligible employees on the same terms; trustees UK resident; former owners and connected persons may not control the trust; the trust gains a controlling interest in the tax year; trustees take reasonable steps so the price doesn't exceed market value and deferred payments carry a reasonable commercial rate; limited participation; relief can be clawed back to the end of the fourth tax year after the disposal | 4 Clawback period (tax years after the disposal) | TCGA 1992 s236H(4); GOV.UK policy paper 'Taxation of employee ownership trusts and employee benefit trusts' (updated 6 November 2024); checked 16 Oct 2026 | EOT |
| T9 The company buying back the owner's shares Capital (not income) treatment only if the conditions are met: an unquoted trading company; wholly or mainly to benefit the trade, not to avoid tax; the seller has owned the shares for 5 years; and the other conditions in sections 1034 to 1043. Otherwise part is taxed as a dividend. The company can ask HMRC for advance clearance | 5 Years the seller must have owned the shares | CTA 2010 s1033, s1035(1) and s1044 (legislation.gov.uk); HMRC Company Taxation Manual CTM17505 and CTM17510 (updated 24 August 2026); checked 16 Oct 2026 | buy-out |
| T10 Lasting power of attorney (property and financial affairs) Registered with the Office of the Public Guardian before it can be used: £92 for each LPA; 8 to 10 weeks if there are no mistakes. The attorney deals with the owner's own affairs, such as the shares; it does not make the attorney a director. Whether the attorney can vote the shares, and who runs the board, depend on the articles: the solicitor's call | £92 Registration fee (£) | GOV.UK 'Make, register or end a lasting power of attorney: register'; 'Changes to lasting power of attorney fees' (from 17 November 2025); checked 16 Oct 2026 | contingency |
| T11 The model articles on death Where the company uses the model articles: on death the shares pass to the personal representatives, who can't vote until registered as holders (art. 27); if no shareholder or director remains, the personal representatives of the last shareholder to die may appoint a director (art. 17(2)); the directors may refuse to register a transfer (art. 26(5)). A company formed before 1 October 2009 usually has articles based on an older Table A (1948 or 1985), not the model articles, so read the company's own articles and any shareholders' agreement | – | The Companies (Model Articles) Regulations 2008 (SI 2008/3229), Schedule 1 (legislation.gov.uk); checked 16 Oct 2026 | family, contingency |
| T12 Deferred consideration A price paid in instalments or later (common in a buy-out or a trust sale) is taxed as if received at the disposal, with no discount for the wait; if part later proves irrecoverable, a claim adjusts the tax. Plan the cash to pay the tax at completion | – | TCGA 1992 s48(1) (legislation.gov.uk); checked 16 Oct 2026 | buy-out, EOT, trade sale |
| T13 Transactions in securities and share-exchange clearances HMRC can counteract an income tax advantage from transactions in securities (for example selling shares to a new company owned by the same people); a clearance can be asked for first, and HMRC must reply within 30 days of the details. A share exchange into a new company has its own advance clearance, sought before the shares are issued | 30 Days for HMRC to reply to a clearance | ITA 2007 s684 and s701; TCGA 1992 s138 (legislation.gov.uk); checked 16 Oct 2026 | buy-out, EOT |
| T14 Inheritance tax after a sale Once the shares are sold the proceeds are cash, which gets no Business Property Relief; and shares under a binding contract for sale when the owner dies are not relevant business property (with exceptions for a sale for shares in a company that will carry on the business, and reconstructions). Plan the estate with the sale | – | IHTA 1984 s113 (legislation.gov.uk); checked 16 Oct 2026 | buy-out, EOT, trade sale, contingency |
Take advice from the accountant or tax adviser and the solicitor before any step. Rates and reliefs change: every pointer is checked on its source again within six months of the plan's date.
| Item | Adviser | Status | In place or due |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lasting power of attorney (Graham) Property and financial affairs LPA, so someone can deal with his shares and money if he can't; without one the family would need a Court of Protection deputy | Solicitor | Not started | due 31 Dec 2026 |
| Lasting power of attorney (Carol) The same for Carol, who holds 20% of the shares | Solicitor | Not started | due 31 Jan 2027 |
| Will aligned with the articles (Graham) His 2009 will leaves everything to Carol and says nothing about the shares; it should match the articles and the shareholders' agreement | Solicitor | Not started | due 31 Jan 2027 |
| Will aligned with the articles (Carol) Carol's will, so her shares don't pass by intestacy or against the plan | Solicitor | Not started | due 31 Jan 2027 |
| Shareholders' agreement (Graham) None exists: what happens to each holder's shares on death, incapacity or leaving, at what value, and Janet's 10% | Solicitor | Not started | due 31 Mar 2027 |
| Articles reviewed (Graham) The 1979 articles, amended in 2004: transmission on death, pre-emption, and how a director is appointed if Graham can't act | Solicitor | In progress | due 30 Nov 2026 |
| Board can act without the owner (Farah D) Graham is the only director: Farah D appointed as a second director so the board can meet and decide | Solicitor | In progress | due 30 Nov 2026 |
| Shareholder protection (IFA question) (Graham) A question for the IFA, not a recommendation: whether cover with a cross-option agreement would suit, so the buyers could pay the family on a death, and what it would cost | Independent financial adviser | Not started | due 31 Jan 2027 |
| Key-person cover (IFA question) (Graham) The existing £500,000 key-person policy on Graham (2019): the IFA reviewed whether the amount still fits | Independent financial adviser | In place | 12 Sep 2026 review 12 Sep 2027 |
| Bank mandates (Farah D) Second signatory: Graham or Farah D up to £50,000, both above | None | In place | 9 Oct 2026 review 9 Oct 2027 |
| Signing authorities (Farah D) A written schedule of who may sign orders, contracts and payments, and up to what amount, when Graham isn't there | None | In progress | due 30 Nov 2026 |
| Documents and access list (Graham) Where the wills, LPAs, policies, deeds and shareholder records are, and how to reach the bank, the broker and the advisers; passwords held securely, not in the list | None | Not started | due 31 Dec 2026 |
Shareholder protection and the size of the key-person cover are questions for the IFA, not recommendations. Whether an attorney can vote Graham's shares, and how a director is appointed if he can't act, depend on the articles: the solicitor's call.
Evidenced Gap, with a dated development action
| Role and the gap | Development action | Owner | Due |
|---|---|---|---|
| Supplier negotiations stakeholder relationship: Meets the two main suppliers' managing directors | Graham introduces Emma to both main suppliers' managing directors Introduction to a stakeholder | Graham | 30 Nov 2026 |
| Supplier negotiations result delivered: Held the steel tube price for 2027 | Emma runs the 2027 steel tube negotiation Delegated decision | Emma | 31 Dec 2026 |
| Key customer relationships stakeholder relationship: Has met the buyers at all three manufacturers without Graham | Graham introduces Declan W to the buyers at all three manufacturers; Declan W goes alone from April 2027 Introduction to a stakeholder | Graham | 31 Mar 2027 |
| Technical sign-off of new designs decision taken: Signed off a new design alone | Stefan O signs off the next two new designs; Graham reviews them afterwards, not before Delegated decision | Stefan O | 31 Mar 2027 |
| Key customer relationships result delivered: Kept Customer B at its 2027 renewal | Declan W leads Customer B's renewal negotiation; Graham reviews the offer before it goes Delegated decision | Declan W | 31 May 2027 |
| Managing director stakeholder relationship: Known to the bank and the three largest customers as the next managing director | Emma leads the next bank review and the three manufacturers' annual reviews, with Graham there but not leading Mentoring by the outgoing owner | Graham | 30 Jun 2027 |
| Technical sign-off of new designs stakeholder relationship: The customers' engineering teams accept his sign-off | Stefan O presents the design reviews to the customers' engineering teams, with Graham attending the first Shadowing | Stefan O | 30 Sep 2027 |
Steps by the quarter they are due; done to do. The contingency steps come first: the owner is exposed now.
| Due | Step | Owner | Adviser | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Oct 2026 | Graham's intentions written down and shared with Carol Communications | Graham | – | Done |
| 15 Oct 2026 | Advisers' quotations received: solicitor, accountant, valuer, IFA Route decision | Farah D | – | Done |
| 30 Nov 2026 | Articles reviewed Contingency | Graham | Solicitor | In progress |
| 30 Nov 2026 | Farah D appointed as a second director Contingency · waits for step 3 | Graham | Solicitor | In progress |
| 30 Nov 2026 | Signing authorities schedule agreed by the board Contingency · waits for step 4 | Farah D | – | Not started |
| 31 Dec 2026 | Graham's and Carol's lasting powers of attorney signed and sent for registration Contingency | Graham | Solicitor | Not started |
| 31 Dec 2026 | Documents and access list written and lodged with the solicitor Contingency | Graham | – | Not started |
| 29 Jan 2027 | Quarterly readiness review of the successor map with Emma, Farah D, Declan W and Stefan O Successor readiness | Graham | – | Not started |
| 31 Jan 2027 | Graham's and Carol's wills aligned with the articles Contingency · waits for step 3 | Graham | Solicitor | Not started |
| 31 Jan 2027 | IFA's answers on shareholder protection and key-person cover; Graham decides Contingency | Graham | Independent financial adviser | Not started |
| 26 Feb 2027 | Formal valuation of the shares Route decision | Farah D | Valuer | Not started |
| 31 Mar 2027 | Shareholders' agreement drafted and signed Contingency · waits for step 3 | Graham | Solicitor | Not started |
| 31 Mar 2027 | Tax adviser's report on the three routes still considered (relief, timing, clearances) Tax and legal · waits for step 11 | Farah D | Accountant or tax adviser | Not started |
| 1 Apr 2027 | Emma appointed to the board Governance | Graham | Solicitor | Not started |
| 30 Apr 2027 | Second family meeting: the routes, fairness between Emma and Rory, Janet's shares Route decision · waits for step 13 | Graham | – | Not started |
| 31 May 2027 | Route decided, with the advisers' sign-off Route decision · waits for step 14 | Graham | Accountant or tax adviser | Not started |
| 30 Sep 2027 | Heads of terms with the buy-out team (if the buy-out is decided) Route steps · waits for step 15 | Graham | Solicitor | Not started |
| 29 Oct 2027 | Contingency checklist reviewed Contingency | Farah D | Solicitor | Not started |
| 31 Dec 2027 | Bank funding offer for the buy-out company Route steps · waits for step 17 | Farah D | Accountant or tax adviser | Not started |
| 31 Jan 2028 | HMRC advance clearances applied for before completion Tax and legal · waits for step 17 | Farah D | Accountant or tax adviser | Not started |
| 31 Mar 2029 | Completion: the buy-out company buys the shares; Emma becomes managing director, Graham non-executive chair Route steps · waits for step 18 | Graham | Solicitor | Not started |
| 31 Mar 2031 | Last deferred payment to Graham; Graham steps off the board Route steps · waits for step 21 | Farah D | Accountant or tax adviser | Not started |
| Date | Audience | Message, channel and who tells them |
|---|---|---|
| 2 Oct 2026 | Family: spouse or partner Carol | Graham's intention to step back by 2029, the routes he is looking at, and what it means for their income Face to face · Graham |
| 24 Oct 2026 | Family: children Emma and Rory, together | The intention, the routes, and that fairness between them is on the table; nothing is decided Family meeting · Graham |
| 31 Oct 2026 | Family: other shareholders Janet | The intention, and that her 10% will be dealt with fairly in any route Visit · Graham |
| 13 Nov 2026 | Management team Farah D, Declan W and Stefan O | Graham's timetable; a buy-out is being looked at; the readiness map; in confidence Meeting · Graham |
| 29 Jan 2027 | Bank Relationship manager | The plan, the contingency steps in place, and a buy-out funding request to come Meeting · Farah D |
| 29 Jan 2027 | Insurer Broker | The second director, the key-person cover review and any change of control later Call · Farah D |
| 18 Jun 2027 | All staff Everyone, at both shifts | Graham's plan, Emma's role, and that jobs and the Cannock works stay as they are Briefing · Graham |
| 16 Jul 2027 | Key customers The three manufacturers | The succession, who leads their account now, and that nothing changes in supply Visit · Declan W |
| 30 Sep 2027 | Suppliers Steel tube and seal suppliers | Who they deal with from now on Call · Emma |
| Adviser | What they are asked to do, and the questions | This plan's work | At the transaction stage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Solicitor Retained solicitors (corporate and private client) | Review the articles; draft the shareholders' agreement; Graham's and Carol's wills and lasting powers of attorney; the second director Questions: Do the articles let an attorney vote Graham's shares? What happens to Janet's 10% on any route? What should the shareholders' agreement say on death, incapacity and value? | £8,500 quotation 7 Oct 2026 | £45,000 estimated |
| Accountant or tax adviser The company's accountants (tax partner) | A report on the three routes still considered: reliefs, timing, clearances and what each means for Graham, Carol and Janet Questions: When must Graham stay an officer to keep Business Asset Disposal Relief? How does the £2.5 million Business Property Relief allowance apply to Graham's and Carol's shares? Gift hold-over for a family transfer? Buy-back or new company for the buy-out, and which clearances? | £7,500 quotation 9 Oct 2026 | £18,000 estimated |
| Valuer Independent chartered business valuer | A formal valuation of the shares, with the discount a sale forced within a year of an owner's death would carry Questions: What is the range for 100%, for Graham's 70%, and for Janet's 10%? How much lower would a forced sale be? | £6,000 quotation 8 Oct 2026 | – |
| Independent financial adviser Independent financial adviser | Questions only: shareholder protection with a cross-option agreement, the key-person cover, and Graham and Carol's retirement income Questions: Would shareholder protection suit, and what would it cost? Is the £500,000 key-person cover still the right amount? How much income do Graham and Carol need, and from what? | £1,500 assumed | – |
The IFA's fee is assumed until the quotation arrives (noted on Checks). Transaction-stage fees are paid if a route goes ahead, plan or no plan, so they are shown but not set against the plan's value. There is no referral arrangement with any adviser.
Without the plan With the plan (the owner's assumption)
| Event | Cost without the plan | With the plan | Reduction | Likelihood over the transfer period (assumed) | Expected cost | Break-even likelihood (half as well) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 Graham dies or can't work suddenly, with no attorney, aligned will or shareholders' agreement | £1,831,000 | £1,558,000 | £273,000 | 6% official statistics | £109,860 | 13.2% (26.4%) |
| E2 Emma leaves before the hand-over | £451,000 | £27,500 | £423,500 | 15% owner's judgement | £67,650 | 8.5% (17.0%) |
| E3 A family dispute over fairness or Janet's 10% delays the transfer | £652,000 | £156,000 | £496,000 | 10% owner's judgement | £65,200 | 7.3% (14.5%) |
| E4 Business Asset Disposal Relief is lost because a qualifying condition fails in the two years before the sale | £60,000 | £0 | £60,000 | 10% owner's judgement | £6,000 | 60.0% (over 100%) |
Each cost is the gross profit at risk (sales ledger) × the share lost × the months it lasts, plus the share of value lost on a forced or delayed sale (from the valuer's range or the accountant's view, applied to the low end of the valuation range), plus one-off costs from quotations or the tax adviser's figure. The forced-sale discount on Graham's death is kept the same with the plan, because no shareholder protection cover is in place: the plan counts no effect from cover it doesn't have. In two events both lost gross profit and a forced-sale discount are counted; a buyer's discount may already reflect the lost profit, so the owner and the valuer judge together whether both apply (noted on Checks). The likelihood of Graham's death or incapacity starts from the ONS life table (about 5% for a man of 62 over 4.5 years). With the owner's assumed likelihoods over the 4.5 years to completion (not a forecast) the events cost £248,710; if the plan works as assumed it cuts that by £135,505; £67,753 if half as well. The plan's cost in full is £35,979 (£6,500 fee, £23,500 advisers, £184 official fees, £1,520 team time, £4,275 the owner's time, £0 premiums). The break-even needs no likelihood: the plan pays for itself on one event alone if that event was at least that likely; it still rests on the owner's assumed effect.
| Measure | Now | Compared with | Re-measure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Contingency items in place | 2 of 12 | 1 at the start | 16 Apr 2027 |
| Readiness evidence items evidenced | 8 of 15 | 6 at the start | 16 Apr 2027 |
| Timetable steps done by their due date | None of 2 | the steps due so far | 16 Apr 2027 |
Small counts: they show direction, not proof.
The shareholdings, routes, roles, evidence, contingency items, steps and messages are as agreed with the owner, the family and the managers on 16 Oct 2026. The tax and legal pointers are those on Tax and Legal, each checked on its official source on the date shown; they are pointers, not tax or legal advice, and no route is decided without an adviser's sign-off. The valuation range is from the Maintainable Profit Review of 22 Sep 2026, an indication, never invented, and the value case uses its low end. Advisers' fees are the client's own cost, from quotations or assumed until one arrives. The gross profit at risk is from the owner's records; how much would be lost, for how long, the share of value lost on a forced or delayed sale, and the plan's effect are the owner's estimates and assumptions or an adviser's view as each row says, not tested; so is each event's likelihood over the transfer period, which is never a fact, so the expected costs hold only with those likelihoods, and the break-even likelihoods still rest on the assumed effect. The measures (contingency items in place, readiness evidence, steps on time) are small counts: they show direction, not proof.
The plan is finished when it is handed over: the contingency checklist, the readiness map, the timetable, the communications plan and the adviser briefing pack. Review the readiness map every quarter and the contingency checklist every year.