Bread, rolls and cakes baked overnight for retailers, cafés and caterers across the West Midlands. 94 staff.
Verdict: 91 people in 12 jobs at 5 levels. Pay averages 0.97 of the band midpoints: 12 below; 75 in band; 2 above; 2 on a youth or apprentice rate. Bringing everyone below band up to the minimum costs £12,917 a year (£15,242 with NIC and pension); you chose to do it in full this year. Next April’s projected rates add £12,070 (£14,188 with NIC and pension). Within the pay review budget of £77,262, that leaves £52,275 (2.0% of the pay bill) for general increases. 2 people are above their band maximum: hold their base pay (a lump sum instead of a rise) until the band catches up, and tell them why. Equal pay: 4 groups compared, 1 with a difference of 5% or more (first: level 2); 10 too small to compare. That is a screen, not a legal finding: check whether the work is really alike, and write down the reason for any difference. Not legal advice.
Bands come from three named sources: the pay club survey (six months old), September’s local job adverts, and an agency guide that is 19 months old and should be refreshed before the bands are used. At level 1 the National Living Wage, not the market, sets the bottom of the band (marked NLW below), so those bands are narrower than planned. All six drivers sit below a band built from this autumn’s adverts (average compa-ratio 0.85): the clearest retention risk in the business. Taking the drivers to their band midpoint, or to the advertised median, would cost £32,500 a year: but adverts often include night and shift premiums, and this review compares base pay, so the true gap is probably smaller. The Maintenance Engineer band holds a 41% spread of pay, from a newer engineer below the minimum to a long-serving one above the maximum. At level 2 the Office Administrator band starts at the same National Living Wage floor as level 1, and level 3 starts only 4% higher: a promotion barely pays.
NLW: the minimum is set by today’s National Living Wage. April: the minimum or midpoint falls below next April’s projected rate, so the band needs lifting before then.
| Job | Minimum | Midpoint | Maximum | People | Compa-ratio | Below | Above |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Production Operative Level 1 · Food and drink employers' pay club survey 2026, 6 months old · good match | £25,847 NLW April | £26,800 | £29,236 | 30 | 1.00 | – | 1 |
| Hygiene Operative Level 1 · Local recruitment agency salary guide 2025, 19 months old · partial match | £25,847 NLW April | £26,000 | £28,364 | 7 | 1.00 | – | – |
| Warehouse Operative Level 1 · Job adverts within 20 miles (sample of 40), 1 months old · good match | £25,847 NLW April | £27,500 | £30,000 | 9 | 0.96 | – | – |
| Delivery Driver (Category C) Level 2 · Job adverts within 20 miles (sample of 40), 1 months old · good match | £31,556 | £35,500 | £39,444 | 6 | 0.85 | 6 | – |
| Skilled Baker Level 2 · Food and drink employers' pay club survey 2026, 6 months old · good match | £27,111 | £30,500 | £33,889 | 10 | 0.91 | 4 | – |
| QA Technician Level 2 · Food and drink employers' pay club survey 2026, 6 months old · partial match | £26,667 April | £30,000 | £33,333 | 3 | 0.97 | – | – |
| Office Administrator Level 2 · Job adverts within 20 miles (sample of 40), 1 months old · good match | £25,847 NLW April | £26,500 | £29,444 | 5 | 1.01 | – | – |
| Team Leader Level 3 · Food and drink employers' pay club survey 2026, 6 months old · good match | £28,696 | £33,000 | £37,304 | 6 | 0.94 | – | – |
| Customer Service Executive Level 3 · Local recruitment agency salary guide 2025, 19 months old · partial match | £26,957 | £31,000 | £35,043 | 4 | 0.97 | – | – |
| Maintenance Engineer Level 4 · Local recruitment agency salary guide 2025, 19 months old · good match | £37,447 | £44,000 | £50,553 | 5 | 0.96 | 1 | 1 |
| Shift Manager Level 4 · Food and drink employers' pay club survey 2026, 6 months old · good match | £34,043 | £40,000 | £45,957 | 3 | 0.92 | 1 | – |
| Department Manager Level 5 · Food and drink employers' pay club survey 2026, 6 months old · partial match | £45,833 | £55,000 | £64,167 | 3 | 1.02 | – | – |
| Group | Women | Men | Women’s against men’s | Screen |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Production Operative | 16 | 13 | -1.4% | Within 5% |
| Level 1 (same level, different jobs) | 23 | 21 | -2.4% | Within 5% |
| Level 2 (same level, different jobs) | 10 | 14 | -6.5% | Difference of 6%: explain it |
| Level 3 (same level, different jobs) | 5 | 5 | +0.9% | Within 5% |
Suppressed (fewer than five of one sex, so no averages are shown): Hygiene Operative, Warehouse Operative, Skilled Baker, QA Technician, Team Leader, Customer Service Executive, Shift Manager, Department Manager, level 4, level 5. At level 2, women’s average full-time pay is 6% below men’s: the drivers (all men) earn more than the office administrators (all women) placed at the same level. That may be justified by a licence and market shortage, but the business must be able to show it, and must check whether the levels really rate these jobs’ demands as equal. Whole business, for information, women’s and men’s mean hourly base pay (not the statutory gender pay gap measure): £13.71 against £15.43 an hour (-11%). Base pay only; the statutory measure (required from 250 employees) uses ordinary pay including allowances and shift premiums, and the median too.
Band midpoints come from the market medians you entered from 3 named sources (the oldest 19 months old), at 100% of the median, with the band spreads you chose for each level; the bottom of every band is at least the full-time National Living Wage (£12.71 an hour). Next April’s rates are a projection (£13.15 an hour for 21 and over), not yet announced. The legal minimum rates, employer NIC (15% above £5,000 a year; none below £50,270 for under-21s and apprentices under 25), the Employment Allowance and the pension (3% of qualifying earnings, for everyone not opted out) are as entered on Inputs from gov.uk and the Pensions Regulator. Pay is base pay only, without overtime, shift premiums or bonus; the minimum-wage test uses the unpaid working time and salary sacrifice you entered, over a year rather than each pay period. The equal-pay screen compares women’s and men’s average full-time pay in the same job or level where there are at least 5 of each: a prompt to look, not a statistical test or a legal finding.
Next April’s figures are the owner’s projection: replace them with the announced rates when the government confirms them. The government also plans to bring the 18 to 20 rate up to the National Living Wage over time (planned, not yet law). Pay barely follows performance (average compa-ratio by rating: Exceeds 0.99; Meets 0.96; Below 0.97), and the two red-circled people have the longest service (Below 5.1; in band 6.7; above 20.5). Re-run it in the spring once the new rates are known, and before the pay review. Not legal advice.