Designs, erects and hires tube-and-fitting and system scaffolding for main contractors and developers, from a yard in Derby. 86 staff. Segment: Main contractors on commercial and education projects (new build and refurbishment) in the East Midlands.
Verdict: The map rests on 79 scores on evidence for us and 5 rivals across 12 factors (4% unknown), and on what 18 customers said (44% lost deals or prospects). Customers value most: Price level; Starts on the agreed day; Alterations within 24 hours. Crowded: Starts on the agreed day; Alterations within 24 hours; Carded, supervised gangs; Inspection paperwork. Open space: Starts on the agreed day; Alterations within 24 hours. The plan raises 2, reduces 1, eliminates 1 and creates 2 factors, each on enough customer evidence and with a test; on the estimates they cost £37,800 a year net in cash, to be recovered in price or wins, and free £16,500 of staff time. The proposed curve is clearly different from every rival. The positioning statement is written (61 words), but its promises aren't yet shown: an internal draft until the tests pass. It feeds 5 catalogue products: 4 of 5 uses ready now; first waiting: Landing Page Conversion Plan: waiting for every promise in the statement to be shown by records or a passed test. Main measure: the discount off the baseline rate card on each quotation, 6.7% in the same months a year earlier, could show a realistic change by the re-measure; the win rate against Rival C (33% of 6) can only show direction. Measure again on 1 Sep 2027 (early read 30 May 2027).
Haverlow now Haverlow proposed Rivals A to E (dashed) Crowded: every firm within a point Open space: valued, nobody above 3
9 of 11 factors within a point of the rival average; closest: Rival A. Before this, Haverlow’s quotations told contractors what every rival’s do: safe, reliable, experienced. The canvas shows why price ends up deciding: on the factors customers rate highest, every firm sits within a point of the others. The red line is the proposed curve: raised where customers say it matters most and nobody delivers it well, cut where Haverlow spends money customers say they don’t value, and two new factors nobody offers.
| Factor | Customers: matters | Importance | Us | A | B | C | D | E | Finding | Action |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Price level (5 = dearest) | 8 | High | 3 | 4 | 2 | 5 | 3 | 2 | Near a band edge. | Keep |
| Starts on the agreed day | 11 | High | 3 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 | Crowded. Open space. | Raise → 5 |
| Short lead time to start | 3 | Medium | 3 | 2 | 4 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Near a band edge. | Keep |
| Alterations within 24 hours | 9 | High | 2 | 3 | 2 | 3 | 3 | 2 | Crowded. Open space. | Raise → 5 |
| In-house scaffold design | 3 | Medium | 4 | 5 | 1 | 5 | 2 | 1 | Near a band edge. | Keep |
| Safety accreditations and record | 4 | Medium | 4 | 4 | 2 | 5 | 4 | 3 | Qualifier. | Keep |
| Carded, supervised gangs | 5 | Medium | 4 | 4 | 3 | 4 | 4 | 3 | Crowded. | Keep |
| Inspection paperwork | 2 | Low | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | 3 | ? | Crowded. Qualifier. Near a band edge. | Keep |
| Single point of contact | 2 | Low | 3 | 2 | ? | 2 | 4 | 3 | Near a band edge. | Keep |
| Branded, repainted kit | 0 / 3 no | Low | 4 | 4 | 2 | 4 | 3 | 2 | Over-served. | Reduce → 2 |
| Flexible hire extensions | 1 | Low | 2 | 2 | 3 | 1 | ? | 3 | Keep | |
| Monthly progress meetings | 0 / 4 no | Low | 4 | 4 | 1 | 4 | 2 | 1 | Over-served. | Eliminate → 0 |
| Live inspection status online (new) | 4 | Medium | ? | 1 | 1 | 2 | 1 | 1 | New factor. | Create → 4 |
| Fixed-price alterations list (new) | 5 | Medium | ? | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 1 | New factor. | Create → 4 |
Scores run 1 to 5 (5 gives customers the most of it); price is scored as price level, 5 the dearest. “?” means no evidence: not guessed. 79 scores on evidence; 3 unknown or missing of 72 (4%); oldest 9 months. Rivals are labelled A to E; the words that identify them stay on the internal Inputs sheet.
Says it matters Says it doesn’t matter Distinct customers, of 18 heard from.
Counted by distinct customer, so one talkative customer counts once. Three said branded kit makes no difference and four said they don’t need the monthly meeting: that is the evidence behind the cuts. Nobody said either matters.
Starts on the agreed day (3 → 5)
Adds £14,000 a year (owner's estimate)
Evidence: 11 of 18 customers and lost prospects put the start date first (CUS-01 to 05, 07, 09; LOST-01, 02, 04; PRO-01)
Test: Confirm the start date in writing five working days ahead on the next 10 jobs and log the actual start; it works if 9 of 10 start on the agreed day (Contracts director, by 29 Jan 2027)
Alterations within 24 hours (2 → 5)
Adds £21,000 a year (owner's estimate)
Evidence: 9 of 18 raised alteration speed, three of them lost prospects (CUS-01, 03, 04, 06, 08; LOST-02, 03, 05; PRO-02)
Test: Run an alterations gang on call for 8 weeks on the six largest live jobs and log hours from request to done; it works if 90% are done within 24 hours (Operations manager, by 26 Feb 2027)
Branded, repainted kit (4 → 2)
Saves £8,000 a year (estimate from records)
Evidence: 3 customers said the colour of the kit makes no difference (CUS-04, CUS-09, LOST-03); nobody said it matters
Test: Repaint on a three-year cycle from January and brand only the boards; it works if no contractor raises kit appearance in the next 20 site visits (Yard manager, by 31 Mar 2027)
Monthly progress meetings (4 → 0)
Frees £16,500 a year of staff time (estimate from records; cash only if roles change)
Evidence: 4 said they don't need the monthly meeting (CUS-01, 03, 07; PRO-02); nobody said it matters
Test: Replace the monthly meeting with a phone call on change on five jobs, with the contractor's agreement; it works if no complaint or score drop in their feedback after three months (Contracts director, by 31 Mar 2027)
Live inspection status online (new → 4)
Adds £3,600 a year (quotation)
Evidence: 4 asked to see inspection status without chasing paper, one lost prospect among them (CUS-01, 05, 07; LOST-04)
Test: Tag three sites with QR codes for 8 weeks; it works if the site managers check the status at least weekly without being asked (Operations manager, by 26 Feb 2027)
Fixed-price alterations list (new → 4)
Adds £1,200 a year (owner's estimate)
Gives up £6,000 a year of income (owner’s estimate)
Evidence: 5 asked for alteration prices agreed up front (CUS-03, 06, 08; LOST-02; PRO-02)
Test: Include the alterations price list in the next 10 quotations; it works if no alteration on those jobs is disputed and contractors mention it in feedback (Estimating manager, by 26 Feb 2027)
Adds £39,800 and gives up £6,000 of income; saves £8,000 in cash and frees £16,500 of staff time (cash only if roles change); net £37,800 more a year in cash. Of the amounts, £36,200 rest on the owner's estimate and £24,500 on estimates from records. The costs are the owner’s estimates unless marked as a quotation or from records: not a forecast. Raising, creating and the variation income given up cost more than the cash cuts save, so the plan hands the Price Rise Plan a job: recover about £37,800 a year in price, or in wins; the staff time freed is not cash unless roles change.
“For contracts managers on commercial and school jobs in the East Midlands, who need the scaffold up on the programme date and altered the next day, Haverlow is a scaffolding contractor that starts on the agreed day and makes alterations within 24 hours at prices agreed up front. Unlike regional groups and low-price local firms, we put both promises in writing.”
Ready: a draft for Value Proposition and Messaging (61 words). Not yet shown by records or a passed test: an internal draft, not for use outside the business (CAP Code 3.7; not legal advice). It names no rival, not even by label. Start dates and 24-hour alterations are promises the tests have yet to show, so it stays inside the business until they pass: claims a customer would take as objective need documentary evidence before they are published (CAP Code rule 3.7; not legal advice). The new position goes live on 1 March 2027, after the last test.
| Rival | Kind of firm | Average gap to our curve now (points) | Clear differences from the proposed curve |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rival A | Regional scaffolding group with three depots and its own design office | 0.36 | 6 |
| Rival B | Small local firm that quotes low, mostly residential and small commercial | 1.40 | 6 |
| Rival C | National access and scaffolding company working mostly in system scaffold | 0.55 | 6 |
| Rival D | Long-established family firm in the same city | 0.70 | 6 |
| Rival E | Newer firm that wins on price and quick starts | 1.30 | 5 |
Rival A is the closest curve today: contractors find it hardest to tell the two apart, so price decides. Its baseline win rate is one of the two lowest, though, and a low start rises by chance, so the win rate is measured against Rival C, the next-closest curve. The proposed curve differs from every rival by at least 2 points on at least 5 factors.
| Source | Scores |
|---|---|
| Customer interview | 26 |
| Rival website | 14 |
| Our records | 12 |
| Mystery shop | 9 |
| Tender feedback | 8 |
| Online or trade review | 4 |
| Published price list | 3 |
| Win-loss note | 3 |
The 3 mystery shops followed a logged protocol: a hypothetical specification (never a live tender), an independent researcher in their own name with no false company identity, signed off by the managing director. No competitively sensitive information was exchanged with a competitor, directly or through a customer, supplier or trade body, and no contractor was asked for a rival’s figures while a tender was open (Competition Act 1998; CMA guidance on information exchange). Not legal advice.
| Product | What it needs | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Value Proposition and Messaging | Positioning statement | Ready now |
| Price Rise Plan | Price position against rivals | Ready now |
| Proposal Rewrite | Raise and create factors | Ready now |
| Target Account List | Factors customers value | Ready now |
| Landing Page Conversion Plan | Proven positioning statement | Waiting for every promise in the statement to be shown by records or a passed test |
Main measure, per quotation: 6.7% on 32 quotations, Mar 2026 to Aug 2026; with about 32 by the re-measure, a change under 1.7 points could be chance, so it can show a realistic change (2 points, assumed). Every quotation is priced against the baseline rate card, so a rate rise can’t pass for a smaller discount.
Does it track winning? 9.6% on 15 won against 6.4% on 40 lost (give or take 1.8 points): yes: won quotations carried deeper discounts, so if the discount falls while the win rate holds, the position is carrying the price.
Direction only: Against Rival C: 33% (2 of 6); against anyone else 23% (of 44); a change under 69 points could be chance, so it can only show direction. It is read net of the win rate against everyone else, so the season and the market cancel out.
Go-live, early read and re-measure: 1 Mar 2027; 30 May 2027; 1 Sep 2027. Illustration only, if the owner’s target win rate is reached (not a forecast): £13,688 a year in gross profit; £6,844 if it moves half as far; against £6,210 of fee and team time and £37,800 a year net cash for the four actions. The win-rate line alone wouldn’t repay the work and the actions: the case rests on what the map unlocks, and on the price the Price Rise Plan can recover.
The scores are the team's reading of 79 pieces of dated evidence on a 1-to-5 scale (price as price level), from rival websites and price lists, mystery shops under the protocol, customer interviews, win-loss notes, tender feedback, reviews and our own records; unknowns are left unknown, not guessed. Importance counts the distinct customers who said a factor matters or doesn't: how many, not how much each is worth; the high and low bands (40% and 15%), the crowded gap (1 point), the open-space level (3) and the over-served level (4) are assumed. Each action's cost is the owner's estimate unless marked a quotation, from records or an estimate from records, staff time freed is kept apart from cash, and none is a forecast. No competitively sensitive information was exchanged with a competitor (CMA guidance; not legal advice). The value case is Unlocks: it names what the catalogue products need from the map; it is not a forecast of sales. The measure-later lines come from the source named on Inputs (quotation log and CRM, quoted jobs in this segment only): the discount off the baseline rate card on 32 quotations in the same months a year before the re-measure, and the win rate against Rival C on 6 quotations that had the full 90-day window, net of the rest. The realistic changes (2 and 10 points) and the target win rate are assumed, so any £ figure is an illustration.
The map is finished when it is handed over. Re-score the rivals once a year, or sooner if one changes its prices or offer, and re-read the importance with the latest loss notes.