Servicing, repair, gas safety and canopy cleaning for commercial kitchens (schools, care homes, hotels, restaurants and pubs) across the East Midlands. 74 staff.
Verdict: Across 10 lines (£6,540,000 of revenue, 39.2% gross margin) the planned rises average 8.4%. With direct costs up about 15% since your last rise, just winning back the gross profit per sale needs 7.9%, and keeping your margin percentage 14.8%; overhead rises (such as employer National Insurance) are not in either. At your expected volume losses the rises add £417,428 of gross profit a year; £306,619 in the first year after 1 month’s notice, the fixed-price dates and caps, a net £302,719 after the cost of the change. In the cautious case: £236,225 a year. 1 line is expected to lose more volume than the rise is worth (£2,375 a year): soften or drop that rise. 1 line is one customer: if that customer goes, £261,000 of gross profit a year goes too, so talk to that customer first. Best: Repair labour (hourly rate) (All customers): £92,000. Worst: Filters, descaler and cleaning chemicals (web shop) (Trade web customers): -£2,375. Go ahead on the lines with headroom. Hold back a few customers, chosen at random, at today’s price and compare volume after 3 and 6 months.
Break-even volume loss = rise ÷ (contribution margin + rise), where the contribution margin counts only the costs that go away when volume is lost (parts all of them; salaried engineers’ time only part), and lower where lost customers take other work with them. The web shop’s filters and chemicals are a click from a rival’s price: a quarter of that volume would go, more than the 10% rise can pay for.
| Line | Revenue | Margin / contribution | Rise | Against competitors | Expected loss / break-even | Gross profit a year | First year | Cautious |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Repair labour (hourly rate) All customers Competitor prices known | £1,250,000 | 46% / 73% | 9% | -8% | 2% / 11.0% | £92,000 | £82,033 | £61,250 |
| Parts supplied with repairs All customers Judgement | £1,420,000 | 28% / 28% | 6% | +2% | 1% / 17.6% | £80,372 | £71,665 | £61,060 |
| Planned maintenance contracts Schools and councils Competitor prices known 100% on fixed prices, capped at 5% at review | £960,000 | 38% / 63% | 7% | -3% | 2% / 9.7% | £53,298 | £3,195 | £31,196 |
| Call-out charge All customers Competitor prices known | £310,000 | 70% / 85% | 18% | -12% | 3% / 17.5% | £46,221 | £41,214 | £36,642 |
| Planned maintenance contracts Care homes and hotel groups Own past rise 70% on fixed prices, capped at 5% at review | £780,000 | 40% / 64% | 8% | +4% | 3% / 10.7% | £44,952 | £22,011 | £26,304 |
| Planned maintenance contracts Restaurants and pubs Customers asked | £540,000 | 41% / 65% | 10% | -6% | 4% / 12.7% | £36,986 | £32,980 | £18,173 |
| Canopy and duct cleaning All customers Lost quotations reviewed | £380,000 | 36% / 55% | 10% | 0% | 5% / 15.3% | £25,612 | £22,837 | £13,224 |
| Planned maintenance contracts One national pub group Customers asked 100% on fixed prices One customer | £450,000 | 30% / 58% | 5% | -2% | 0% / 7.9% | £22,500 | £16,875 | £8,325 |
| Gas safety inspections and certificates All customers Judgement | £260,000 | 52% / 71% | 12% | +12% | 6% / 14.0% | £17,861 | £15,926 | £3,802 |
| Filters, descaler and cleaning chemicals (web shop) Trade web customers Competitor prices known | £190,000 | 35% / 35% | 10% | +6% | 25% / 22.2% | −£2,375 | −£2,118 | −£23,750 |
Fixed-price dates and caps hold up £68,269 of the first year’s gain: the schools and councils framework can’t change until September 2027, and then by no more than 5%. The national pub group is one customer: lose it and £261,000 of gross profit a year goes with it. 26% of revenue rests on judgement alone (parts and gas safety).
Give a month’s notice (more, and a conversation, for the largest accounts, starting with the national pub group); diary every contract’s price review date and cap. Tell customers what has gone up and what they get. Check the combined rise on a typical repair job: call-out, labour and parts all rise together. Keep 5% of customers at today’s price for six months, chosen at random, and compare their volume with everyone else’s at 3 and 6 months: that is what makes the next rise evidence-based. Each line has two marks to watch: its expected loss (on track) and its break-even (stop and rethink). Decide in advance the least rise you will accept on each line, and check the price actually achieved: a rise given back in discounts is no rise.
Not legal advice. For business customers the contract’s price variation clause decides what you can do; trade price lists must not mislead (Business Protection from Misleading Marketing Regulations 2008); the schools and councils framework follows its own terms (Procurement Act 2023); never discuss future prices with competitors or through a trade association (Competition Act 1998).
Revenue and gross margin by line come from the last 12 months’ accounts; the share of each line’s direct costs that goes away with lost volume, and its cost rise since the last price rise (14% where no line figure is given), are the owner’s estimates. Overheads are not included. The volume each rise loses is the owner’s estimate, counted beyond normal losses (26% of revenue on judgement alone). Assumed: the cautious case multiplies every loss by 2, with at least 5% on any line with a rise, and counts lost customers’ other work in full, otherwise 50% of it counts; 5% of customers are held back at today’s price for six months. The first year allows 1 month’s notice, each contract’s fixed-price date and any cap at review, with the volume lost scaled to the capped rise. Competitors may move too, and a rise that holds this year may not next: measure volume against the held-back customers after 3 and 6 months.
At handover the managing director dropped the web shop rise, as the plan advised, and phoned the national pub group before the letters went. The agent was then set up in Thornsett's own AI assistant account, with read-only access to the sales ledger and the price lists. On the first Monday of each month it enters each line's volume since the rise, the held-back customers' volume and the price actually achieved in a new dated copy of the plan, runs the checks and sends the managing director a short note. It judges each line against the two marks the plan already set, the expected loss (on track) and the break-even loss (stop), from month 3. It uses the rules on Inputs: a flag when more than 25% of a rise is given back in discounts, and 30 days' warning before notice must go on a fixed-price contract. Nothing left Thornsett, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it. These events continue the fictional example.
| Date | What the agent found | Flag? | What people decided |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2 Nov 2026 | First run. The price letters went on 30 October, with new prices from 1 December. The agent recorded the baseline: each line's volume for December to May a year earlier, and the held-back customers. The national pub group's notice, due by 1 December, had already gone. | Note only | Nothing needed. The managing director read the note. |
| 4 Jan 2027 | On the call-out charge, the price actually achieved in December was 11%, against the 18% rise. 39% of the rise was given back, mostly to regular restaurant customers, above the 25% set on Inputs. | Flag | The new charge stands. A waiver now needs the service manager's approval and a reason on the job sheet. |
| 1 Feb 2027 | The care homes and hotel groups contracts can change price on 1 April, so notice had to go by 1 March: 28 days away, inside the 30 days' warning. | Flag | The commercial manager sent the review letters by 19 February at the 5% the contracts allow, after phoning the three largest groups. |
| 1 Mar 2027 | Month 3, the first judgement. Restaurants and pubs maintenance had lost 6.5% more volume than the held-back customers: above the 4% expected, still well below its 12.7% break-even. The other lines measured were on track. | Flag | Keep the rise. The sales manager called the eight accounts that had cut visits from monthly to quarterly and offered a fixed-date visit plan. |
| 5 Apr 2027 | Gas safety inspections had lost 14.5% more volume than the held-back customers, above the 14.0% break-even: the rise was costing gross profit. | Flag | No further rise on gas safety this year. From 12 April an inspection booked with a service visit is charged at last year's price; re-measure at month 6. |
| 7 Jun 2027 | Month 6. Gas safety was back below break-even at 11.0%, though still above the 6% expected. Restaurants and pubs stood at 7.0%. Every other line was on track and nothing had newly got worse. | Note only | The held-back customers move to the new prices from 1 July. The next judgement is in December, against last year. |
At the check-in after the first monthly run, on 30 November (about six weeks after handover), Geoff and the managing director read the first log row together and confirmed the two rules on Inputs; Geoff's upkeep of the set-up ended there. No rule needed changing. As the implementation includes, Geoff went through the month-3 and month-6 notes with the managing director; every decision in the log was Thornsett's own.
What the agent added. The method is unchanged: the same lines, the same marks, the same held-back comparison. The agent made sure the measurement happened every month and that the two problems the plan warns about, a rise given back in discounts and a line losing more than it can afford, reached the managing director while there was still time to act. The benefit here is the result holding and problems caught earlier; no £ figure is claimed for it.
Fictional and labelled: these events continue the worked example. The same 6 events are the sample rows in the Agent log of the worked-example spreadsheet. The tracking table on the Agent sheet shows each line as at the last run, 7 June 2027. The agent is part of the guided and done-for-you routes; the self-implement kit does not include it.