Develops and makes chilled plant-based sauces, dips and ready meals for retailers’ own-label ranges and its own brand, Telford. 38 staff. Year to 30 June 2026.
Verdict: First: a claim notification must reach HMRC by 31 Dec 2026 (77 days), or no claim can be made for this period. Worth taking to a qualified tax adviser. 2 projects look likely to qualify and 2 arguable, with qualifying costs of £147,888 (£205,590 with the arguable ones). Estimated benefit £22,183 to £30,839 under the merged scheme, or £15,433 to £24,089 after the adviser’s fee and your team’s time. Most of it comes from Preservative-free 28-day shelf life for chilled dips (57% of the likely cost). The claim itself must be made by 29 Jun 2028. Evidence: 5 held; 3 partly; 1 not held. Before claiming, consider HMRC’s advance assurance on the doubtful points (Readiness). A screen, not a claim or tax advice.
| Project | Screen | Reasons | Cost if it qualifies |
|---|---|---|---|
| Preservative-free 28-day shelf life for chilled dips Food science: microbiology and food preservation · grant-funded | Likely | Meets each DSIT test on your answers | £85,033 |
| Egg-free dressing stable through freezing and thawing Food science: emulsions | Arguable | Only partly an advance beyond what is known in the field; Not sure a competent professional couldn’t readily have resolved it | £36,125 |
| Continuous cooking line for thick sauces Engineering: food process engineering and heat transfer | Likely | Meets each DSIT test on your answers | £62,855 |
| Lower-salt ready meals for a retailer’s own-label range Food science: flavour and formulation | Arguable | Only partly an advance beyond what is known in the field; Not sure a competent professional couldn’t readily have resolved it; Partly routine work; Not clear who decided on the R&D: check the customer contract | £21,578 |
| New packaging and recipe variants for the own brand None: marketing and recipe range | Unlikely | No advance in overall knowledge or capability in the field; A competent professional could readily have resolved it; The uncertainty is commercial, aesthetic or cosmetic, not scientific or technological; Routine work: adaptation, optimisation, fault fixing or testing a finished design; No competent professional named | £20,025 |
The shelf-life and continuous-cooking projects each sought an advance in the field, faced uncertainty a competent professional couldn’t readily resolve, and were Fernhallow’s own decision. The egg-free dressing builds on known ambient products, and the lower-salt meals were done to a retailer’s targets: the retailer may be the one who “decided” on any R&D, so the contract needs reading. New packaging and flavour variants are not R&D.
Overseas challenge testing (£5,850 after the 65% restriction) is left out: R&D done abroad counts only if the conditions it needs exist only there, and cost isn’t a reason. 56% of the counted staff cost rests on estimated shares of time. The finance manager’s time tracking the trials’ costs is counted as a qualifying indirect activity (DSIT guidelines, para 31).
| Likely only | Likely and arguable | |
|---|---|---|
| Qualifying expenditure | £147,888 | £205,590 |
| of which staff | £108,188 | £150,990 |
| of which agency workers | £0 | £11,700 |
| of which subcontractors | £15,600 | £15,600 |
| of which consumables, software, data and cloud | £24,100 | £27,300 |
| Expenditure credit at 20% | £29,578 | £41,118 |
| After notional tax at 25% | £22,183 | £30,839 |
| Estimated benefit | £22,183 | £30,839 |
| Adviser’s fee | £4,500 | £4,500 |
| Your team’s time | £2,250 | £2,250 |
| Net benefit | £15,433 | £24,089 |
R&D intensity is 2.1% of total spend, far below the 30% that ERIS needs, and Fernhallow is profitable, so the merged scheme applies. The adviser’s fixed fee is 20% of the likely benefit.
Claim notification: Needed by 31 Dec 2026 (77 days from 15 October 2026). Fernhallow has never claimed, so it must tell HMRC within six months of the period end or lose the claim for the year. Additional information form: needed with every claim, before the return. Latest date for the claim: 29 June 2028.
Advance assurance: Targeted advance assurance (pilot, until May 2027): ask HMRC about up to 2 doubtful areas (the R&D definition, overseas costs, contracted-out work, the PAYE cap exemption), one project each, before you claim for the period. For Fernhallow the obvious candidates are the retailer project (who decided on the R&D?) and the egg-free dressing (is it an advance?). Assurance and a good adviser on a fixed fee both reduce the risk of an enquiry.
| Evidence | Status | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Time records for the staff on each project (timesheets or project time logs) | Partly | 8 h |
| Records showing the uncertainty at the start of each project (specifications, test plans, design reviews) | Partly | 6 h |
| Records of the work done and the results, including what failed | Held | – |
| A named competent professional for each project, with their experience | Held | – |
| Payroll records for the staff costs claimed (salary, employer NIC, pension) | Held | – |
| Invoices for subcontractors, agency workers, consumables, software and cloud, showing where the work was done | Held | – |
| Customer contracts showing who decided on the R&D, for any work done for a customer | Partly | 2 h |
| Grant or funding letters for any funded project | Held | – |
| Draft project descriptions for the additional information form (advance, uncertainty, how resolved) | Not held | 10 h |
The biggest gap is time: four of the people whose time is counted have no timesheets, so the shares need rebuilding from trial logs and project records before an adviser can rely on them.
Each project’s result rests on your own answers to the DSIT tests (an advance in the field, uncertainty a competent professional couldn’t readily resolve, more than routine work, your own decision); 56% of the counted staff cost rests on estimated shares of time. Rates are from HMRC’s manual and gov.uk, checked 15 October 2026: credit 20%, notional tax 25% or 19%, ERIS 86% and 14.5% at 30% intensity. The tax position comes from the profit before relief, with marginal relief treated at the main rate; connected-party costs are counted at the payment; other income and group relief are ignored. HMRC decides what qualifies: a qualified adviser must review before any claim.
This is a screen, not a claim and not tax advice. HMRC checks many R&D claims and a careless claim can carry a penalty of up to 30% of the tax at stake: use a qualified adviser, prefer a fixed fee, and never sign under time pressure.