Makes commercial fryers, ovens and hot-holding cabinets in Telford, sold through catering equipment distributors, resellers and dealers, and direct to restaurant and pub groups. 70 staff.
Verdict: 17 partners bought £6,903,000 in the last 12 months (+11% on the year before), leaving £1,324,409 of gross profit after discount, rebates, funds, returns and warranty and £1,104,577 after the cost to serve them: £10.66 per £100 of list-price sales, against £16.62 direct. 2 partners lose £3,800 between them. Largest partner: Distributor A (33% of partner sales). Tiers: 6 Grow; 7 Keep; 2 Fix terms; 2 Exit. The 5 changes to do should add £23,681 a year after the risk of losing partners, for £5,670 including fixing the terms (£1,800 of it cash): a first-year net of £12,091 (£31 if they do half as well). Best in the first year: “Dealers D and F: buy through Distributor C instead of direct from us (£4,800)”. Partner terms: 7 missing; 3 not known. Recommend resale prices if you like; never fix them.
Profit counts warranty, returns and the VAT-inclusive money tied up in debts, for partners and direct alike. Black: Grow. Grey: Keep. Red: Fix terms or Exit. The distributors earn the least per £100 because they take the deepest discount and the biggest rebates, but they carry the stock, the credit and the small customers Brackenwell couldn’t serve itself. The comparison with direct isn’t like-for-like: most of a lost partner’s sales wouldn’t come back direct.
| Partner | Sales | Growth | Gross profit | Cost to serve | Profit | Tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Distributor A Distributor · National · 2 clashes | £2,250,000 | +31% | £373,188 | £45,407 | £327,781 | Grow |
| Distributor B Distributor · North and Scotland · 1 clash | £1,120,000 | -5% | £165,040 | £30,193 | £134,847 | Fix terms |
| Reseller A Reseller · London · 5 clashes | £720,000 | +18% | £162,034 | £17,522 | £144,513 | Grow |
| Distributor C Distributor · South West | £640,000 | +8% | £108,972 | £16,400 | £92,573 | Keep |
| Reseller B Reseller · Midlands · 4 clashes | £410,000 | -10% | £92,283 | £12,592 | £79,691 | Keep |
| Reseller C Reseller · North West · 1 clash | £380,000 | +27% | £95,451 | £8,948 | £86,504 | Grow |
| Reseller D Reseller · Yorkshire · 2 clashes | £265,000 | -9% | £50,367 | £14,779 | £35,588 | Keep |
| Reseller E Reseller · East Anglia | £210,000 | +11% | £52,960 | £6,535 | £46,425 | Grow |
| Dealer A Dealer · Kent · 3 clashes | £180,000 | +20% | £50,892 | £4,807 | £46,085 | Grow |
| Reseller F Reseller · Wales · 1 clash | £150,000 | -14% | £26,306 | £15,251 | £11,055 | Fix terms |
| Dealer B Dealer · Hampshire | £145,000 | +4% | £41,205 | £5,125 | £36,079 | Keep |
| Dealer G Dealer · Shropshire · 2 clashes | £120,000 | +26% | £33,928 | £3,647 | £30,281 | Grow |
| Dealer C Dealer · Devon | £95,000 | -14% | £21,892 | £8,624 | £13,268 | Keep |
| Dealer H Dealer · Sussex · 4 clashes | £70,000 | +9% | £19,595 | £3,528 | £16,066 | Keep |
| Dealer D Dealer · Lincolnshire · 1 clash | £62,000 | -22% | £10,180 | £11,818 | −£1,638 | Exit |
| Dealer E Dealer · Cumbria | £48,000 | +7% | £13,779 | £6,157 | £7,622 | Keep |
| Dealer F Dealer · Norfolk | £38,000 | -27% | £6,337 | £8,500 | −£2,162 | Exit |
4 partners clashed with the direct team on three or more deals each: rules of engagement come before any change to discounts. Deal registration should share only the customer and project, never prices or margins, because the direct team competes with the partners; and partners must stay free to answer enquiries that come to them unasked.
| Change | Plan | Expected gain a year | Cost | First-year net | Half as well |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dealers D and F: buy through Distributor C instead of direct from us Route to market · tested with similar partners, 50% chance · £14,000 a year if it works · 25% risk of losing £0 of profit (Small dealers: 2 partners) | Do | £7,000 | £450 | £4,800 | £2,175 |
| Rules of engagement: deal registration for projects over £20,000 Rules of engagement · industry practice, 30% chance · £30,000 a year if it works · 0% risk of losing £775,864 of profit (All: 17 partners) | Do | £9,000 | £3,150 | £3,600 | £225 |
| Reseller F: marketing funds only against an agreed plan; support by phone, not visits Marketing funds · tested with similar partners, 50% chance · £10,000 a year if it works · 10% risk of losing £7,739 of profit (Reseller F: 1 partner) | Do | £4,226 | £180 | £2,990 | £1,115 |
| Distributor B: pay in 60 days instead of 75, keeping today’s rebate Payment terms · partner has agreed in principle, 60% chance · £3,600 a year if it works · 0% risk of losing £94,393 of profit (Distributor B: 1 partner) | Do | £2,160 | £90 | £1,530 | £720 |
| Marketing funds paid only against a plan, claimed with proof within 90 days Marketing funds · industry practice, 30% chance · £30,000 a year if it works · 1% risk of losing £770,529 of profit (Funds: 16 partners) | Do | £1,295 | £720 | £251 | −£3,124 |
| Distributor B: pay the rebate only on sales above last year Rebate terms · industry practice, 30% chance · £33,600 a year if it works · 15% risk of losing £94,393 of profit (Distributor B: 1 partner) | Park | – | – | – | – |
“Marketing funds paid only against a plan, claimed with proof within 90 days” touches 16 partners: even a 1% risk of losing them puts £7,705 of profit against an expected £9,000, so it only just pays, and not at all if it does half as well. Introduce it at renewal, partner by partner.
Parked: “Distributor B: pay the rebate only on sales above last year”. It would save £33,600 if it worked, but at 30% odds it risks more of the distributor’s profit than it gains. Test a softer version (a rebate only above 95% of last year) first.
Brackenwell may publish recommended resale prices, but must never fix or enforce them, set minimum advertised prices, or stop partners selling online: that would be resale price maintenance under the Competition Act 1998, outside the Vertical Agreements Block Exemption Order 2022. Before exiting Dealers D or F, check neither is really a commercial agent (Commercial Agents Regulations 1993). Not legal advice.
| Check | Status | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| A written agreement with every partner: discount, rebate, funds, payment terms and notice period | In place | – |
| Discounts and rebate terms applied the same way to every partner of the same type | Missing | 6 h |
| Rebates paid only for growth or agreed targets, and reversed on goods returned | Missing | 4 h |
| Marketing funds paid only against an agreed plan, with proof of what was spent | Missing | 0 h |
| Rules of engagement: which customers your direct team keeps, and which belong to partners | Missing | 0 h |
| Deal registration: first to register wins, for a set period (e.g. 90 days), sharing only customer and project | Missing | 0 h |
| A written rule for two partners chasing the same customer | Not known | 2 h |
| Your direct sales staff aren't paid more for winning a customer from a partner | Missing | 3 h |
| Who supplies repeat orders, spares and servicing for a customer a partner won | Not known | 2 h |
| Partner reviews at a set interval, and a 90-day improvement plan before any exit | Missing | 4 h |
| Recommended resale prices only: no minimum or advertised-price rules, and partners free to sell online | In place | – |
| Notice periods known, and no partner is really a commercial agent (selling in your name on commission) | Not known | 3 h |
Most of Brackenwell’s terms live in emails and habit. The changes above cover funds, rebates and deal registration; the rest is about £1,080 of staff time, counted in the first-year cost. All-in, partners get 36% off list once rebates and funds are added to the discount.
Partners’ sales, discounts, rebates and funds come from the sales ledger. Product cost is taken as 50% of list price for every partner (differences in product mix are ignored); support hours are estimates, costed at £45 an hour; returns cost 40% of their value and money 8% a year on VAT-inclusive debts (both assumed). The direct comparison counts discount, cost of selling, returns, warranty and payment days, but leaves out stock held for direct customers, bad debts and the overheads both channels share; it isn’t like-for-like, because partners reach customers you wouldn’t reach direct. A lost partner’s profit counts at 70% (the rest won back direct, assumed). Each change counts at the chance it works (60% agreed in principle, 50% tested, 30% industry practice, 20% a hunch, all assumed), less the assumed risk of losing the partners affected, from 3 months in.
The weakest numbers are the support hours (the team’s estimate) and the product cost taken as one share of list price for every partner. Log support time by partner for a quarter before acting on the Exit tier.
At handover the sales director agreed the five changes to do, starting with deal registration and moving Dealers D and F to Distributor C. The agent was then set up in Brackenwell's own AI assistant account, with read-only access to the sales ledger, the rebate and funds records and the CRM. On the second Monday after each quarter end it loads the last two years' figures into a new dated copy of the review, runs the checks and sends the sales director a short note. It uses the rules already on Inputs (the £8 Fix terms line, the Exit rule, 3 clashes, the 30% largest-partner share, rebates on sales down 10%) and one new one: a flag when a partner's profit per £100 of list-price sales falls by more than £3. Nothing left Brackenwell, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it. These events continue the fictional example.
| Date | What the agent found | Flag? | What people decided |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9 Nov 2026 | Test run at set-up, on the latest quarter's figures. The agent rebuilt the review from the same exports, to 30 September; every figure matched and all checks passed. | Note only | Nothing needed. The sales director read the note. |
| 11 Jan 2027 | Dealer C's £3,000 year-end rebate had been paid in December although its sales were down 14%. Its profit per £100 of list-price sales fell from £10.20 to £7.89, newly in Fix terms. | Flag | From 2027 Dealer C's rebate is paid only on sales above the previous year; the channel manager told Dealer C at its February review. |
| 11 Jan 2027 | Dealer G had newly reached 3 clashes with the direct team in a year: two restaurant-group projects in November were quoted by both. | Flag | Deal registration went live on 1 February as planned, with Dealer G's two open projects registered first. |
| 12 Apr 2027 | A £9,000 marketing funds claim from Reseller F had been paid in February without an agreed plan. Its profit per £100 fell by £4.08, more than the £3 set, to £0.93. | Flag | The claim had been approved under the old terms. From 1 April every funds claim needs an agreed plan and proof of spend, as already decided. |
| 12 Jul 2027 | A new dealer appeared in the sales ledger without a type, so Checks showed CHECK and the note gave no figures. | Flag | The channel manager set its type from the signed agreement. Checks passed again the same morning. |
| 12 Jul 2027 | Dealers D and F had bought only through Distributor C since April, as decided. The Exit tier was empty. | Note only | Nothing needed. |
At the 30-day check-in on 16 November, Geoff and the sales director read the set-up test run together and confirmed the new rule on Inputs. No rule needed changing. Geoff's upkeep ended there: the quarterly reruns from January, and the agent and its log, were Brackenwell's.
What the agent added. The method is unchanged: the same partners, tiers, thresholds and changes. The agent made sure the review was rerun every quarter, so a rebate paid against falling sales or a funds claim paid without a plan was caught in the quarter it happened, not at the next annual review. The benefit here is the result holding and problems caught earlier; no £ figure is claimed for it.
Fictional and labelled: these events continue the worked example. The same 6 events are the sample rows in the Agent log of the worked-example spreadsheet. The workbook's other sheets stay as at October 2026; each rerun was saved as its own dated copy. The agent is part of the guided and done-for-you routes; the self-implement kit does not include it.