Sales and Marketing Alignment Scorecard · October 2026

Coldharbour Office Interiors Ltd

Office fit-out, refurbishment and furniture for businesses within about 60 miles of Bristol. 38 staff.

Worked example. Coldharbour Office Interiors and its figures are fictional. All figures come from the worked-example spreadsheet: ALL CHECKS PASSED (with 4 notes).
The headline

One enquiry in 12 is never followed up, and late ones win half as often

Net gain
£51,703
a year, after £8,610 for a weekly review and the extra follow-up time
Lost now
£160,062
gross profit a year: about 21 wins
Alignment
16 → 28
of 40, now and target
Followed up fast
58%
within one working day

Verdict: Sales and marketing score 16 of 40 on alignment (target 28), weakest on the handover from marketing to sales. Of 840 enquiries a year that fit, 58% are followed up within a working day and 8% never. Fast follow-up wins 15% against 8% late, so slow or no follow-up loses about 21 wins a year, £160,062 of gross profit, the largest share from Website form. Recovering 50% of the wins, up to the 8 extra customers a year the business could deliver for, is worth £60,313 a year (the capacity limit binds); after £8,610 for a weekly review and the extra follow-up time, £51,703.

The scorecard

Eight areas, scored by the people who do the work

Area and today's levelNow (black) and target (red)First action
A shared definition of a good enquiry
Today: Sales and marketing each have a rough idea, not written down
12345Agree a one-page definition with the marketing manager
Sales director
A follow-up rule
Today: An informal aim ("same day") that often slips
12345Same working day by phone; tracked weekly
Sales director
The handover from marketing to sales
Today: Enquiries arrive in inboxes and voicemail with no owner
12345Every enquiry into the CRM with a named owner
Marketing manager
Feedback from sales to marketing
Today: Complaints about lead quality, without specifics
12345Thirty-minute weekly enquiry review
Marketing manager
Shared targets
Today: Separate targets, or none
12345Report wins and gross profit by source to both
Managing director
Shared target accounts
Today: A written list both teams use
12345Keep the target account list
Sales director
Content sales actually uses
Today: Sales has a set of case studies, proposals and answers it uses
12345Build answers to the ten commonest buyer questions
Marketing manager
Systems
Today: A CRM, partly used
12345Connect the website form to the CRM
Marketing manager

Levels are cumulative: each includes everything below it, and the score is the highest level fully true. The weakest area is the handover: enquiries land in inboxes with no owner, which is why so many are answered late or not at all.

The enquiries

840 enquiries a year that fit; what slow follow-up costs, by source

SourceEnquiries (6 months)FastNeverWin rate: fastGross profit lost a yearCost per win
Website form14057%7%12%
late 8%
£50,400£214
Google Ads12050%12%10%
late 7%
£43,200£1,067
Trade show4533%11%13%
late 8%
£36,000£1,625
LinkedIn2540%20%10%
late 0%
£21,600£1,800
Phone calls6087%0%17%
late 12%
£5,538–
Referrals3087%0%31%
late 25%
£3,323–

A lost win is the gap between the fast and late win rates for late enquiries, plus the fast rate for those never answered. Fast enquiries may partly have been keener buyers, so only 50% is counted, and no more than the 8 extra customers a year Coldharbour could deliver for: that cap is what limits the gain to £60,313.

How confident are we?

What this rests on

Enquiries, follow-up speed and wins come from 6 months of the business’s own records, annualised. A lost win is the difference between the fast and late win rates for late enquiries, and the fast win rate for those never followed up; it’s valued at the gross profit on a first order, and only 50% is counted as recoverable, up to the extra customers the business could deliver for. Fast follow-up may partly reflect keener buyers, which is why only a share is counted. Repeat orders, referrals and time saved arguing are not counted. The scorecard levels are cumulative and scored by the people who do the work.

The months after

What the agent flagged, and what was decided

At handover, Coldharbour agreed its follow-up rule (the same working day, by phone), put every enquiry into the CRM with a named owner, and started a thirty-minute weekly enquiry review. The agent was then set up in Coldharbour's own AI assistant account, with read-only access to the CRM and the enquiry inbox. Each working day at 9:00 it tells the owner's manager about any enquiry that fits and has waited more than a working day; each Monday it moves the Sources counts on a week in a new dated copy, runs the checks and sends the counts to the sales director and the marketing manager for the review. It uses the target on Inputs: 90% of enquiries that fit followed up within a working day. It never replied to an enquirer. Nothing left Coldharbour, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it. These events continue the fictional example.

Slow enquiry flagged
Next morning
two Friday-evening enquiries called the next day; one booked a survey
Runs logged
6
20 October 2026 to 4 January 2027
Flags raised
4
the other runs sent the note only
Replies sent by the agent
0
every enquirer was answered by a person
DateWhat the agent foundFlag?What people decided
20 Oct 2026Two website-form enquiries from the Friday evening had had no follow-up by the end of Monday.FlagThe sales director called both the next morning; one booked a survey. Friday-evening enquiries now go to the Monday morning rota.
26 Oct 2026Last week 31 of 34 enquiries that fit were followed up within a working day (91%), and none was left unanswered.Note onlyNothing needed. Read at the weekly enquiry review.
9 Nov 2026A new Google Ads campaign doubled enquiries from that source, mostly after 17:00, and only 14 of 22 were followed up within a working day (64%), below the 90% target.FlagThe marketing manager moved the ads to office hours, and evening enquiries are called first thing the next morning.
23 Nov 2026Three LinkedIn enquiries had no fit mark, so that source's counts didn't add up and Checks showed CHECK. The note said the counts could not be relied on that week.FlagThe marketing manager marked them. Checks passed the same day.
7 Dec 2026Four of the 21 enquiries that fit from the November trade show had never been followed up after two weeks: they had gone into the CRM with no owner.FlagThe sales director gave each a named owner and all four were called that week. Trade-show enquiries now go into the CRM, with an owner, on the day.
4 Jan 2027No source had more than 10% never followed up, and 93% of enquiries in the last four weeks were followed up within a working day. The six-month figure had risen from 58% at handover to 71%.Note onlyNothing needed. Read at the weekly enquiry review.

At the 30-day check-in on 11 November, Geoff, the sales director and the marketing manager read the log together. No rule needed changing.

What the agent added. The method is unchanged: same scorecard, same counts, same checks. The agent made a slow enquiry visible the next morning, while it could still be won, and kept the weekly counts ready for the review. No £ figure is claimed for it beyond the product's own value case, which already counts the wins recovered by faster follow-up.

Fictional and labelled: these events continue the worked example. The same 6 events are the sample rows in the Agent log of the worked-example spreadsheet. The agent is part of the guided and done-for-you routes; the self-implement kit does not include it.