Haulage, warehousing and pallet distribution for food and drink manufacturers across Yorkshire and the North Midlands, from a site near Doncaster. 139 staff.
Verdict: In the 12 months to 30 Sep 2026, 41 people left (36 voluntary) from an average of 137: a turnover rate of 30% a year (26% voluntary). Replacing them costs about £226,773 a year: £121,341 in cash, £6,480 in gross profit lost while posts were empty and £98,952 in lost output and managers’ time. The costliest to replace: Class 1 driver £8,286; Class 2 driver £4,860; Warehouse operative nights £4,269. 55% of the cost was in your control (partly controllable reasons at half); the biggest controllable reasons: Pay £33,920 a year; Manager £29,632 a year. 56% of leavers went within their first year, costing £107,224 a year. Highest turnover: Warehouse nights (64% a year, against 30% for the business). The 5 actions to do should keep about 5.5 leavers a year and save £51,491 a year (£30,106 of it cash), for £13,328 in the first year (£5,600 of it cash): a first-year net of £25,291 (£5,981 if they do half as well) and £39,388 over two years, counting 50% of the saving in the second. Best for the money: “Onboarding plan for every starter: a buddy, a day-one checklist, one-to-ones in weeks 1, 4 and 12”.
Warehouse nights lost 14 of its 22 people in the year, 11 of them within their first year; Manager was the most common reason given there. Where new starters churn like this, keeping one settled person also saves the replacements who would have followed: up to two hires on the night shift (the cap on Inputs). Teams with fewer than 5 leavers are combined, so no one can be picked out.
| Role | Post empty | Recruitment (cash and time) | Starter costs | Learning and training | Per leaver | A year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Class 1 driver 9 left, 9 replaced | £2,160 | £2,539 | £450 | £3,137 | £8,286 | £74,578 |
| Warehouse operative nights 14 left, 14 replaced | £600 | £1,812 | £180 | £1,678 | £4,269 | £59,768 |
| Warehouse operative days 9 left, 8 replaced | £360 | £1,648 | £180 | £1,527 | £3,715 | £29,720 |
| Class 2 driver 5 left, 4 replaced | £1,000 | £1,613 | £400 | £1,847 | £4,860 | £19,441 |
| Other roles (3) some estimates 4 left between them; each has fewer than 5 leavers | – | – | – | – | – | £43,265 |
Over half the cost is cash: agency fees and job boards, starter costs such as tachograph cards, driver checks and kit, and the agency or overtime premium while the post is empty. For Class 1 drivers it also includes the margin lost on loads given to another haulier. The rest is the output a new starter can’t yet give and the hours managers spend recruiting and training. On-costs include the Apprenticeship Levy, as the pay bill is above £3 million. Roles with fewer than 5 leavers are combined; two of them are costed on estimates and should be firmed up from invoices.
| Reason | Leavers | In first year | Cost a year | In your control? | Controllable a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pay | 9 | 2 | £67,841 | Partly | £33,920 |
| Manager | 6 | 4 | £29,632 | Yes | £29,632 |
| Hours/flexibility | 6 | 4 | £29,380 | Partly | £14,690 |
| Progression | 4 | 1 | £26,885 | Partly | £13,443 |
| Involuntary under 6 months | 4 | 4 | £20,540 | Partly | £10,270 |
| Not known | 4 | 3 | £19,986 | Partly | £9,993 |
| Workload | 3 | 3 | £12,844 | Yes | £12,844 |
| Retirement | 2 | 0 | £8,286 | No | – |
| Relocation | 2 | 1 | £7,984 | No | – |
| Involuntary 6 months or more | 1 | 1 | £3,394 | No | – |
“Partly” counts half in the controllable cost, but an action on a partly controllable reason is not cut twice: its expected reduction already says how many of those leavers it could keep. Pay is the biggest controllable reason by cost, but a £1,800 rise for all 34 Class 1 drivers would cost £70,686 a year with on-costs, against about £9,040 a year of turnover cost it might save. It stays parked: a pay review may still be right for recruitment or fairness, with market evidence on file.
| Action | Plan | Leavers kept a year | Saving a year | First-year cost | First-year net | Two-year net |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Onboarding plan for every starter: a buddy, a day-one checklist, one-to-ones in weeks 1, 4 and 12 All reasons · All · first-year leavers · own trial in another team · 30% fewer leavers if it works, 50% chance | Do | 3.1 | £26,203 | £3,776 | £15,876 | £25,762 |
| Manager development for the night-shift manager and team leaders: monthly one-to-ones, handling absence, giving feedback Manager · Warehouse nights · leavers told us · 50% fewer leavers if it works, 50% chance | Do | 1.2 | £10,673 | £4,192 | £3,813 | £5,405 |
| Stay interviews twice a year with every driver All reasons · Drivers · best practice · 20% fewer leavers if it works, 30% chance | Do | 0.7 | £7,482 | £1,904 | £3,708 | £5,769 |
| Fixed night-shift patterns, rotas published four weeks ahead, and a shift-swap rule Hours/flexibility · Warehouse nights · leavers told us · 40% fewer leavers if it works, 50% chance | Do | 0.6 | £5,123 | £1,008 | £2,834 | £4,724 |
| Driver referral scheme: £500 to the referrer once the new driver passes probation All reasons · Class 1 driver · best practice · 14 fewer days empty and 15% fewer agency hires, 30% chance | Do | 0.0 | £4,192 | £2,448 | £696 | £456 |
| Pay review: Class 1 drivers up £1,800 a year (34 drivers, with on-costs) Pay · Class 1 driver · leavers told us · 50% fewer leavers if it works, 50% chance | Parked | 0.8 | £9,040 | £70,854 | −£64,074 | −£130,240 |
| Class 2 to Class 1 training route: two places a year Progression · Drivers · best practice · 40% fewer leavers if it works, 30% chance | Parked | 0.2 | £1,697 | £6,616 | −£5,343 | −£10,831 |
The five actions to do cost £5,600 in cash; the rest of the £13,328 first-year cost is managers’ time. Where they cover the same people, the onboarding plan and the night-shift actions for example, they are combined leaver by leaver (a person both could keep is counted once), so the £51,491 total is less than the rows added up. Of the saving, £30,106 is cash and £19,791 is lost output and managers’ time. The second year counts only half the saving: £14,098 net, or £39,843 if it all lasts.
Leavers, teams and headcount come from payroll for the 12 months to 30 Sep 2026; reasons come from exit conversations and are only as good as what people said (11% of voluntary leavers’ reasons not known). Each role’s cost per leaver uses your records for pay, adverts, agency fees, days empty, cover premiums and subcontracted work, except 2 role(s) with leavers marked Estimate; on-costs of 15.5% and output of 50% while a starter learns are assumed, and gross profit lost while a post is empty counts only where entered from records. How far each reason is in your control is your judgement on Inputs: Partly counts half in the controllable cost, and any reason marked Yes or Partly is in scope for actions, whose expected reduction × chance it works (50% if leavers told us or your own trial, 30% best practice, 20% a hunch) is applied once. A kept person is worth their replacement cost × the replacements their team’s first-year leavers would need (capped at 2.0). Actions build up over 6 months, overlapping actions are combined leaver by leaver, and later years count 50% of the saving. It assumes next year’s leavers look like last year’s.
Repeat the review every six months from payroll and the exit conversations; the measures are leavers in their first year and the night shift’s rate, not the cost estimate. Exit conversations are voluntary: hold them before the last day, note reasons in categories, and keep any personal detail out of the spreadsheet. Shift-pattern changes need consultation and care with night workers’ health assessments; this is not legal advice.
Fictional, continuing the example. Brantingley started the five actions to do and chose the guided route. The agent was set up in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to payroll's leavers and headcount reports and the reason category on each exit conversation record (its IT confirmed this before it committed). On the first working day of each month it adds the month's leavers to a new dated copy of the review, rolls the twelve months forward, costs each new leaver at their role's figures, runs the checks and sends the managing director a short note that names no one. It uses the owner's lines on Inputs: a team's rate up more than 10 points since the review (small teams by count only), a team newly above 2 times the business's rate, one leaver costing more than £10,000 to replace, first-year leavers above 40% and rising, or reasons not known for more than 30% of voluntary leavers. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it.
| Date | What the agent flagged | What was decided |
|---|---|---|
| 3 Nov No flag | October’s three leavers were costed as they went (a Class 1 driver at £8,286 and two night operatives at £4,269 each) and the twelve months rolled forward. Warehouse nights stood at 68% a year. Nothing over a line. | Nothing needed. The managing director read the monthly note. |
| 1 Dec Flag | A transport planner resigned for progression: £13,450 to replace, above the £10,000 line. | The managing director filled the post inside, moving up the Class 2 driver who had covered planning, and advertised the driver post instead, with no agency. |
| 5 Jan Flag | Warehouse days rose 11 points since the review, to 35% a year: four leavers in November and December, three within their first three months. | The operations director started the onboarding plan on the day shift straight away, instead of after nights. |
| 2 Feb Flag | The reason was not known for 35% of voluntary leavers, above the 30% line: four of the five day-shift leavers since November had no exit conversation. | The HR and payroll manager now holds an exit conversation within a week of every notice, and rang the four recent leavers herself; three gave a reason. |
| 2 Mar No flag | Warehouse nights was down to 52% a year from 64% at the review. Nothing over a line. | Nothing needed. The figures were shared with the night-shift manager. |
At the check-in on 4 December, about day 45 from handover and after the first monthly runs, Geoff and the managing director read the first two notes and the log together. No rule needed changing, and Geoff's upkeep of the set-up ended there. What the agent added. The method is unchanged: same roles, same costs, same checks, same decisions. The agent made sure every leaver was costed as they went and each team compared with the review every month. One flag turned an expensive resignation into a promotion before an advert went out, one moved an action to the team that needed it first, and one restored the exit conversations the reasons depend on. Night-shift turnover falling from 64% to 52% is the actions working; the review already counts their value, so the months after add no £ figure.