Chilled desserts and patisserie (cheesecakes, tarts and trifles) made for three supermarket groups' own labels and for foodservice, from two sites near Northallerton, North Yorkshire. 340 staff. Preparing successors for the managing director, who retires in 2029.
Verdict: 3 candidates for 1 role (top job: Managing director). All seven parts of the deliverable are complete; the board agreed its decision criteria before anyone was scored. At baseline the candidates reached Isla 73%; Magnus 65%; Yusuf 76% of the required level; 17 gaps, every one with a dated action. Now: Isla: plan in place for 29 Mar 2029; Magnus: plan falls short of 29 Mar 2029; Yusuf: plan in place for 29 Mar 2029. The board decides on 29 Mar 2029; the scorecard informs it and does not rank. Risk avoided, not a forecast: if Barnaby left with no successor ready it would cost about £759,500 (£38,250 of it time). With the chance the owner assumes (35%) and the effect assumed (50% of it removed), the programme cuts the expected cost by £132,913 (£66,456 if half as well) against £114,354 for the programme in full; it pays for itself if it removes 43.0% of the chance. With the owner's own assumptions it covers its cost, but if it helps only half as well it does not. It feeds 3 catalogue products.
Managing director: Runs both sites and the board's agenda, holds the three supermarket accounts at the top and the bank relationship; Barnaby retires at the end of September 2029. Held by Barnaby; successor ready by 29 Mar 2029; the board decides on 29 Mar 2029.
| Competency and why it matters here | Weight | Required | Level 3, and what level 4 looks like here |
|---|---|---|---|
| Retailer and foodservice account leadership 62% of sales go to three supermarket groups on annual own-label contracts; two renewals fall due in 2027 and the range reviews decide volumes | 3 | 4 | Leads a full account, including a price negotiation, and keeps the agreed margin Level 4: Leads the top accounts at board level with the customers' senior buyers; wins or holds a range review on evidence |
| Financial and margin management Ingredient and energy costs moved margin by four points in 2023-25; cost-plus negotiations and the bank covenants need the MD to read and act on the numbers | 3 | 4 | Sets and delivers a budget; uses product and customer margin to decide prices and priorities Level 4: Owns the company's budget, cash and covenants; challenges and is challenged by the board on the numbers |
| Food safety and technical standards Retailers audit both sites; BRCGS grade AA and the retailers' codes of practice are conditions of supply; a recall would end a contract | 2 | 3 | Takes decisions that put food safety first under commercial pressure; leads the response to an audit finding Level 4: Sets the food safety culture across both sites; the retailers' technical teams trust their judgement |
| Operations and capacity planning Seasonal peaks double Christmas volumes; the second site's new tart line (£6.2 million) starts in 2027 | 2 | 3 | Plans capacity across a site for a season, including the peak Level 4: Plans capacity and investment across both sites over three years |
| Leading and developing managers 340 staff, 14% labour turnover, and a management team of nine; most managers have grown up in the business | 3 | 4 | Leads managers; develops at least one manager who is later promoted; handles a difficult conduct or capability case properly Level 4: Builds a management team that runs both sites without them; settles conflict between senior managers |
| Strategy and capital investment The board must choose between a third site and a co-packing partnership by 2028 | 2 | 3 | Leads a business case for a major investment through the board, with the risks set out Level 4: Sets the three-year direction with the board and keeps the business to it |
| Board and governance The successor will lead the board's agenda with Ingrid as non-executive and will carry a director's duties under the Companies Act 2006 | 2 | 3 | Contributes to board decisions beyond their own area; understands a director's duties and conflicts of interest Level 4: Leads the board's agenda; manages the family's and the board's expectations |
| Bank, supplier and community relationships The bank facility renews in 2028; three dairy and fruit suppliers supply 70% of ingredients; the business is the largest employer in its village | 1 | 3 | Represents the business with the bank and main suppliers on their own Level 4: Is the business's face to the bank, the main suppliers and the community |
| Candidate | Years in / outside | Wants it? | Readiness | Gaps | Actions | Client cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Isla Family Commercial manager | 9 / 6 | Yes | 73% | 6 | 11 | £6,350 |
| Magnus Family Site manager, Brompton bakery | 11 / 2 | Unsure | 65% | 6 | 10 | £11,150 |
| Yusuf Head of operations | 7 / 12 | Yes | 76% | 5 | 8 | £5,800 |
3 candidates (2 family, 1 not); every one told how they would be assessed before the baseline. Magnus says they are unsure about or don't want the role; the plan develops them either way and the board will not press (a note on Checks).
| Competency | Isla | Magnus | Yusuf |
|---|---|---|---|
| Retailer and foodservice account leadership | 4 of 4 4 · 4 | 2 of 4 2 · 2 | 2 of 4 discussed 2 · 3 |
| Financial and margin management | 2 of 4 discussed 2 · 3 | 2 of 4 2 · 2 | 3 of 4 3 · 3 |
| Food safety and technical standards | 2 of 3 2 · 2 | 3 of 3 discussed 4 · 3 | 4 of 3 4 · 4 |
| Operations and capacity planning | 2 of 3 2 · 2 | 4 of 3 4 · 4 | 4 of 3 4 · 4 |
| Leading and developing managers | 3 of 4 3 · 3 | 3 of 4 discussed 4 · 2 | 3 of 4 discussed 3 · 4 |
| Strategy and capital investment | 2 of 3 discussed 3 · 2 | 2 of 3 2 · 2 | 3 of 3 3 · 3 |
| Board and governance | 2 of 3 2 · 2 | 1 of 3 discussed 1 · 2 | 2 of 3 2 · 2 |
| Bank, supplier and community relationships | 3 of 3 3 · 3 | 2 of 3 2 · 2 | 2 of 3 discussed 3 · 2 |
Each cell: the rating that counts, of the level required; below it, each assessor's rating. Where they disagreed, they discussed the evidence and agreed a rating. Barnaby is a close relative of a candidate, which is declared, so every disagreement, even of one level, was discussed and agreed (a note on Checks). 8 disagreements: the agreed rating was Barnaby's on 2 (family) and 2 (not); Ingrid's on 2 and 1; between the two on 1. An assessor is related to a candidate, so every disagreement was discussed.
Isla · 11 actions · Plan in place for 29 Mar 2029
| Kind and gap | What happens, and the mentor or sponsor | Dates | Client cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mentoring Financial and margin management | Monthly one-to-one with Malcolm on the company accounts, cash and the bank covenants Malcolm (finance director) | 4 Jan 2027 to 20 Dec 2027 | – |
| Formal learning Financial and margin management | Finance for non-financial directors, a three-day course | 15 Feb 2027 to 17 Feb 2027 | £2,400 quotation |
| Stretch assignment Financial and margin management · criterion 4 | Prepares the 2028-29 company budget with Malcolm and presents it to the board Malcolm (finance director) | 1 Nov 2027 to 30 Mar 2028 | – |
| Rotation Food safety and technical standards | Six months as deputy to the technical manager across both sites, including two retailer audits Rhona (technical manager) | 5 Apr 2027 to 30 Sep 2027 | – |
| Rotation Operations and capacity planning | Runs the Christmas 2027 peak plan at the main site with the planning manager Ewart (planning manager) | 1 Sep 2027 to 14 Jan 2028 | – |
| Delegated decision Leading and developing managers | Takes over line management of the planning and customer service managers Barnaby (managing director) | 3 Apr 2028 to 22 Dec 2028 | – |
| Stretch assignment Strategy and capital investment | Leads the business case for the third site or a co-packing partnership Ingrid (non-executive director) | 8 Jan 2028 to 29 Sep 2028 | – |
| Board or governance exposure Board and governance · criterion 7 | Attends every board meeting from April 2027 as an observer, then as a director from April 2028 Ingrid (non-executive director) | 1 Apr 2027 to 29 Mar 2029 | – |
| Formal learning Board and governance | Company director programme (accredited), including directors' duties | 6 Sep 2027 to 26 Nov 2027 | £3,950 assumed |
| Stretch assignment · criterion 5 | Runs the business for four weeks during Barnaby's planned leave, escalating only what the board agreed Ingrid (non-executive director) | 3 Jul 2028 to 28 Jul 2028 | – |
| Stretch assignment · criterion 6 | Leads the 2028 bank review and the three supermarket groups' top-to-top meetings, with Barnaby present but not leading Barnaby (managing director) | 1 Feb 2028 to 30 Jun 2028 | – |
Magnus · 10 actions · Plan falls short of 29 Mar 2029
| Kind and gap | What happens, and the mentor or sponsor | Dates | Client cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mentoring Retailer and foodservice account leadership | Monthly mentoring with an outside mentor, a former managing director of a dairy business Sabine (outside mentor) | 11 Jan 2027 to 13 Dec 2027 | £4,800 quotation |
| Rotation Retailer and foodservice account leadership | Six months in the commercial team as account manager for the foodservice customers Elif (key account controller) | 5 Apr 2027 to 30 Sep 2027 | – |
| Formal learning Financial and margin management | Finance for non-financial directors, a three-day course | 15 Feb 2027 to 17 Feb 2027 | £2,400 quotation |
| Stretch assignment Financial and margin management | Forecasts the bakery site's labour cost monthly and explains variances to the board Malcolm (finance director) | 4 Jan 2027 to 20 Dec 2027 | – |
| Mentoring Leading and developing managers | Monthly sessions with Ingrid on how decisions are made and explained to managers Ingrid (non-executive director) | 14 Jan 2027 to 16 Dec 2027 | – |
| Stretch assignment Strategy and capital investment | Writes the business case for the bakery site's oven replacement Malcolm (finance director) | 4 Oct 2027 to 31 Mar 2028 | – |
| Outside experience Board and governance | Joins the board of governors of a local food technology college | 1 Sep 2027 to 29 Mar 2029 | – |
| Formal learning Board and governance | Company director programme (accredited), including directors' duties | 6 Sep 2027 to 26 Nov 2027 | £3,950 assumed |
| Delegated decision Bank, supplier and community relationships | Leads the annual reviews with the two main dairy suppliers Malcolm (finance director) | 3 May 2027 to 30 Nov 2027 | – |
| Board or governance exposure Board and governance · criterion 7 | Attends board meetings as an observer from October 2027 Ingrid (non-executive director) | 1 Oct 2027 to 29 Mar 2029 | – |
Yusuf · 8 actions · Plan in place for 29 Mar 2029
| Kind and gap | What happens, and the mentor or sponsor | Dates | Client cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Stretch assignment Retailer and foodservice account leadership · criterion 3 | Takes the second supermarket account for twelve months alongside his role, and leads its 2027 renewal Elif (key account controller) | 5 Apr 2027 to 31 Mar 2028 | – |
| Formal learning Retailer and foodservice account leadership | Key account negotiation course, two days | 8 Mar 2027 to 9 Mar 2027 | £1,850 quotation |
| Stretch assignment Financial and margin management | Prepares the company's cash flow forecast and covenant tests for a year Malcolm (finance director) | 4 Jan 2027 to 20 Dec 2027 | – |
| Delegated decision Leading and developing managers | Takes over line management of the two site managers Barnaby (managing director) | 3 Apr 2028 to 22 Dec 2028 | – |
| Board or governance exposure Board and governance · criterion 7 | Attends every board meeting from April 2027 as an observer, then as a director from April 2028 Ingrid (non-executive director) | 1 Apr 2027 to 29 Mar 2029 | – |
| Formal learning Board and governance | Company director programme (accredited), including directors' duties | 6 Sep 2027 to 26 Nov 2027 | £3,950 assumed |
| Delegated decision Bank, supplier and community relationships · criterion 6 | Leads the 2028 bank facility renewal with Malcolm, and meets the three supermarket groups' senior buyers with Barnaby Malcolm (finance director) | 10 Jan 2028 to 30 Jun 2028 | – |
| Stretch assignment Financial and margin management · criterion 4 | Prepares the 2027-28 company budget with Malcolm and presents it to the board Malcolm (finance director) | 2 Nov 2026 to 26 Mar 2027 | – |
Per gap, for fairness (family or not): Isla 1.8 actions and £1,058 a gap, 78% sponsored by a board member; Magnus 1.7 actions and £1,858 a gap, 71% sponsored by a board member; Yusuf 1.6 actions and £1,160 a gap, 83% sponsored by a board member. A plan falls short when a gap, or a board criterion not yet met, has nothing leading to it by the ready-by date. No candidate sponsors another's action; the two assessors sponsor some actions, which is declared (a note on Checks).
Reviews: 7 Jan 2027, 8 Apr 2027, 8 Jul 2027, 7 Oct 2027, 6 Jan 2028, 6 Apr 2028, 6 Jul 2028, 5 Oct 2028, 4 Jan 2029, 8 Mar 2029.
| Criterion (agreed by the board on 15 Sep 2026) | Isla | Magnus | Yusuf |
|---|---|---|---|
| Every competency at the level the role requires Every competency at the required level | Not yet | Not yet | Not yet |
| At least six development evidence items achieved Development evidence achieved at least 6 | Not yet | Not yet | Not yet |
| Has led a supermarket contract renewal and held the agreed margin Board records Yes or No | Met | Not yet | Not yet |
| Has prepared the company budget and presented it to the board Board records Yes or No | Not yet | Not yet | Not yet |
| Has run the business for four weeks while the managing director was away, escalating only what the board agreed Board records Yes or No | Not yet | Not yet | Met |
| Has met the bank and the three supermarket groups' senior buyers as a possible successor Board records Yes or No | Not yet | Not yet | Not yet |
| The non-executive director's view, minuted: ready to lead the board's agenda Board records Yes or No | Not yet | Not yet | Not yet |
At baseline. The board decides on the evidence; the scorecard informs the decision and does not rank the candidates.
| By | Audience | What they are told |
|---|---|---|
| 15 Sep 2026 | Board | The scorecard's decision criteria, for agreement before anyone is scored Barnaby · board paper |
| 29 Sep 2026 | Each candidate individually | How they will be assessed: the framework, the evidence, the two assessors, the board's criteria, who sees what, and their right to see their own ratings Barnaby and Ingrid · in person |
| 23 Oct 2026 | Each candidate individually | Their baseline ratings, the evidence and their development plan Ingrid and Barnaby · in person |
| 4 Nov 2026 | Family council or family meeting | The programme and its timetable; that the board, not the family council, decides; readiness verdicts only, never ratings Barnaby · meeting |
| 9 Nov 2026 | Senior managers | The programme, the three candidates' development roles and how rotations affect their teams Barnaby · meeting |
| 16 Nov 2026 | All staff | Barnaby plans to retire in 2029; the board will choose his successor in spring 2029; why some managers are taking on new roles Barnaby · meeting |
| 5 Apr 2027 | Key customers and suppliers | The candidates' wider roles, as each rotation starts Isla and Yusuf · in person |
| 15 Jun 2027 | Bank and advisers | The succession plan in outline, at the facility review Malcolm · meeting |
| 2 Apr 2029 | Candidates not chosen | The board's decision, the evidence for it, and their role and development from here Ingrid · in person |
Personal data: Legitimate interests (assessment recorded); ratings kept 12 months after the decision; seen by: The board (Barnaby, Ingrid and Malcolm); each candidate sees their own ratings, evidence and plan; the family council sees: readiness verdicts only.
| If the leader left with no successor ready | £ | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Gross profit lost while the business is disrupted | £570,000 | Estimate from the records |
| Recruiting an outside successor | £36,250 | Quotation |
| Interim cover until a successor starts | £99,000 | Assumed (no quotation) |
| Key staff who leave as a result | £72,000 | Assumed |
| Less: the leader's pay saved while the post is empty | −£56,000 | Estimate (payroll) |
| Owner's or family's time stepping back in (time, not cash) | £38,250 | Estimate |
| Cost of the event, in full | £759,500 | Not relevant (no sale or transfer valued in the period): no value effect counted |
| Cost of the programme | £ | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Consultant's fee | £24,000 | Quotation (the consultant's proposal) |
| Outside mentors and formal learning, from Plans | £23,300 | Quotations, some assumed (Plans) |
| Backfill while candidates are away on rotations | £29,214 | Assumed |
| Team time | £37,840 | Estimate |
| Cost of the programme, in full | £114,354 | 445 team hours over 29.9 months |
With the chance Barnaby assumes (35% that he leaves with no successor ready, without the programme) and the effect assumed (50% of that chance removed): assumptions, never facts. The expected cost falls by £132,913 (£66,456 if the programme helps half as well) against £114,354 for the programme in full. It pays for itself if it removes 43.0% of the chance (33.7% to 59.5% across the owner's high and low gross profit figures). It covers its cost on the owner's own assumptions, but not if it helps only half as well.
| Feeds | Part it needs and what | Ready? |
|---|---|---|
| Ownership Transfer Plan | Scorecard Evidence that a successor is ready, for its successor readiness map and the timing of the route decision | Complete |
| Ownership Transfer Plan | Development plans The development actions and dates, so its readiness map and timetable match this programme | Complete |
| Non-Family Executive Hire | Framework The competencies and their descriptors, as the selection criteria if no internal candidate is on course | Complete |
| Family Constitution | Scorecard The board's agreed decision criteria, for its clauses on family members in leadership | Complete |
Measure later, direction only: 0 evidence items achieved; criteria met 2 at baseline, 2 now; next re-measure 7 Jan 2027. With three candidates no statistical test applies; the counts show direction, not proof.
The competencies come from the business's own plans and records, named against each on Framework; the required levels and the decision criteria were set by the board on 15 Sep 2026. Every rating rests on the evidence recorded against it and on two named assessors (Barnaby (managing director) and Ingrid (non-executive director)), one of whom is a close relative of a candidate (declared); every disagreement was discussed and agreed. The chance that the leader leaves with no successor ready, the share the programme removes, the months of disruption, the gross profit lost, the staff who would leave and the hours are the owner's assumptions or estimates, not facts or forecasts; at least one outside cost is assumed until a quotation arrives. With 3 candidates the measures show direction, not proof.
Not legal advice: personal data, any change to a director's appointment and any use of a licensed psychometric are for the client's own advisers and qualified users, whose fees the client pays directly.