Chilled ready meals and savoury pies for farm shops, delis and two regional grocery chains, made at a unit near Taunton. 84 staff.
Verdict: 349 invoice lines worth £1,142,312 over 6 months were tested; 99% of the value had an agreed price to test against. Found: £9,365 of overcharges to claim (price above agreed £5,722; surcharges £967; quantity above delivered £174; line totals wrong £60; possible duplicates £2,442), plus £5,539 of rebates and £690 of discounts owed: £15,565 recoverable within the 6-year limitation period (plus £1,051 VAT on the credit notes), about £10,236 expected from the claims planned once suppliers dispute some. Talk first to: Meat wholesaler (£10,309 to recover; £24,979 a year of leakage); IT and phones provider (£0 to recover; £5,880 a year of leakage); Haulier (£3,409 to recover; £1,799 a year of leakage). A further £1,960 billed above old prices after agreements ended is for renegotiating, not claiming. Left alone, the leakage runs at about £36,143 a year (1.6% of spend), with one-offs left out. The controls should stop about £7,718 a year once working, £3,312 of it by paying on time to take the early-payment discount. First-year net £11,926 (£3,432 if half as well) after a first-year cost of £5,063 (£0 of it cash); £4,478 a year after that. Not every control pays in year one: “Three-way match: order, signed delivery note or timesheet, invoice” (-£2,021 net in year one); it pays only over later years.
| Supplier | Value tested | Found | Recoverable | Expected | Leakage a year |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Meat wholesaler Materials · 3 agreements on file | £393,116 | price £4,770; rebate £5,539 | £10,309 | £7,455 | £24,979 |
| IT and phones provider IT and telecoms · 2 agreements on file | £12,724 | after the agreement ended £1,960 (renegotiate) | – | – | £5,880 |
| Haulier Carriage · 1 agreement on file | £65,891 | surcharges £967; possible duplicate £2,442 | £3,409 | £1,705 | £1,799 |
| Packaging supplier Packaging · 2 agreements on file | £112,008 | price £952 | £952 | £714 | £1,757 |
| Staffing agency Agency labour · 2 agreements on file | £298,948 | discount £690 | £690 | £207 | £1,380 |
| Waste contractor Waste · 2 agreements on file | £18,556 | quantities £174 | £145 | £102 | £348 |
| Cleaning contractor Cleaning · 2 agreements on file | £44,220 | line totals £60 | £60 | £54 | – |
| Energy supplier Utilities · 2 agreements on file | £181,858 | Nothing found | – | – | – |
| Dry goods merchant Materials · 0 agreements on file | £14,992 | No agreement to test against | – | – | – |
The meat wholesaler billed diced beef at £8.85 against the agreed £8.40 from its invoice of 10 July, and paid the volume rebate short; at September’s rate the price rise alone costs about £19,400 a year. The IT and phones agreement ended on 31 May and says it ends rather than rolls on, so the provider’s move to £62 a user is for renegotiating, not claiming. The haulier charged a 9% fuel surcharge against the 8% in its rate card, and a £15 admin fee nobody agreed. The dry goods merchant has no agreement on file, so nothing could be tested.
Undercharges of £90 (chicken thigh billed below the schedule for three weeks) are set against the meat wholesaler’s price overcharges: claim the net, or the supplier will. The waste contractor has already credited £29. The credit notes would add £1,051 of VAT, and the VAT you reclaimed falls by the same, so the gain is the ex-VAT figure.
| Supplier | Item | Agreed price | Basis | Price in force | Period |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Meat wholesaler | Diced beef per kg | £8.40 | Fixed | £8.40 | 01 Jan 2026 to 31 Dec 2026 Rolls on same terms |
| Meat wholesaler | Minced beef 15% fat per kg | £6.10 | Fixed | £6.10 | 01 Jan 2026 to 31 Dec 2026 Rolls on same terms |
| Meat wholesaler | Diced chicken thigh per kg | £5.20 | Fixed | £5.20 | 01 Jan 2026 to 31 Dec 2026 Rolls on same terms |
| Packaging supplier | CPET ready-meal tray per each | £0.1220 | Index-linked · cap 4% | £0.1269 | 01 Apr 2026 to 31 Mar 2027 Rolls on same terms |
| Packaging supplier | Lidding film per roll | £46.50 | Fixed | £46.50 | 01 Apr 2026 to 31 Mar 2027 Rolls on same terms |
| Haulier | Pallet delivery per pallet | £36.50 | Fixed · fuel 8% | £36.50 | 01 Jan 2026 to 31 Dec 2026 Rolls on same terms |
| Energy supplier | Electricity per kWh | £0.2480 | Fixed | £0.2480 | 01 Oct 2025 to 30 Sep 2027 Rolls on same terms |
| Energy supplier | Standing charge per day | £4.20 | Fixed | £4.20 | 01 Oct 2025 to 30 Sep 2027 Rolls on same terms |
| Waste contractor | General waste 1100L lift per lift | £14.50 | Fixed | £14.50 | 01 Feb 2026 to 31 Jan 2028 Rolls on same terms |
| Waste contractor | Food waste 240L lift per lift | £6.80 | Fixed | £6.80 | 01 Feb 2026 to 31 Jan 2028 Rolls on same terms |
| Cleaning contractor | Night hygiene clean per month | £6,850.00 | Fixed | £6,850.00 | 01 Jan 2026 to 31 Dec 2026 Rolls on same terms |
| Cleaning contractor | Sanitiser 5L per each | £12.75 | Fixed | £12.75 | 01 Jan 2026 to 31 Dec 2026 Rolls on same terms |
| Staffing agency | Production operative per hour | £15.20 | Fixed | £15.20 | 01 Apr 2026 to 31 Mar 2027 Rolls on same terms |
| Staffing agency | Hygiene operative per hour | £15.90 | Fixed | £15.90 | 01 Apr 2026 to 31 Mar 2027 Rolls on same terms |
| IT and phones provider | Managed IT support per user a month | £48.00 | Fixed | £48.00 | 01 Jun 2023 to 31 May 2026 Ends: renegotiate |
| IT and phones provider | Phone line per line a month | £9.50 | Fixed | £9.50 | 01 Jun 2023 to 31 May 2026 Ends: renegotiate |
The tray price is index-linked with a 4% cap on each April review. The index rose 5.0%, so the agreed price is £0.1269, not the £0.1281 billed.
| Supplier | Invoice | Item | Issue | Amount |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Haulier | HL-5209A 05 Jun 2026 | Pallet delivery | Possible duplicate | £2,442 |
| IT and phones provider | IT-1502 01 Jun 2026 | Managed IT support | After the agreement ended: renegotiate | £490 |
| IT and phones provider | IT-1503 01 Jul 2026 | Managed IT support | After the agreement ended: renegotiate | £490 |
| IT and phones provider | IT-1504 01 Aug 2026 | Managed IT support | After the agreement ended: renegotiate | £490 |
| IT and phones provider | IT-1505 01 Sep 2026 | Managed IT support | After the agreement ended: renegotiate | £490 |
| Meat wholesaler | MW-4114 10 Jul 2026 | Diced beef | Price above agreed | £423 |
| Meat wholesaler | MW-4117 31 Jul 2026 | Diced beef | Price above agreed | £423 |
| Meat wholesaler | MW-4120 21 Aug 2026 | Diced beef | Price above agreed | £423 |
The haulier’s invoice HL-5209A has the same number as HL-5209 bar the suffix, the same date and the same amounts. Until the delivery notes for that week confirm there was only one load, it counts at a 50% chance. 337 lines repeat three or more times: a duplicate among them shows up only by its invoice number, so check those suppliers’ statements.
| Action | Plan | First-year value | First-year cost | First-year net | Value a year after |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Claim the diced-beef rise and the rebate shortfall Recovery claim · Meat wholesaler · 72% chance | Do | £7,455 | £180 | £7,275 | – |
| Claim the uncapped index rise on trays Recovery claim · Packaging supplier · 75% chance | Do | £714 | £90 | £624 | – |
| Claim the duplicate invoice, the admin fees and the fuel surcharge above 8% Recovery claim · Haulier · 50% chance | Do | £1,705 | £90 | £1,615 | – |
| Claim the extra lifts billed Recovery claim · Waste contractor · 70% chance | Do | £102 | £45 | £57 | – |
| Claim the sanitiser line total Recovery claim · Cleaning contractor · 90% chance | Do | £54 | £23 | £32 | – |
| Claim the early-payment discount not given Recovery claim · Staffing agency · 30% chance | Do | £207 | £45 | £162 | – |
| Load every agreed price into the accounts system and hold invoices that don't match Control · Best practice · 40% chance | Do | £2,021 | £1,800 | £221 | £2,310 |
| Three-way match: order, signed delivery note or timesheet, invoice Control · Best practice · 40% chance | Do | £49 | £2,070 | −£2,021 | £56 |
| Diary of contract ends, price reviews, rebate years and discount dates Control · Best practice · 40% chance | Do | £1,785 | £405 | £1,380 | £2,040 |
| Pay the agency within 14 days to take the 1.5% discount Control · Own records or a trial · 60% chance | Do | £2,898 | £315 | £2,583 | £3,312 |
| E-invoicing with automatic matching Control · Hunch · 20% chance | Park | – | – | – | – |
Each control is credited only with the kinds of leakage it stops. The three-way match only catches quantities here, so it costs more than it saves in year one: keep it if the waste and agency volumes grow, or park it. Claim politely and in writing, with the agreement and the invoice lines attached; keep paying the undisputed part of each invoice on time. 18 months: test needed. Enter the agreements that covered them (7 suppliers have none on file that far back), then export and test those invoices; nothing is counted until then.
Every line is tested against the agreement in force on its invoice date, as entered on Agreements (index-linked prices from the Indices sheet, capped where the agreement says; an agreement that rolls on keeps its price; after one that ends, a rise is for renegotiating, not claiming); price differences under 0.5% and lines in a different unit are not counted, and undercharges are set against price overcharges. Possible duplicates match on supplier, item, quantity and amount with the same invoice number (ignoring suffixes) or within 5 days, and at lower confidence within 60 days when closer than the item’s usual billing interval; unchecked ones count at 50%. Recovery counts at assumed chances by kind (75% a written price, 30% a discount not given), within 6 years (Limitation Act 1980; not legal advice). The yearly leakage takes price drift and surcharges at each supplier’s latest month, and leaves one-offs out; the controls are credited only with the kinds they stop, after the 50% that stops anyway once claims are raised, at assumed chances. Lines without an agreement are not tested.
The chances that claims succeed, the share of leakage that stops anyway and the controls’ chances are assumptions, set on Inputs. The haulier’s agreement limits disputes to 90 days, so its older lines may be harder to recover. This is not legal or tax advice: for a disputed claim of any size, take advice from a solicitor, and ask your accountant about VAT.
Fictional, continuing the example. After the check, Saltercombe chose the guided route and set up an agent in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to its accounts system and the invoice inbox (its IT confirmed this before it committed). Every Friday (every 7 days, the owner's setting on Inputs) it tests the week's new invoice lines against the agreements on file, with the same rules as the check, and logs what it finds on the Agent sheet. When one supplier's new overcharges pass £25 (the owner's figure on Inputs), it drafts a claim. The owner approves every claim. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it.
| Date | What the agent flagged | What was decided |
|---|---|---|
| 16 Oct Flag | Diced beef still billed at £8.85 a kg against the agreed £8.40 on invoice MW-4128: £405 over on 900 kg. | The owner approved adding the lines to the meat wholesaler claim and sent it on 19 October. |
| 30 Oct Flag | The haulier still charging 9% fuel and the £15 admin fee on invoice HL-5230: £36.90 over the rate card. | The owner approved adding it to the haulier claim. The haulier confirmed 8% and no fee from its next invoice. |
| 6 Nov No flag | Diced beef back at £8.40 on invoice MW-4131, and a credit note for the price lines claimed. | The finance manager entered the credit on Suppliers. The rebate part of the claim is still open. |
| 6 Nov Flag | Three agreements end on 31 December: the meat price schedule, the haulier rate card and the cleaning contract. | The owner asked each supplier for its 2027 prices in writing. New rows go on Agreements when they arrive. |
| 20 Nov Flag | 32 general-waste lifts billed on invoice WS-3333 against 30 on the driver tickets: £29 over. | Not claimed. The finance manager found the two extra lifts were ordered by phone for the Christmas run. |
| 4 Dec No flag | The first IT invoice under the new agreement, IT-1508, billed at the agreed £55 a user. | None needed. The owner had renegotiated from the £62 billed after the old agreement ended. |
By early December the two largest leaks the check found had stopped at source: diced beef was billed at the agreed price from 6 November, and the haulier at 8% with no admin fee. At the check's volumes the diced-beef rise alone was running at about £19,400 a year (from the check above), so the agent's part was catching the October lines and confirming the correction held. One flag was not claimed, because the extra lifts were genuine: the agent drafts, and people check the evidence and decide. The rebate shortfall is still open. The agent reminds the owner at each run until the credit is entered, and will warn 60 days before the 31 March 2027 claim deadline. Reading the flags and approving drafts took the finance manager about 15 minutes a week (estimate). The full check is rerun in April on a fresh six months. The months after add nothing to the figures above.