Contract cleaning, washroom services and window cleaning for offices, schools, healthcare premises and public buildings across the East Midlands, from Derby. 165 staff. All values ex VAT.
Verdict: Over the last 2.5 years you bid for 40 tenders and won 30% of those decided (22% by value), at £11,939 of bid time and cash a win; each bid hour won £250 of gross profit for the £42 it cost. You won 44% when you knew the buyer and 16% when you didn’t. Of the 10 tenders due, bid for 6, using 425 of 450 bid hours, for an expected net of £119,641 after mobilisation (£72,224 to £167,057 across the range of win chances; £77,838 in the cautious case); decline 4 tenders; 410 hours freed. Of the recommended bid hours, 310 fall due in the next 30 days against about 150 available: find the hours now or drop the weakest. 4 recommended bids involve TUPE (or may): check the staff, pensions and liabilities before pricing. The win chances you gave past bids ran 12 points above what you won: trust the record over the feel. Bidding for everything shows £131,174 on paper but needs 835 bid hours (385 more than you have) and includes 1 you couldn’t deliver. Best for the bid hours: “Logistics company headquarters”.
Wrenmoor wins 44% (18 bids) against 16% (19 bids): knowing the buyer before the tender is worth more than anything in the bid itself. Rebids for contracts it held: 67% (3 bids) against 26% (34 bids). Its four framework bids won nothing; it won 17% (12 bids) against 29% (17 bids) on price-led tenders against quality-led ones, and it lost one bid where its price was the lowest. Where the scores are known, it lost by 8.3 points behind on average (22 bids); 7 within 5 points. The win chances it gave bids at the time: 51% expected, 39% won (18 decided bids). Withdrawn bids count in the costs, not the rates.
| Tender | Win chance (range) | Expected gross profit | Bid cost | Expected mobilisation | Expected net | Net per bid hour | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Logistics company headquarters Private · office cleaning · £180,000 a year for 3 years · TUPE: no · 50 bid hours, due in 21 days Own record 71% of the weight (9 bids knew and shaped alike, 5 also same buyer type); rest overall × assumed adjustments | 65% 51%–78% | £41,915 | £2,300 | £3,881 | £35,734 | £715 | Bid |
| Science park offices and labs Private · office cleaning · £150,000 a year for 3 years · capacity: partly · TUPE: yes · 70 bid hours, due in 40 days Own record 71% of the weight (9 bids knew and shaped alike, 5 also same buyer type); rest overall × assumed adjustments | 65% 51%–78% | £34,929 | £3,340 | £4,528 | £27,061 | £387 | Bid |
| County council offices, Lot 3 Public · office cleaning · £95,000 a year for 3 years · we hold it now · TUPE: no · 60 bid hours, due in 25 days Own record 73% of the weight (9 bids knew and shaped alike, 6 also same buyer type); 3 rebids and the assumed uplift; rest overall × assumed adjustments | 54% 39%–69% | £18,357 | £2,670 | £0 | £15,687 | £261 | Bid |
| Private hospital group, 2 sites Private · healthcare cleaning · £260,000 a year for 3 years · TUPE: yes · 80 bid hours, due in 18 days Own record 81% of the weight (18 bids knew and shaped alike, 5 also same buyer type); rest overall × assumed adjustments | 20% 9%–31% | £22,863 | £3,660 | £1,599 | £17,604 | £220 | Bid |
| Academy trust, 12 schools Public · schools cleaning · £420,000 a year for 4 years · TUPE: yes · 120 bid hours, due in 30 days Own record 88% of the weight (18 bids knew and shaped alike, 13 also same buyer type); rest overall × assumed adjustments | 15% 8%–23% | £29,256 | £5,640 | £2,322 | £21,294 | £177 | Bid |
| Housing association windows Public · window and high-level · £60,000 a year for 3 years · TUPE: not known · 45 bid hours, due in 33 days Own record 21% of the weight (1 bids knew and shaped alike, 1 also same buyer type); rest overall × assumed adjustments | 22% 8%–36% | £4,795 | £2,090 | £444 | £2,261 | £50 | Bid |
| Primary schools federation, 4 schools Public · schools cleaning · £85,000 a year for 3 years · TUPE: yes · 70 bid hours, due in 14 days Own record 88% of the weight (18 bids knew and shaped alike, 13 also same buyer type); rest overall × assumed adjustments | 15% 8%–23% | £4,737 | £3,190 | £619 | £927 | £13 | Consider |
| NHS trust community clinics Public · healthcare cleaning · £350,000 a year for 5 years · capacity: no · TUPE: yes · 140 bid hours, due in 28 days Own record 88% of the weight (18 bids knew and shaped alike, 13 also same buyer type); rest overall × assumed adjustments | 15% 8%–23% | £29,256 | £6,680 | £1,858 | £20,718 | £148 | No bid |
| Retail park washrooms Private · washrooms and hygiene · £40,000 a year for 2 years · TUPE: yes · 40 bid hours, due in 10 days Own record 81% of the weight (18 bids knew and shaped alike, 5 also same buyer type); rest overall × assumed adjustments | 20% 9%–31% | £2,158 | £1,830 | £400 | −£71 | −£2 | No bid |
| Regional facilities framework, cleaning lot Public · office cleaning · £1,200,000 a year for 4 years · framework, 4 suppliers on the lot · capacity: partly · TUPE: not known · 160 bid hours, due in 35 days Own record 88% of the weight (18 bids knew and shaped alike, 13 also same buyer type); 4 framework bids; rest overall × assumed adjustments | 10% 2%–19% | £4,179 | £14,220 | £0 | −£10,041 | −£63 | No bid |
The regional framework’s £1.2m a year headline counts at 30% called off, shared between 4 suppliers on the lot, and 60 hours a year of mini-competitions: at Wrenmoor’s framework record it no longer covers the cost of bidding. The NHS clinics need a clinical-cleaning capability Wrenmoor doesn’t have, and the retail park washrooms don’t cover their bid and mobilisation costs. The primary schools federation pays a little but doesn’t fit the hours. The science park is recommended but can only partly be delivered, and four of the recommended bids involve TUPE or may: ask for the employee liability information before pricing. The housing association windows win chance rests mostly on assumptions: read its range, not its middle.
| Expected gross profit | Bid and mobilisation | Expected net | Bid hours | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The recommended bids | £152,114 | £32,473 | £119,641 | 425 of 450 |
| The recommended bids, across the range of win chances (±1 standard error) | – | – | £72,224 to £167,057 | 425 of 450 |
| The recommended bids, cautious case (win chances × 70%) | £106,480 | £28,641 | £77,838 | 425 of 450 |
| Bidding for everything | £192,444 | £61,270 | £131,174 | 835 of 450 |
Bidding for everything needs 835 hours against 450: the extra would come from people running contracts, and it includes a contract Wrenmoor couldn’t deliver. Net per bid hour: £282 against £157. Of the recommended bid hours, 310 fall due in the next 30 days, against about 150 hours a month: find the time now, or drop the weakest of the early ones.
Win rates come from your own 37 decided bids over 2.5 years (withdrawn bids count in the costs, not the rates). Each group’s own rate is blended with the wider estimate, own rate × n ÷ (n + 8), starting from your overall rate × assumed adjustments (knew the buyer ×1.50 or ×0.75; specification shaped ×1.40 or ×0.85; public ×0.90, private ×1.15; a rebid ×1.50), with no chance above 80%; the low–high range is ±1 standard error. Expected gross profit = value a year ex VAT × the first year plus 50% of later years × margin (18% unless set) × win chance, with frameworks at 30% of headline value (assumed) shared between the suppliers on the lot; less the bid cost (bid time at £42 an hour, cash and framework mini-competitions) and mobilisation × win chance. Your record guides, it doesn’t forecast: buyers, rivals and the rules under the Procurement Act 2023 change. Not legal advice.
The ranges are wide because the groups are small: the logistics headquarters’ 65% is more honestly somewhere from 51% to 78%. Ask for feedback after every result: under the Procurement Act 2023 public buyers give each bidder an assessment summary, and private buyers will usually talk if asked. Add each result to Past bids, and re-run the decision every quarter.
Fictional, continuing the example: every tender, buyer, person and date is invented, and Wrenmoor's people are named by role. The log is on the Agent sheet of the worked-example workbook (a sample of its rows). The two new tenders were scored by rerunning this workbook's own model with each one added to Upcoming.
After the decision, Wrenmoor chose the guided route and set up the agent in the final session, in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to the bid inbox where its tender alerts, results and feedback arrive (its IT confirmed this before it committed). Each working morning it reads new notices for Wrenmoor's types of work worth at least £40,000 a year, scores each against the record with the existing Inputs, and writes a one-page brief to the week's shared drafts document: the win chance and its range, the expected net, where it ranks against the quarter's list within the 425 of 450 bid hours already taken, and the answers it proposed from Wrenmoor's records for the bid manager to confirm. For each result it drafts the Past bids row and a feedback request. The managing director decided every bid; the bid manager confirmed every row and sent every note. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it.
| Date | What the agent scored, drafted or flagged | Decided by | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 20 Oct Flag | New tender: City council civic buildings, £260,000 a year ex VAT (the notice's £936,000 over 3 years includes VAT). Scored at a 15% win chance (8% to 23%), £8,341 expected net, £83 a bid hour: Consider, as the quarter's hours are taken. | Managing director | No bid. The bid manager sent the decline the agent drafted and asked to hear about the council's next market engagement. |
| 28 Oct Flag | Pipeline notice: an NHS trust will tender cleaning for 9 health centres in February 2027, with a market engagement event on 18 November. | Managing director | Attend. The operations director went on 18 November and met the trust's estates manager. |
| 4 Nov Flag | New tender: Business park managing agent, 6 office buildings, where Wrenmoor knew the managing agent’s facilities manager. Scored at 39% (24% to 53%), £10,056 expected net, £223 a bid hour: Bid, which moves the housing association windows (£50 a bid hour) to Consider. | Managing director | Bid for the business park and drop the windows bid. The bid manager confirmed the proposed answers and added the row to Upcoming. |
| 5 Nov No flag | Decline drafted to the housing association for the windows tender. | Bid manager | Sent, with thanks and an offer to talk before the next one. |
| 23 Nov No flag | Result: Logistics company headquarters won. Past bids row and a feedback request drafted. | Bid manager | Row confirmed and added; feedback call held on 30 November. |
| 1 Dec Flag | Result: Private hospital group lost, 78% against the winner's 83%, price rank 3. Past bids row and a feedback request drafted. | Bid manager | Row confirmed and added; feedback call booked for 8 December. |
At the check-in on 18 November, 30 days after the agent's first morning run, Geoff and the managing director read the log together in Wrenmoor's own account, and Geoff's upkeep of the set-up ended. In the weeks shown, two tenders arrived between quarterly reruns and were decided within a day of their briefs: one declined early, before any bid hours went on it, and one taken in place of a weaker bid. The pipeline notice put Wrenmoor in the room before the specification is written. Both results went into Past bids within a day, so the next quarterly rerun starts from a fuller record. Reading the briefs and confirming the rows took the bid manager about 20 minutes a week (estimate). The months after add nothing to the figures above: the expected nets stay what the decision worked out.