Structural engineering consultancy that surveys, assesses and strengthens existing buildings (offices, mills, schools, warehouses) so they can be reused, extended or converted, for developers, owners and architects across the South West and South Wales, from offices in Gloucester. 38 staff.
Verdict: The point of view: We think most buildings that get knocked down could have been kept: survey early, bring the engineer in at the start, and reuse can cost less and take less time. It rests on 3 themes, 3 of them with enough usable evidence (7 items usable, 1 on hold); 0 of 7 points in the narrative rest on evidence and the rest are worded as opinion. The calendar counts 74 pieces over 12 months from 3 spokespeople (8 more pitched), ramping up from 1.0 a month, using 42% of the hours they have with review and reply time, with no month over capacity; every claim uses approved wording on usable evidence. 3 of 3 profiles are rewritten to the checklist (2.0 items before, 9.0 after, scored by people who didn't write them). Measure later: 24.3% (34 of 140 commissions in 12 months; give or take 7.2 points); background 30.0% (27 of 90 other commissions). By the re-measure the main measure can show direction only; the content-seen share direction only; invitations direction only; messages direction only. To cover the cost in full, the content-seen share would have to rise by 5.8 points (3.3% to 9.1%). No: a change that just pays its way is smaller than what chance could do (10.1 points). Illustration only: £28,420 a year if it reached 10%, not a forecast. Early read 31 Jan 2027; measure again 2 May 2027.
“We think most buildings that get knocked down could have been kept: survey early, bring the engineer in at the start, and reuse can cost less and take less time.”
3 themes; 3 with at least 2 usable evidence items, one of them factual; 0 of 7 points in the narrative rest on evidence, the rest are worded as opinion. Each view and so what is worded as opinion unless it links usable evidence for its theme; general claims never rest on selected case studies or testimonials.
| Theme | The belief we challenge | Our view, and so what for buyers | The strongest objection | Usable evidence | Pieces counted |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| T1 · Keep it standing lead: Managing director | Old buildings have to come down to meet today's standards. | We think most can be kept and strengthened: what decides it is what the survey finds, not the building's age. So what: In our view, owners and developers get usable space sooner and keep the frame they've already paid for. | Objection: Retrofit hides surprises that blow the budget. Our answer: That's an argument for surveying early, not for demolishing: open up the riskiest spots before the design is fixed (theme 2). | 3 (2 factual) | 25 |
| T2 · Survey before you draw lead: Principal engineer | Intrusive surveys are a cost to keep down until planning is through. | In our view, opening up the building early is the cheapest risk reduction on a reuse project. So what: We think it means fewer surprises once the contractor is on site, and a price the client can trust. | Objection: Clients won't pay to open up a building they don't own yet. Our answer: Target a few openings at the riskiest spots; access can usually be agreed with the seller before exchange. | 2 (2 factual) | 25 |
| T3 · Engineer at the table from day one lead: Associate director | The engineer comes in once the architect's scheme is fixed. | We believe bringing the engineer in at feasibility saves redesign and keeps more of the existing building. So what: In our experience, architects and clients avoid redrawing schemes the structure can't carry. | Objection: Paying engineering fees before the scheme is certain. Our answer: In our view, a short feasibility review costs a fraction of one redesign. | 2 (2 factual) | 24 |
| ID | Theme | Kind | Approved wording (said word for word wherever it is used) | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| E1 | T1 | Own data all in the period | “Of the 64 feasibility studies we completed from January 2022 to June 2026, 41 recommended keeping and strengthening the existing frame.” | Usable |
| E2 | T1 | Case study selected | “We converted a 1960s concrete office block in Cheltenham into 46 flats, keeping the frame and adding two storeys.” | Usable |
| E3 | T2 | Own data all in the period | “On the 23 reuse projects since 2023 where we opened up the building before design, structural variations averaged 2.1% of the contract sum, against 6.4% on the 17 where we didn't. The projects differed in other ways too, so this doesn't show that opening up caused the difference.” | Usable |
| E4 | T2 | Case study selected | “At a Victorian mill in Stroud, trial pits and core samples taken before design found corroded beam ends, so the repair was priced into the contract rather than found on site.” | Usable |
| E5 | T3 | Own data all in the period | “Redesign hours averaged 46 on schemes where we joined after the planning drawings, against 12 where we joined at feasibility (our timesheets, 2022 to 2026). The schemes differed in other ways too, so this doesn't show that joining early caused the difference.” | Usable |
| E6 | T3 | Client testimonial selected | "Having the engineer in the first meeting saved us redrawing the scheme twice." An architect client. | Hold: needs the client's permission (CAP Code 3.47, 3.50; in writing, house policy) |
| E7 | T1 | Our experience not applicable | “In our experience, the deciding factor is usually the condition of the connections, not the age of the frame.” | Usable |
| E8 | T3 | Case study selected | “On a secondary school extension, joining at feasibility let the new floor sit on the existing columns.” | Usable |
Own data, case studies and published research are objective claims: the evidence is on file before they are published (CAP Code 3.7 where the Code applies, a house standard everywhere else). Comparisons say they don't show cause. A case study naming a client, or a client's testimonial, needs the client's permission (3.47, 3.50; asked in writing, as house policy); the architect's testimonial stays out of every piece until it's given. "Our experience" is said as opinion. Not legal advice.
By channel: networking site post 59; newsletter 12; trade press 2; podcast guest 1. 8 more are pitched to editors and hosts and count only once accepted. Every piece maps to a theme and an audience its channel reaches; the 15 in the plan that make a claim about the firm's work each use a usable evidence item for their theme in its approved wording; the one paid placement is labelled as an advertisement feature (CAP Code 2.1, 2.4).
| Month | Who | Format | Theme | Topic |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 2026 accepted | Principal engineer | Trade press comment | T3 | Architects and engineers: the first conversation |
| Jan 2027 pitched | Managing director | Trade press article | T2 | What a desk study can't tell you |
| Jan 2027 accepted | Associate director | Podcast guest | T2 | Survey early: a checklist for developers |
| Feb 2027 pitched | Principal engineer | Podcast guest | T1 | What a keep-or-replace decision should be based on |
| Mar 2027 pitched | Managing director | Talk or panel | T3 | Joining late: what it means for everyone |
| Apr 2027 pitched | Associate director | Trade press article | T1 | What reuse means for the programme |
| Jun 2027 pitched | Principal engineer | Trade press comment | T1 | How often our feasibility studies recommend keeping the frame evidence E1 |
| Jul 2027 pitched | Managing director | Trade press article | T1 | The questions a developer should ask an engineer about reuse |
| Jul 2027 pitched | Associate director | Talk or panel | T3 | What clients get from an early structural review |
| Sep 2027 pitched | Managing director | Podcast guest | T3 | Joining at feasibility on a school project evidence E8 |
| Oct 2027 accepted | Associate director | Trade press article | T2 | What estates managers should know before a survey (advertisement feature, regional business magazine) paid: labelled |
| Month | S1 Managing director | S2 Associate director | S3 Principal engineer | Support |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nov 2026 | 2 · 4.5 of 10 h | 2 · 3 of 9 h | 1 · 1 of 6 h | 2.5 of 16 h |
| Dec 2026 | 2 · 3 of 10 h | 3 · 5.5 of 9 h | 2 · 2.5 of 6 h | 3.25 of 16 h |
| Jan 2027 | 3 · 3 of 10 h | 3 · 6.5 of 9 h | 3 · 5.5 of 6 h | 3.75 of 16 h |
| Feb 2027 | 3 · 5.5 of 10 h | 2 · 3 of 9 h | 2 · 1 of 6 h | 2.75 of 16 h |
| Mar 2027 | 2 · 1 of 10 h | 3 · 5.5 of 9 h | 2 · 3 of 6 h | 2.75 of 16 h |
| Apr 2027 | 2 · 3 of 10 h | 2 · 1 of 9 h | 2 · 3.5 of 6 h | 2.25 of 16 h |
| May 2027 | 3 · 5.5 of 10 h | 2 · 3 of 9 h | 2 · 3 of 6 h | 3.25 of 16 h |
| Jun 2027 | 2 · 3 of 10 h | 3 · 5.5 of 9 h | 2 · 1 of 6 h | 2.75 of 16 h |
| Jul 2027 | 3 · 3 of 10 h | 1 · 0 of 9 h | 3 · 5.5 of 6 h | 2.5 of 16 h |
| Aug 2027 | 3 · 5.5 of 10 h | 2 · 3 of 9 h | 1 · 1 of 6 h | 2.75 of 16 h |
| Sep 2027 | 3 · 3 of 10 h | 3 · 5.5 of 9 h | 2 · 3 of 6 h | 3.25 of 16 h |
| Oct 2027 | 2 · 3 of 10 h | 2 · 7.5 of 9 h | 2 · 3.5 of 6 h | 4.25 of 16 h |
125.5 of 300 hours over the year (42%); person-months over capacity: 0; at 90% or more: 2; over if every pitch were accepted: 0; over the ramp-up: 0. Hours counted include half an hour of review and reply a piece; pitched pieces aren't counted until accepted. The hours a piece are estimates (assumed) on the Inputs sheet; the hours available were agreed with each person. In the first three months each person's pieces stay within what they publish now plus one a month.
| Who | Before | After | In the calendar |
|---|---|---|---|
| S1 Managing director, chartered structural engineer | Managing Director at Stowmarden Structural Engineers 3 of 9 | Managing director, Stowmarden Structural Engineers | Helping developers and owners keep, strengthen and convert existing buildings instead of knocking them down Thinking of demolishing? Send me the address through the contact page on our website and I'll tell you what a first survey would look at. (points to: The contact page on the firm's website) 9 of 9 second scorer 9 | 30 pieces 68 hours |
| S2 Associate director, heritage and conversions | Associate Director | Chartered Engineer | Heritage 2 of 9 | Associate director, Stowmarden Structural Engineers | Structural engineer for conversions and heritage buildings | Working with architects from feasibility Working on a reuse scheme? Message me here to book a 30-minute feasibility conversation before the drawings are fixed. (points to: Direct messages on the networking site, answered by the associate director) 9 of 9 second scorer 8 | 28 pieces 64 hours |
| S3 Principal engineer, surveys and investigations | Engineer 1 of 9 | Principal engineer, Stowmarden Structural Engineers | Surveys and investigations of existing buildings before design Planning a survey? Send me the address through our website's contact page and I'll tell you what we'd open up first. (points to: The contact page on the firm's website) 9 of 9 second scorer 9 | 24 pieces 38.5 hours |
3 of 3 complete; 2.0 items before, 9.0 after; scored by operations director, with finance manager scoring blind; 0 more than 1 item apart. The checklist: who they help, within the limits, the business and what it does up front, the point of view, the customers' words, one call to action that works, no unsupported claim, a current photo, a featured piece.
| Measure | Now | Smallest change it could show by the re-measure (80% power) | What it can show |
|---|---|---|---|
| Main: share of reuse and conversion commissions where we were appointed at feasibility | 24.3% (140 commissions in 12 months; background 30.0%) | 30.0 points, net of the background | Direction only: the target gap is smaller than the smallest change it could show |
| Second: share of new enquiries that saw content (coded blind) | 3.3% (1 of 30 answered; 1 name only, kept apart) | 14.2 points | Direction only: too few content-seen answers to say more |
| Invitations to speak or write | 3 in the same six months a year earlier | a rise of 706% | Direction only: too few invitations to say more |
| Inbound messages from target roles | 16 in 12 weeks | a rise of 475% | Direction only |
| Leading: pieces published a month | 1.0 | – | 6.2 a month counted, ramping up |
Direction only: the target gap is smaller than the smallest change it could show. With about 70 commissions by then, a change under 21.4 points could be chance and the smallest it could show (80% power, net of the background) is 30.0 points; the owner's target of 35% (assumed) is 10.7 points away. The content-seen share is coded blind, with old and new answers mixed and dates hidden; a referral naming a spokesperson is kept apart as "name only". A share can rise just because other enquiries fall, so at each read the weekly rate of content-seen enquiries is compared with the rate of all the others. Invitations are compared with the same calendar months a year earlier (the early read with its own three months); messages are netted against four colleagues whose profiles stay as they are. Before and after is never cause and effect. Nothing was chosen because its numbers were worst.
Cost in full: £24,778 (£3,900 fee ex VAT; £13,896 spokespeople's time, 171 hours at £81.50 with lost fees; £1,140 support; £1,611 monthly reviews; £850 paid placement; £180 travel; £2,445 setting up; £216 counting; £540 outside specialists, paid directly). Fee earners' hours are valued at their fee-earning rate for the half that displaces billable work.
Break-even: To cover the cost in full, the content-seen share would have to rise by 5.8 points (3.3% to 9.1%). No: a change that just pays its way is smaller than what chance could do (10.1 points). Illustration only: £28,420 a year if it reached 10%, not a forecast.
The point of view and themes are the spokespeople's judgement: each point is either linked to usable evidence or worded as opinion. Each theme rests on 2 or more usable evidence items held on file, at least one factual, each in approved wording that every piece and profile says word for word; comparisons are worded so they don't claim cause. Where the CAP Code applies (marketing, including the firm's own posts and paid placements) it is followed (rules 2.1, 2.4, 3.7, 3.47, 3.50); editorial pieces, talks and podcasts may fall outside it, and the same rule on claims applies there as a house standard; not legal advice. The checks catch claims marked as claims, not every claim. The hours a piece are estimates (assumed), with review and reply time; pitched pieces count only once accepted. The profiles are scored by operations director and, blind, by finance manager, neither of whom wrote them. The main measure is the share of 140 commissions over 12 months appointed at feasibility, from the CRM, netted against 90 other commissions; at these volumes it can show direction only. The content-seen share comes from a 6-week tally of 34 enquiries, coded blind, with names alone kept apart; a share can move because other enquiries move, so the weekly rates are compared at each read. Invitations are compared with the same months a year earlier; messages are netted against 4 colleagues whose profiles stay unchanged. Nothing was chosen because its numbers were worst. The targets, the 50% counted as truly extra, the realistic rise, the share of hours that displace fee-earning work and the hours a piece are assumptions; the commissions, enquiries, conversion, gross profit, rates and costs are from the records. The break-even and any £ figure are illustrations, not forecasts.
The programme is finished when it is handed over: the one-page narrative, the 12-month calendar, the profile rewrites and the 30-minute monthly review agenda.
Fictional, continuing the example: every person, piece and date is invented, and Stowmarden's people are named by role. The log is on the Agent sheet of the worked-example workbook (a sample of its rows).
Stowmarden chose the guided route and set up the agent in the final session, in an AI assistant the business already uses, with read access to the workbook, the shared drafts folder and the marketing coordinator's publishing log (its IT confirmed this before it committed). It started at go-live on 2 November. Each Monday it drafts the coming month's pieces 14 days ahead and the pitches 8 weeks ahead, each from its theme, with any claim in its approved wording; it updates Drafted and Published from what people log, and flags a pitch not accepted 21 days before its month: the managing director's settings on Inputs. Every piece went out under a spokesperson's name only after that person approved it, and the marketing coordinator posted and sent each one; the agent never touched the networking site. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it.
| Date | What the agent drafted or flagged | Decided by | What happened |
|---|---|---|---|
| 9 Nov No flag | Drafted the pitch for January's trade press article, the managing director's “What a desk study can't tell you”, 8 weeks before its month. | Managing director | Approved with one change; the marketing coordinator sent it to the developers' trade magazine on 10 November. |
| 9 Nov Flag | The architect's testimonial (E6) was still on hold without permission. Drafted the permission request. | Associate director | Sent on 10 November; written permission came on 20 November and was recorded on Evidence, so E6 became usable. |
| 23 Nov No flag | Drafted December's 7 pieces, each from its theme, with the two claims (E4, E5) in their approved wording. | Each spokesperson | All approved by 27 November; the principal engineer rewrote the opening of his short post. |
| 30 Nov Flag | An edit to the December newsletter dropped “so this doesn't show that joining early caused the difference” from the E5 claim. | Associate director | The approved wording went back in, word for word; the newsletter went out on 7 December. |
| 30 Nov No flag | Monthly review note: November's 5 pieces published as planned, December's 7 approved, no month over anyone's hours, January's pitch awaiting a reply. | Managing director | No changes at the 2 December review. |
| 14 Dec Flag | January's trade press pitch still not accepted 18 days before its month, inside the 21 days set. | Managing director | Offer it to the regional business magazine; if neither accepts by 4 January, move it to March. |
At the check-in on 2 December, 30 days after go-live and straight after the first monthly review, Geoff and the managing director read the log together in Stowmarden's own account, and Geoff's upkeep of the set-up ended. In those weeks every piece went out in its month, one claim was kept to its approved wording after an edit had turned a comparison into a claim of cause, and a testimonial became usable with the client's written permission. Because the monthly note reports each named spokesperson's pieces against the plan, Stowmarden told the three of them what it reports and updated its staff privacy notice before go-live. Reading the note and the drafts took the marketing coordinator about 30 minutes a week, and each spokesperson about 15 minutes a month on their drafts (estimate). The months after add nothing to the value case above: the early read on 31 January and the re-measure in May are still taken by the people named, the same way.