Paid Advertising Wasted Spend Audit · October 2026

Tolverne Commercial Cleaning Ltd

Office, industrial and specialist cleaning contracts for businesses across Bristol, Bath and Swindon. 140 staff. Google Ads (Search, Performance Max, Display), 1 Jul 2026 to 28 Sep 2026.

Worked example. Tolverne Commercial Cleaning is fictional; every name and figure is invented. All figures come from the worked-example spreadsheet: ALL CHECKS PASSED (with 3 notes): tracking that over-counts, a search term still to decide, and segments to look at.
The headline

The advertising pays. A quarter of it doesn't.

Ad spend
£5,576
a month; £16,500 over 90 days
Gross profit per £1
£3.48
expected from the enquiries your own records confirm, at £638 each
Spend to exclude
£4,390
27% of spend, on searches and placements that bring nothing
Expected saving
£14,424
a year, counting 60% of excluded spend and 40% of over-target spend

Verdict: Make the changes: about £14,424 a year to save, and fix the tracking so the next audit is sharper. Each enquiry is worth about £638 of gross profit and you'll pay up to £160 for one; the account averages £183 on your own count. The waste is not the strategy, it's the leaks: job seekers, homeowners, equipment hire and games apps. Beyond those, £2,307 goes on campaigns paying more per enquiry than it's worth.

Can we trust the numbers?

The platform counts more enquiries than you do

Google Ads recorded 120 conversions. 7 were job applications through the enquiry form, now taken out, leaving 113. Your enquiry log credits paid advertising with 90, so the platform still counts 1.26 times as many; the likeliest cause is calls counted twice. The values in this audit use your count (80% of the platform's). Over-counting hides waste rather than inventing it, so the exclusions are safe to make now; fix the tracking so the next audit is sharper.
Where the money goes

Campaigns

CampaignSpendConversions on your countCost per conversion*To excludeOver target
Brand
Search · brand
£90027£33£95–
Office cleaning
Search
£6,20034£181£1,775–
Industrial cleaning
Search
£3,10011£278£480£842
Specialist cleaning
Search
£1,9005£398£590£548
Performance Max
Performance Max
£2,80010£293£830£446
Display remarketing
Display
£1,6003£502£620£472

Red = above the £160 most you'll pay. Over target is what a non-brand campaign spends, after exclusions, beyond its conversions at £160 each. Brand searches (30% of conversions) would mostly find you anyway. *Cost per conversion on your own count, before exclusions, so a campaign can be red here and on target once its leaks are switched off. £3,567 of spend went on searches and placements too small to list, or that the platform doesn't show.

What to switch off

20 searches and placements, £4,390

WhySearch terms and placementsConversionsSpend
Homeownersdomestic cleaner bristol, window cleaner near me, end of tenancy cleaning bristol, oven cleaning0£1,080
Accidental taps in a gameMobile app: puzzle game, Mobile app: word puzzle, Mobile app: casual games0£990
Job seekerscleaning jobs bristol, office cleaning jobs, warehouse jobs bristol, tolverne cleaning jobs7£915
Not our audienceFree online games site, Video: children's cartoons channel, Recipe website0£460
Buying products, not a serviceindustrial cleaning chemicals, cleaning supplies wholesale0£370
Hiring equipmentcarpet cleaning machine hire, pressure washer hire0£260
Outside our areacleaning company cardiff0£230
Looking for advice, not a contractorhow to clean office carpets0£85

Kept or still to decide:

Segments to look at (these overlap the campaigns, so they are not added in):

The plan

What changes, who and when

ByActionOwnerHours
16 Oct 2026Add the excluded search terms as negative keywords; shared lists for jobs, homes, products and equipment hire
Exclusions
Marketing manager2
16 Oct 2026Exclude games apps, children's video and other off-audience placements in Performance Max and Display
Placements
Marketing manager1
16 Oct 2026Target people in Bristol, Bath and Swindon only, not people interested in them; exclude Cardiff
Locations
Marketing manager0.5
23 Oct 2026Weekend bids down 30%; review after 30 days
Bids and budgets
Marketing manager1
30 Oct 2026Count each call once and only over 60 seconds; take the careers form out of conversions
Tracking
Web agency3
13 Nov 2026Give job seekers a careers page so they stop using the enquiry form
Landing pages
Web agency4
13 Nov 2026Review search terms, placements and this audit every month
Routine
Marketing manager2
How confident are we?

What this rests on

Spend, clicks and conversions are the ad platform's own figures for 90 days. A conversion is worth £638 of gross profit, from your own figures, and you will pay up to £160 for one. Items to exclude are your decisions, item by item; conversions on them are taken out (job applications, for example). Where the platform counts more conversions than your records, values use your records' count (80% of the platform's). Over-target spend is what each non-brand campaign spends, after exclusions, beyond its conversions at that price: an average, so poor search terms inside a good campaign are not in it. The saving assumes you keep 60% of excluded spend and 40% of over-target spend, scaled from one period to a year with no allowance for seasons. Segments overlap the campaigns and are not added in.

The months after

What the agent flagged, and what was decided

At handover the marketing manager loaded the exclusion lists, and the web agency was booked to fix the call tracking. The agent was then set up in Tolverne's own AI assistant account, with read-only access to the Google Ads reports and the enquiry log. Every Monday at 7:00 it reruns the audit on the latest 90 days, ending two weeks before the run so late enquiries are in, in a new dated copy, runs the checks and sends the managing director a short note. It uses the rules on Inputs: £160 the most Tolverne will pay for an enquiry, one enquiry's worth of spend with no conversions before an item needs a decision, a 20% tracking tolerance and a 20% rise in a campaign's cost per conversion. It never changes the ad account. Nothing left Tolverne, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it. These events continue the fictional example.

Weekly runs
13
19 October to 11 January
Flags raised
5
the other runs sent the weekly note only
Exclusions not applied
26 Oct
caught ten days after they were due
Changes made to the ad account by the agent
0
every change was made by a person
DateWhat the agent foundFlag?What people decided
26 OctTwo job-seeker search terms decided Exclude were still spending: £64 in the week to 25 October, after the exclusions were due on 16 October.FlagThe marketing manager found the shared negative list had not been applied to the Office cleaning campaign, and applied it. Spend on both stopped the next day.
2 NovTracking moved further from the enquiry log: the platform's conversions that count were 1.31 times Tolverne's own count, against 1.26 at the audit and a 20% tolerance.FlagThe managing director chased the web agency, which fixed the call counting and took the careers form out of conversions on 4 November.
16 NovTwo new search terms, 'cleaning franchise opportunities' and 'commercial cleaning apprenticeship', had spent £353 with no conversions, each above the £160 threshold. The agent marked them Review.FlagThe marketing manager excluded both and added the words to the shared job-seeker list.
23 NovA campaign renamed in Google Ads no longer matched the older rows. Checks showed CHECK, so the note reported a data problem and no figures.FlagThe marketing manager used the new name on both sheets. The rerun passed the same morning.
7 DecIndustrial cleaning's cost per enquiry rose to £352, 27% above the audit's £278, with two new advertisers on its main search term.FlagThe managing director held the budget and asked for a landing page test for warehouse managers in January.
11 JanNothing crossed a line. With the tracking fixed, the platform's count was 1.08 times the enquiry log, within the tolerance.Note onlyNothing needed. The managing director read the note.

At the 30-day check-in on 16 November, Geoff and the managing director read the log together. No rule needed changing.

What the agent added. The method is unchanged: same spreadsheet, same checks, same decisions. The agent made sure the audit was rerun every week, not once a quarter. It caught exclusions that had not been applied ten days after they were due, and new wasted search terms within weeks, and it showed when the tracking could be trusted again. The benefit here is that the audit's savings held; no new £ figure is claimed for it.

Fictional and labelled: these events continue the worked example. The same six events are the sample rows in the Agent log of the worked-example spreadsheet. The agent is part of the guided and done-for-you routes; the self-implement kit does not include it.