Lapsed Customer Win-Back Plan · October 2026

Brackenmoor Coffee Roasters Ltd

Roasts and supplies coffee, equipment servicing and barista training to cafés, restaurants and offices across West and North Yorkshire. 24 staff. 214 customers in the export; a customer has lapsed after 4 months without an order.

Worked example. Brackenmoor Coffee Roasters and its customers are fictional; every name and figure is invented. All figures come from the worked-example spreadsheet: ALL CHECKS PASSED (with 3 notes): reasons nobody knows, customers we can't contact, and one reason already blending in its own results.
The headline

£169,873 of gross profit a year walked out. A first round of 30 calls should win back about £4,535.

Lapsed customers
67
34% of customers; they used to buy £404,460 a year, 25% of today's sales
Expected back
4
customers if all 67 are approached, weighted by the chance for each reason and how long they've been gone
Expected gross profit, all approached
£6,138
a year once back, at 60% of their former spend; £4,297 still coming a year later
Cost
£939
of calls, visits and offers: £7 of gross profit for each £1

Most lapsed customers won't come back, and the plan doesn't pretend otherwise. But the approach is cheap: a first round of 30 customers costs about £503 and carries £4,535 of the expected gain. And the biggest single reason they left is unknown: 19 customers stopped and nobody knows why, so the first round includes calls to the 10 most valuable of them simply to ask.

Why they left

Gross profit lost a year, by reason

Unknown19 customers
£38,287a year lost · 10% chance (assumed) · £1,015 expected back
Went to a competitor11 customers
£33,814a year lost · 10% chance (assumed) · £1,203 expected back
Price13 customers
£31,550a year lost · 16% chance (blended with your results) · £1,846 expected back
Service problem10 customers
£30,001a year lost · 20% chance (assumed) · £1,653 expected back
Needs changed6 customers
£19,240a year lost · 5% chance (assumed) · £422 expected back
Closed or moved away8 customers
£16,981a year lost · 0% chance (assumed) · £0 expected back

Learning as you go. Price: 12 approached in a spring trial and 2 came back, so the plan blends that in: 16% instead of the assumed 15%. Twelve approaches is still mostly luck; record every approach on the Reasons sheet and your own rate will carry more weight as they build up.

What we'll do

A different approach for each reason

ReasonApproachOwnerCost to approachOffer per win
UnknownShort call to ask why they stopped; offer a free bag with the next orderAccount manager£8£25
Went to a competitorFree tasting visit with a new seasonal blend; ask what the other roaster does betterSales manager£25£80
PriceCall with a like-for-like price check and a three-month price holdSales manager£12£60
Service problemOwner calls: say what went wrong and what has changed (second van, delivery window)Managing director£15£40
Needs changedEmail the new decaf and oat-milk range; no offerMarketing assistant£2–

Customers who closed or moved away aren't approached. 3 lapsed customers are left out at their own or our request.

Who first

The first round: 20 to win back, 10 to ask

#Customer and reasonLast orderGross profit a year they used to bringChanceExpected gross profitLess the cost
1Ossett Lane Hotel
Price
Mar 2026£4,17516%£399£377
2Wolden Hotel
Service problem
Apr 2026£3,02020%£362£339
3Garsby Coffee House
Price
Dec 2024£5,76210%£330£312
4Cragside Coffee House
Service problem
Sep 2025£3,78812%£273£253
5Ossett Lane Coffee House
Service problem
Jan 2024£6,4856%£233£216
6Moorgate Deli
Price
Nov 2025£2,34416%£224£202
7Netherby Coffee House
Went to a competitor
Jun 2025£5,7206%£206£176
8Lumbfoot Coffee House
Went to a competitor
Feb 2025£5,5826%£201£171
9Pickersgill Bakery
Price
Mar 2026£1,84016%£176£154
10Netherby Hotel
Service problem
Sep 2024£4,4106%£159£141
11Cragside Hotel
Went to a competitor
Jan 2025£4,7466%£171£141
12Ainsty Deli
Went to a competitor
Jan 2026£2,76410%£166£133
13Wexcombe Café
Service problem
Nov 2023£3,9826%£143£126
14Hebble Bistro
Service problem
Nov 2024£1,96112%£141£121
15Holme Bank Hotel
Needs changed
Feb 2026£4,1035%£123£121
16Hesketh Café
Went to a competitor
Mar 2026£2,36910%£142£109
17Skelbrook Deli
Price
Mar 2026£1,36516%£130£109
18Heptonby Hotel
Service problem
Dec 2023£3,2386%£117£99
19Wolden Bistro
Price
Dec 2024£1,88610%£108£90
20Garsby Café
Needs changed
Aug 2025£4,7713%£86£84

Ranked by expected gross profit less the cost of the approach and offer. The chance falls the longer a customer has been gone.

Ask why first (no known reason; gross profit a year they used to bring): Dunnock Coffee House (£4,469), Ellerdyke Café (£4,444), Garsby Hotel (£3,616), Pickersgill Hotel (£3,276), Thrushcross Coffee House (£2,688), Netherby Bistro (£2,512), Calverly Bakery (£2,423), Hebble Bakery (£2,113), Kelda Offices (£1,966), Ashdene Hotel (£1,865).

How confident are we?

What this rests on

Customers, dates and sales come from your records; a customer has lapsed after 4 months without an order, and those gone more than 36 months are left out. Why each stopped comes from your team; where nobody knows, the reason is Unknown. The chance of winning each back is assumed by reason, scaled down the longer they have been gone, and blended with your own results as approaches are recorded (after 10 approaches, half and half). A customer won back is assumed to return with 60% of their former spend; expected gross profit is a year of that at your 42% margin, less the cost of approaches and offers; about 70% of those won back are assumed to be buying a year later. It is a plan to test, not a forecast: approach the first batch, record what happens, and let the results take over.

The months after

What the agent drafted and flagged from October to November, and what people decided

Fictional, continuing the example: every customer, person and date is invented, and Brackenmoor's people are named by role. The log is on the Agent sheet of the worked-example workbook (a sample of its rows).

Brackenmoor chose the guided route and set up the agent in the final session, in an AI assistant the business already uses, connected read-only to its sales system and CRM (its IT confirmed this before it committed), and updated its privacy notice first, because several of its customers are sole traders. Each Monday it reloads last orders and sales into the workbook, spots customers newly past 4 months without an order, and drafts the approach for each reason from the plan, or an ask-why call where nobody knows, at most 5 for one owner a week. It flags an approach with no reply after 3 weeks and leaves a customer alone for 3 months after an approach: the managing director's settings on Inputs. It drafts an email only where the person's consent is recorded. Each reason's owner made every approach from their own phone or email. Nothing left the business, and no decision changed, without one of its own people approving it.

DateWhat the agent drafted or flaggedDecided byWhat happened
19 Oct
No flag
Drafted the first round's approaches by reason, at most 5 for one owner that week: 17 of the 30, the rest over the next weeks.Each ownerAll 17 made that week; the sales manager rewrote two openings.
19 Oct
Flag
Garsby Café is a sole trader with no marketing consent recorded: held the email about the new range and drafted a letter instead.Marketing assistantLetter approved and posted on 20 October.
26 Oct
No flag
Price: 4 more approached and Moorgate Deli ordered again on 23 October. Contacted and won back updated on Reasons: 16 and 3.Sales managerConfirmed against the call log.
2 Nov
Flag
Ellerdyke Café asked not to be contacted again, on the ask-why call.Managing directorMarked do not contact, with the date in Notes; nothing more drafted.
9 Nov
Flag
Newly lapsed after 4 months without an order: Scarcroft Bistro, Oldacre Hotel and Stainby Coffee House. No reason known, so ask-why call notes drafted.Account managerCalled on 10 and 11 November: a cheaper roaster, a new head chef trying another, a refit until March. Reasons entered.
9 Nov
Flag
Wexcombe Café: no reply 3 weeks after the managing director's letter.Managing directorOne follow-up call, then leave it alone for 3 months.

At the results review on 18 November, a month after the agent's first weekly run, Geoff and the managing director read the log and the first round's results together in Brackenmoor's own account, and Geoff's upkeep of the set-up ended. Three customers who lapsed in early November were asked why within days rather than at the next quarterly rerun, one customer who asked to be left alone was, and Price now rests on 16 approaches rather than 12. Because the agent reviews named customers' buying every week, Brackenmoor also wrote a short data protection impact assessment (not legal advice). Reading the note and approving drafts took the owners about 30 minutes a week between them (estimate). The months after add nothing to the figures above: the expected gains stay what the plan worked out, and the next rerun blends in the results recorded.